Nursery Cryme vs Fragile

Winter Wine wrote: Fragile by miles, stronger songs, better atmosphere, just SOUNDS better. Nursery cryme's shabby production and weak tracks bring it down too much. Fragile is the clear winner

Same thoughts here.I also like the individual pieces on the album,which I have noticed a lot of people on here don't.All the full songs on the album are incredible.

Nursery Cryme has great songs,but,as I have stated before about it,the terrible production somewhat spoils it for me.

Nursery is more more more more and MORE intimate and profound album than Fragile

Im a way bigger Genesis fan, than Yes fan, but Nursery Cryme isn't Genesis's best work (try Trespass or Foxtrot). So I would reluctantly opt for Fragile if given a choice. 

 

Granted. The Musical Box is the only piece of music on NC that makes it a good album, other than that its dismal

Gomah wrote: So the moral of the story: Fragile was released in November 1971 in UK.

hahahahah I thought this thread was dead and buried. 

Blimey, this is getting a bit heated!

On my copy of Fragile (CD from 2002) it says it was recorded at Advision September 1971, but that copyright (c) in sleeve drawings, photos, logos is 1972. Presumably therefore a 1972 release....though I must admit I had always thought it was 1971 but there you go...though copyright can be renewed of course.

I do have the original Fragile booklet from the vinyl record at home I'll see what it says, but the LP cover is sadly long gone!!

Lindsay Lohan wrote: The original picture:

That's good, at least I posted the liner note here for you guys to put on your photoalbums around the world, thank you!

ivan_2068 wrote: Is the page from the album complete?????? YES (False, there's not the songlist, copyright, the name of the album neither the RELEASE  date) Is the ATLANTIC SEAL complete??????????  YES (Are you blind) Can the serial number be seen????? YES (False, nothing can be seen - I'm talking about the second photo) Isn't that the exact text in all the central art covers of all UK Fragile editions???? I don't know, I haven't seen any, so what? (I have 5 different editions and all are the same except the mention of UK and the serial number which can't be seen) Just in case and to prove now you're "WRONG": tHIS IS YOUR PHOTO COPIED FROM YOUR POST: Incomplete page, no song list, no name of the album, incomplete Atlantic seal, no serial number. If you say the contrary, hen you're lying. You just used the same photo than 31 of December 2005 and a partial copy of the centerfold THAT SAYS ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. NOTHING

Answers:

1. Song list and the rest may be on other pages, so what?
2. Well, are you kidding me or what? Have you seen your optician lately? If not please do.
   • I see a complete Atlantic seal there which looks like these:
   • 
   • 
3. If you mean 2401 019 Deluxe, yes I see it clearly below Atlantic seal and it goes down to mention MARKETED BY POLYDOR. 
4. Enough said on that

You cannot just make some false claims and say if I say the contrary I am lying. That doesn't make sense and along with your next sentence shows how desparate you are and how funny you can be. I said enough about origin of the pictures and I think it's time you take some computer and photography courses, never too late to learn.

 

BTW: Are you sure you're not making fun of me or trying to make me nervous by saying you see a white strip below Atlantic seal? If that is the case then let me tell you that I don't get bothered easily. And if you really mean it, maybe there is a problem with your computer!

Edited by Gomah

Gomah wrote: ivan_2068 wrote: Is the page from the album complete?????? YES (False, there's not the songlist, copyright, the name of the album neither the RELEASE  date) Is the ATLANTIC SEAL complete??????????  YES (Are you blind) Can the serial number be seen????? YES (False, nothing can be seen - I'm talking about the second photo) Isn't that the exact text in all the central art covers of all UK Fragile editions???? I don't know, I haven't seen any, so what? (I have 5 different editions and all are the same except the mention of UK and the serial number which can't be seen) Just in case and to prove now you're "WRONG": tHIS IS YOUR PHOTO COPIED FROM YOUR POST: Incomplete page, no song list, no name of the album, incomplete Atlantic seal, no serial number. If you say the contrary, hen you're lying. You just used the same photo than 31 of December 2005 and a partial copy of the centerfold THAT SAYS ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. NOTHING If you don't get it, you don't want to see it, this photo has been manipulated and without a serial number or copyright data it has no value. Sorry, that's what you think, and it's a free world, think as you wish Good Bye. Iván

1. Is the page from the album complete??????
2. Is the ATLANTIC SEAL complete??????????
3. Can the serial number be seen?????
4. Isn't that the exact text in all the central art covers of all UK Fragile editions???? 

If you don't get it, you don't want to see it, this photo has been manipulated and without a serial number or copyright data it has no value.

Good Bye.

Iván

Edited by ivan_2068