Movie Poll: Dick Tracy vs Sin City

I find these moveis to have similar tones and mood, stylisticaly gritty and nasty, but also beautifully made aswell, the movies are both gritty and beautifull on the same time which is quite remarkable. this is about the movies, not comics, the movies as well movies,

which movie entertain you the most, which makes you wave your hands and beat your chest the most,

both movies challanges our morals and our perseption of violence, you thorugh the film see the dark side of violence bu the movie aint hiding the graphical roance that can be found in revenge and forfull your duty by all ways nessesary,

savey

Didn't really enjoy either but voted for Sin City as it seemed better produced.

There is an option missing.
The 'I didn't like any of them!'
I watched them both, but I didn't like them, sorry...
Actually I think the only film I loved that was a transfer from comics to the cinema, was 'V for Vendeta'. An absolute wonderful movie that one!
But I will vote for Sin City because it was a better movie IMHO...

i did not really think Dick Tracy as that good ether, like the stylistics but it was stale and to un-inspired (2/6 stars)

Sin City is a stand out film based on comics (graphic novel), one of the best (top 5) in the past decade,

all actors delivers in Sin City, Mickey Rourkes re-debute in limlight, (everyone say the Wrestler is (fantasitic film) but Sin City brought him back and showed that he is one of the greatest actors alive), Bruce Willies killed it, and killed the yellow perv, like a boss, Jessica Alba made me drawl sometimes, and Alexie Bledel  was amazingly cute as allways, here blue eyes are mezmerizing.

Dick Tracy was an actual movie. Sin City is all style, no substance or anything else. 

Dean wrote: The T wrote: Dick Tracy was an actual movie. Sin City is all style, no substance or anything else.  Dick Tracy played out like a radio play, Sin City played out like a graphic novel - both were actual films (sorry, moovies) but with narative styles from different media.

Dean wrote: The T wrote: Dick Tracy was an actual movie. Sin City is all style, no substance or anything else.  Dick Tracy played out like a radio play, Sin City played out like a graphic novel - both were actual films (sorry, moovies) but with narative styles from different media.

True. But what works in a graphic novel fails to do so in the big screen if the same rhythm and treatment is given. In my opinion. 

Dean wrote: The T wrote: Dean wrote: The T wrote: Dick Tracy was an actual movie. Sin City is all style, no substance or anything else.  Dick Tracy played out like a radio play, Sin City played out like a graphic novel - both were actual films (sorry, moovies) but with narative styles from different media. True. But what works in a graphic novel fails to do so in the big screen if the same rhythm and treatment is given. In my opinion.  It worked for Watchmen and 300. In my opinion.

Watchmen the movie and Watchmen the graphic novel are different enough to both work, in my opinion. 

Okay, but stop calling me Tracey.

Dick Tracey because dick is in it

hehehehehehehehehehe