Prog Album Star Rating Game

tool - 10,000 Days

- Fragile by Yes

I never understood all the love for this album...

progrocker2244 wrote: - Fragile by YesI never understood all the love for this album...

It extends from the fact that this was YES' first genuine breakthrough album with a hit single (Roundabout) and that all the tracks on the album are really good...



Uriah Heep - Abominog

Edited by progkidjoel - July 18 2009 at 08:28

Porcupine Tree - NIL RECURRING EP

  Marillion - Marbles

 

progkidjoel wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: <!-- Start Member Post --><!-- google_ad_section_start -->                  Marillion - Marbles Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album?

Clearly no.

Now I get to do the honors..

- Black Clouds and Silver Linings by Dream Theater



Edited by progrocker2244 - July 18 2009 at 09:47

StyLaZyn wrote: progrocker2244 wrote:   progkidjoel wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: <!-- Start Member Post --><!-- google_ad_section_start -->                  Marillion - Marbles Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album? - Black Clouds and Silver Linings by Dream Theater 5 stars?!?!? Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album?

Yes. I like Rudess era DT much more than Moore and Sherinian eras. 38% of people gave it 5 stars, and 30% gave it 4 stars. Almost SEVENTY PERCENT of people gave it an excellent review. You're the outcast on this one.

StyLaZyn wrote: progrocker2244 wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: progrocker2244 wrote:   progkidjoel wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: <!-- Start Member Post --><!-- google_ad_section_start -->                  Marillion - Marbles Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album? - Black Clouds and Silver Linings by Dream Theater 5 stars?!?!? Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album? Yes. I like Rudess era DT much more than Moore and Sherinian eras. 38% of people gave it 5 stars, and 30% gave it 4 stars. Almost SEVENTY PERCENT of people gave it an excellent review. You're the outcast on this one. I guess you missed the sarcasm. And I guess I am not entitled to opinion? King Crimson - Red

Yes I did miss the sarcasm. Where is it?

StyLaZyn wrote: progrocker2244 wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: progrocker2244 wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: progrocker2244 wrote:   progkidjoel wrote: StyLaZyn wrote: <!-- Start Member Post --><!-- google_ad_section_start -->                  Marillion - Marbles Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album? - Black Clouds and Silver Linings by Dream Theater 5 stars?!?!? Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album? Yes. I like Rudess era DT much more than Moore and Sherinian eras. 38% of people gave it 5 stars, and 30% gave it 4 stars. Almost SEVENTY PERCENT of people gave it an excellent review. You're the outcast on this one. I guess you missed the sarcasm. And I guess I am not entitled to opinion? King Crimson - Red Yes I did miss the sarcasm. Where is it? here: 5 stars?!?!? Have you, perchance, actually listened to this album?

That's sarcastic? It didn't seem so considering you gave BC&SL 3 stars...

Subterranean Masquerade - Suspended Animation Dreams (great avant-garde prog metal album)



by the way : Marillion - Marbles (song ; Ocean Cloud is a masterpiece!)




Edited by Agnostic21 - July 18 2009 at 11:20