Inappropriate reviews

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

   It's not a secret that a lot of guys without a life try to send their favorite album to the top throwing crap with electric fan to any suposedly rivals. but there are some important things that prove that the guy is just an ignorant: 

Posted Friday, April 28, 2006, 00:25 EST | Permanent link

 Symphonic Prog 
(Studio Album, 1972) 
Avg: 4.62/5 
from 286 ratings 
GENESIS — Foxtrot
Review by Oler_Than_i_Look 

 This alum for me felt rushed and sloppy. i have had enough of songs soundong the same, and they do on this abum.(Yeah pal, probably Can Utility and the Coastliners, Horizons and Supper's Ready sound exactly the same.)

i dont hate gennisis (The poor idiot doesn't know that proper names use high case, and even worst, doesn't even knows how to read the name of the band, probably never heard the album)

but i have had enough of there boring music. this album puts me asleep, and not in a good way. (Please somebody explain me how can anything put you to sleep in a bad way except a Magnumm 44 bullett?)

a lot of people may call this album a timeless classic combining the best elements of 70's rock and 70's technology (Any first grade student of Progressive Rock 101 knows that the technology on early Genesis albums suck, the production is poor, the important thing is the music, so I insist, this guy never even heard somebody talking about the album) 

with mythology and classical music. but however this is not true.(Mythology? I believe this dude read something about Nursery Cryme, no song from this album is about mythology, even Can-Utility is historical)

try Dark side of the moon - Pink Floyd Atom Heat mother (Poor mother he's sending her to HEAT) - pink floyd Time and a world (The word became a world?)- yes Closer to the eage () - yes in the court of the crimson king - king crimson wish you were her (Wish you were HER????) - pink floyd the six wives - rick wakeman and please dont be ooled by this album it is not that good. 

Posted Friday, April 28, 2006, 00:22 EST | Permanent link

 Symphonic Prog 
(Studio Album, 1973) 
Avg: 4.56/5 
from 405 ratings 
GENESIS — Selling England By The Pound
Review by Oler_Than_i_Look 

 This alumb dissapointed me.This album is how Genesis got its roots. (I believe Genesis roots are in FGTTR or in the worst case in Tespass, or even if you want the definitive lineup in Nursery Cryme)The band with Peter Gabriel is the true Genesis, after Gabriel forget it. (Holy God, if this is the true Genesis and we must forget the rest and this guy gives 1 star, probably post Gabriel Genesis is poisonus) Songs like the Battle of Epping Forest show the path of this band and the core of its music. (Please say waht's the path!!!!!!!!)I heard this album my freshman year in college"74" and to this day it still stands as a remarkable debut to "The Lamb lies down". (debut to The Lamb??? Plese take this guy to rehab.) but over time i have grow to hate this album with its vocals (no jon anderson) (Probably because Jon Anderson never sung with Genesis), and guitar. if you want a real alum try 'dark side of the moon' or rush's 2112 or better yet pink floyds atom heat mother a true prog album. (For God's sake, nothing but a bunch of BS)

I believe that when this kind of behaviour is so obvious, the worst punishment is to delete all the reviews by the same author and send them to oblivium, because is logical to believe that the positive ones are also created to push those albums to the top of our chart.

Iván

Edited by Ivan_Melgar_M - April 28 2006 at 23:45