ERRORS THREAD Report Errors and Omissions Here

NotAProghead wrote: ^ It's easy to check - rate it and then delete the rating.  Though I'm almost sure it will be rated more than once before April 27.

Just looked at the text formatting on the Progarchives Review Guidelines section on the album page where it looks as though the quote character(") is being displayed as � in error. e.g.

Do not use abbreviations or �texting� language

I'll alert Max to this pronto.

but yes, it's gonna be hammered before the release date by the 'raters only' brigade

^ You and I are well versed in such shenanigans and the usual rule should apply - if they disclose the source of their review copy is a legit one (say, a promo) we would let the review stay. You're right though, these things are becoming harder and harder to control. Many eagerly awaited albums appear in their entirety on You Tube prior to release and there's squat we can do about it.

First I messed up when adding this one http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=36659

The release year should be 2012 and the track listing should be changed to this:

Coochie Brake:
1. Theater Of Shadows (5:25)
2. The Noche Called My Nombe (3:19)
3. Gotta Believe (3:03)
4. Rot Of Ages (3:59)
5. Outside The Fence (3:49)
6. Tied To A Cactus (4:00)
7. Crocodile Tears (3:03)
8. Dead Man On The Floor (3:00)
9. Runaway (3:07)
10. Bitter Biter (4:19)
11. Please Don't Go (6:41)

Lying Horse Rock:
*12. Lying Horse Rock (7:09)
*13. West & Kembrell (19:36)

And this should be the release information:

*Ralph Records RZ1110 in 2011
MVD Audio MVD5294A in 2012
MVD Audio MVD5294LP in 2012

*Bonus CD only with limited fan club release in 2011


And as for the second problem, after some checking I think all of the next ones should be switched to singles/fanclub/promo cause they were all limited releases:

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=36680
http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=20937
http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=8348
http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=8397

Edited by historian9 - February 16 2012 at 18:50

Wind & Wuthering release year, vol 2:

Pekka wrote: Wind & Wuthering release year, vol 2: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=1512 This album was discussed here before: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=56319 Now somebody has changed it back to 1977, even though for example Discogs lists a ton of 1976 editions: http://www.discogs.com/Genesis-Wind-Wuthering/master/29409 Is there an argument why a 76 release should be listed as a 77 release as it was changed back?

I'm not a Genesis expert or anything so I'm just going by Wiki here which states the album was released in December 76 in both the US and UK. I've changed it accordingly. Given the popularity of the band here on PA I'm sure some Charterhouse Anoraks will give me pelters if we're both mistaken

^Nothing is incrustable! You just need the right temperature in your frying oil.

A regular smorgasbord of incrustable objects all served up with aioli and some gentle Residents tunes in the background... 

Pekka wrote: ExittheLemming wrote: Pekka wrote: Wind & Wuthering release year, vol 2: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=1512 This album was discussed here before: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=56319 Now somebody has changed it back to 1977, even though for example Discogs lists a ton of 1976 editions: http://www.discogs.com/Genesis-Wind-Wuthering/master/29409 Is there an argument why a 76 release should be listed as a 77 release as it was changed back? I'm not a Genesis expert or anything so I'm just going by Wiki here which states the album was released in December 76 in both the US and UK. I've changed it accordingly. Given the popularity of the band here on PA I'm sure some Charterhouse Anoraks will give me pelters if we're both mistaken Someone has sneaked behind our backs and changed it again to the wrong year  C'mon, what's wrong with the original release date?

But this website http://www.genesis-discography.org says:

Released:
December 1976 / January 1977

and Steve Hackett's official website says 1977.

So?

Booklet of my copy says it's from 1977, Scott McMahon's Genesis Discography ( http://cyberreviews.skwc.com/gendis.pdf, p. 48) also says January 1977 with a remark:

^My cd says 1976 as well