Joined: September 20 2010
Location: Serbia
Status: Offline
Points: 10213
Posted: June 25 2013 at 10:16
Dean wrote:
Svetonio wrote:
Dean wrote:
Svetonio wrote:
Dean wrote:
Svetonio wrote:
I agree with Knobby. Many bands have continued with proto sound after 1970, so that we can call these bands proto prog; i.e. the same as we call krautrock a band who released a debut album in 2013 e.g. in Italy.
What makes that Italian band "Krautrock"? Serious question.
Nothing makes it krautrock if you like that, but we still call it krautrock.
So, why we call it krautrock?
There's some reason for that.
Laziness?
Of course not.
Then what is it? Since this theoretic band does not actually exist then there would be some characteristic that makes them more Krautrock than Psych Prog or Advant Prog or Jazz Rock or combinations thereof. If this is so obvious and such a no-brainer that it is a reflex reaction to automatically say "Krautrock" when this ficticious Italian band is first heard then how is this so when there is such diversity in musical styles and directions within the German bands that (unforunately) get dumped into this illnamed catch-all miasma that is laughingly called a "genre" by all except that bands that started it. What are the musical simularities between Can, Amon Düül, Popol Vuh, Faust, Guru Guru (and even Tangerin Dream and Kraftwerk if you're feeling real lazy) that make anyone say that a 2013 band from Italy is Krautrock?
You asked why do we call it Krautrock and I answered - that is the historically accurate reason - laziness - pure unadulterated journalistic laziness ... in the 1970s if it was rock and came from Germany it got called Krautrock by lazy British journalists and ever since then we have invented a "genre" around that zenophobic insult, but its still a lazy generalisation.
Aha.
Well, my answer is that krautrock still exist.
Special Collaborator
Retired Admin and Amateur Layabout
Joined: May 13 2007
Location: Europe
Status: Offline
Points: 37575
Posted: June 25 2013 at 10:24
Svetonio wrote:
Dean wrote:
Svetonio wrote:
Dean wrote:
Svetonio wrote:
Dean wrote:
Svetonio wrote:
I agree with Knobby. Many bands have continued with proto sound after 1970, so that we can call these bands proto prog; i.e. the same as we call krautrock a band who released a debut album in 2013 e.g. in Italy.
What makes that Italian band "Krautrock"? Serious question.
Nothing makes it krautrock if you like that, but we still call it krautrock.
So, why we call it krautrock?
There's some reason for that.
Laziness?
Of course not.
Then what is it? Since this theoretic band does not actually exist then there would be some characteristic that makes them more Krautrock than Psych Prog or Advant Prog or Jazz Rock or combinations thereof. If this is so obvious and such a no-brainer that it is a reflex reaction to automatically say "Krautrock" when this ficticious Italian band is first heard then how is this so when there is such diversity in musical styles and directions within the German bands that (unforunately) get dumped into this illnamed catch-all miasma that is laughingly called a "genre" by all except that bands that started it. What are the musical simularities between Can, Amon Düül, Popol Vuh, Faust, Guru Guru (and even Tangerin Dream and Kraftwerk if you're feeling real lazy) that make anyone say that a 2013 band from Italy is Krautrock?
You asked why do we call it Krautrock and I answered - that is the historically accurate reason - laziness - pure unadulterated journalistic laziness ... in the 1970s if it was rock and came from Germany it got called Krautrock by lazy British journalists and ever since then we have invented a "genre" around that zenophobic insult, but its still a lazy generalisation.
Aha.
Well, my answer is that krautrock still exist.
...for bands that were called Krautrock in the 1970s.
Joined: August 22 2010
Location: Indiana
Status: Offline
Points: 20623
Posted: June 25 2013 at 12:12
It's too bad that so many threads have to degenerate into arguments about what is really what type of music. I fear there are too many hard bolied egos on the forum.
Back to some lp's/tracks that I liked from the old days......to me these are 'proto prog'.
Pussy-Plays
Five Day Rain
East Of Eden-Mercator..
Arcadium-Breathe..
The Gods-Genesis
Mike Stuart Span /Leviathan
One does nothing yet nothing is left undone. Haquin
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
This page was generated in 0.152 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.
/PAlogo_v2.gif "Progarchives.com Homepage")
Favorite Proto-Prog Album
Topic Options
Dean wrote:
