Progarchives.com has always (since 2002) relied on banners ads to cover web hosting fees and all. Please consider supporting us by giving monthly PayPal donations and help keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.
Joined: November 10 2008
Location: __
Status: Offline
Points: 65760
Posted: April 03 2016 at 09:43
A Person wrote:
Disparate Times wrote:
greed that drives innovation
I have never understood this concept.
My thinking is basically that innovation comes from human curiosity and creativity, the economic system merely rewards greed as a motivator to use that creativity, but it is far from the only reason people innovate. If anything, greed in capitalism quashes innovation that doesn't result in profit.
Read a book recently that laid out how so much of the technology we use today, ranging from health to computers, was started by government initiative. Either funding, loans or direct R&D, or even stuff that comes from a result of military...the pieces were there thanks to government and people took them, built stuff with it and run off to a fortune.
Basically: It'd be like someone making a bunch of random metal pieces and individuals technologies, leaving it at a park, then someone comes, takes em and builds a smart phone with it. The author noted this happened far less in Europe, and thus it's not coincidence they have had lower innovation.
So while private enterprise may be a driving factor, perhaps more credit should be given to government which enabled it to happen at all. Also, for those who want lesser government, perhaps we should be wary where those cuts fall.
Joined: November 10 2008
Location: __
Status: Offline
Points: 65760
Posted: May 05 2016 at 10:14
JJLehto wrote:
Funny thing on the note of greed and innovation.
Read a book recently that laid out how so much of the technology we use today, ranging from health to computers, was started by government initiative. Either funding, loans or direct R&D, or even stuff that comes from a result of military...the pieces were there thanks to government and people took them, built stuff with it and run off to a fortune.
Basically: It'd be like someone making a bunch of random metal pieces and individuals technologies, leaving it a park, then someone comes, takes em and builds a smart phone with it. The author noted this happened far less in Europe, and thus it's not coincidence they have had lower innovation.
So while private enterprise may be a driving factor, perhaps more credit should be given to government which enabled it to happen at all. Also, for those who want lesser government, perhaps we should be wary where those cuts fall.
The smartphone thing is a good example, because one of the (more vapid) retorts I see against anti-capitalists is "posted from an iPhone" or some variant. It is funny because internet was a DARPA project, wifi was significantly developed by the Australian government (i think), etc.
Read a book recently that laid out how so much of the technology we use today, ranging from health to computers, was started by government initiative. Either funding, loans or direct R&D, or even stuff that comes from a result of military...the pieces were there thanks to government and people took them, built stuff with it and run off to a fortune.
Basically: It'd be like someone making a bunch of random metal pieces and individuals technologies, leaving it a park, then someone comes, takes em and builds a smart phone with it. The author noted this happened far less in Europe, and thus it's not coincidence they have had lower innovation.
So while private enterprise may be a driving factor, perhaps more credit should be given to government which enabled it to happen at all. Also, for those who want lesser government, perhaps we should be wary where those cuts fall.
The smartphone thing is a good example, because one of the (more vapid) retorts I see against anti-capitalists is "posted from an iPhone" or some variant. It is funny because internet was a DARPA project, wifi was significantly developed by the Australian government (i think), etc.
DARPA is indeed mentioned as well as a bunch of other things. Blanking off the top of my head but it was usually stuff like how company X had a loan early on, how Y's algorithm is thanks to a grant, or research from somewhere. An obvious one is Tesla who had a government loan.
The author wasn't opposed to this btw, she mainly just laid out how it is, and actually advocated the gov taking a more activist role. She did conclude by saying since the gov is such a big investor and many dont often pan out, they should get a piece of successful projects, like directly through owning stock or part of it.
That last part is a matter of personal debate, I'm fine with people running with what the gov may lay down but it was quite interesting, and certainly took a bit of a swing at the Ayn Rand type notion of glorious geniuses who do it all on their own with no help, and free markets being this soup of bubbling brilliance. Again not that there isn't amounts of that or even a motivating factor for people, but we gotta understand the complexity of innovation.
tl;dr Is ProgArchives still an AnCap forum, primarly? Or are there two or three ancaps who are incredibly loud and make everyone think that "ProgArchives is still an AnCap forum, primarly." No, but seriously, in a nutshell, is it?
Categories strain, crack and sometimes break, under their burden - step out of the space provided.
Joined: October 03 2008
Location: Là, sui monti.
Status: Offline
Points: 10841
Posted: June 07 2016 at 10:08
In a nutshell, PA is a left-right-wing anarco-royalist, post-imperialist, post-marxist forum (with some light hints of capitalism, because someone made nice, conmfortable and not too expensive t-shirts and it would be time for all of you to buy them, so M@x could spend his next vacations at Hawaï for one full month).
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
This page was generated in 0.223 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.