ERRORS THREAD Report Errors and Omissions Here

Cover: Per Spjøtvold

Total Time 90:24

Line-up:

Releases Information:

Executive Producer: Arny Schorr

Associate Producer: Bruce Pilato

Executive Archival Producer: David Skye

Producer: 3

Mastering Engineer: Randy Perry

Photography: Drew Minasian, Jacqueline McDonald, Rolf Remlinger, Tony Ortiz

2CD RockBeat Records - ROC-CD-3379 (US, 2017)

Progarchives - https://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=56409

Discogs - https://www.discogs.com/release/11187651-3-2-Keith-Emerson-Carl-Palmer-Robert-Berry-Live-Rockin-The-Ritz

1. Canario (Fantasia Para Un Gentilhombre) (3:57)

2. All I Want Is You (2:33)

Total Time 5:30

Releases Information:

Engineers: Jack Nuber, Karl Pitterson

7" Ariola – 100 238 (Germany, 1978)

Progarchives - https://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=25058

Discogs - https://www.discogs.com/release/1169270-Emerson-Lake-Palmer-Canario

Under Compilation not Studio as "Birds & Passage to the Forest of Mysterious"

The album that Mayer added, called "Birds: Passage to the Forest of Mysterious (24​-​48 Ltd 2CD)" edition did exist on Bandcamp as a pre-order digital release around the turn of the year. This was the summary page of his releases on Bandcamp as captured on 21st December 2022: https://web.archive.org/web/20221221055658/https://antonykalugin.bandcamp.com/music, and that album was the latest release.

Full details of the album as captured on 5th January 2023 here: https://web.archive.org/web/20230105164339/https://antonykalugin.bandcamp.com/album/birds-passage-to-the-forest-of-mysterious-24-48-ltd-2cd-edition.

The pre-order version of the album was removed from Bandcamp however when the final version, "Passage to the Forest of Mysterious" & "Birds" (Hi​-​Res 24​-​48) was released just yesterday.

The Birds: Passage to the Forest of Mysterious (24​-​48 Ltd 2CD edition) IS still available as a LTD edition double CD digipack physical release via Bandcamp though for €17 EUR or more.

The two images are for the "Passage to the Forest of Mysterious" (on the left) & "Birds" (on the right) discs that are included in the package. The original track 9: "Mysterious Forest Fan Bandcamp Preview" (11:11) seems to be have been replaced in the final package (on the "Birds" CD, track 6) by "Birds of Passage and the Enchanted Forest (Single Version)", so that original track will now probably not exist anywhere other than in the homes of those who have already downloaded it.

As for the PA album that Mayer added, and which is also still on RYM, I'd be inclined to replace it with the final release version that's now on Bandcamp, though the track running order seems to be different for the digital album and the physical digipak version.

14th Karfagen album (special edition double CD & digital album):

Digital album:

As for it now being included as a compilation on PA, Antony Kalugin calls it his 14th Karfagen album on his Bandcamp, so I reckon it should really be in the studio albums after all, but that's ultimately for you guys to decide! 

I never looked to see what other albums had recently been added to the Karfagen page on PA, but yes, the album that is being discussed above, Birds and Birds & Passage to the Forest of Mysterious (currently in compilations) and the Birds album in studio releases both have to go, as it seems they were only available temporarily as a stop gap while the Passage To The Forest Of Mysterious & Birds Limited 2CD digipak that we have in studio albums (& currently named just 'Passage to the Forest of Mysterious') was being prepared.

However, the track list as we currently have it on this studio release is not correct, as much confusion exists.

I took the listing in my previous post above from bandcamp, where down towards the bottom of the page it shows:

However, Caerllysi Music's page for the album, which also gives its title as 'Passage To The Forest Of Mysterious & Birds', gives the following (I've rearranged it here into PA format):

Total time 115:56

Caerllysi Music are Antony Kalugin's UK partners, and would be the first to know of any latest news regarding this artist's releases, so I would take this info as gospel. This tracklist is confirmed by the images from the CD package uploaded yesterday to facebook too, though you can't quite make out the exact lettering due to the low quality of the image.

This tracklist also now matches the digital one for the album on Bandcamp too, apart from the absence of track 14, 'Birds Short Introduction' (3:20), which is only available if you purchase the physical CD version.

 

So, in summary, I agree with the above actions, but I'd be inclined to rename the studio album we are keeping as 'Passage To The Forest Of Mysterious & Birds', and to alter its tracklist as discussed above.

Bonus CD from 2013 remaster:

1. 1-2-3-4 (radio version) (2:56)

2. Do You Believe in Magic? (radio version) (3:48)

- Recorded Live November 13, 1971 At Bessunger Turnhalle In Darmstadt, Germany:

3. Good Day (7:59)

4. Odyssee (Da-Da-Dum) (6:38)

5. 1-2-3-4 (13:20)

6. Do You Believe In Magic? (4:53)

7. Odyssee (Ron's On) (10:36)

8. New Day Dawning (7:28)

Releases Information:

2CD Purple Pyramid - CLP 0662 (US, 2013)

Progarchives - https://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=2732

Discogs - https://www.discogs.com/release/5004637-Nektar-Sounds-Like-This

I understand your point of view. But I believe the track-list on the album should reflect the original release, rather than the reissues and remasters that came out after.

In addition, I believe this track-list better represents the artist's original vision for the album. That vision being two long suites, rather than eleven individual tracks divided by two headers. Also, the original pressings of the album show 2 tracks with numerous corresponding sub-tracks (Please see Discogs links below).

To quote Wikipedia, "There are only two songs on the album, one for each side, titled simply "Part One" and "Part Two"."

Wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recycled_(Nektar_album)

Progarchives - https://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=2736