truth---Peart or Portnoy? - i’ll kill you

vote;

only if you heard

RUSH or

Dreamthetre

otherwise

****  off

 

 

who is the daddy drummer?

tell me truth

 

 

 

vote for NIEL PEART

 

or i'll cut you in the pieces,

eight piece

 

i warn you allready

 

 

 

 

or let us know

why do you like perticular drummer?

 

 

and dont even talk about other drummer ( palmer or anybody( i like palmer))

then i'll cut you ...

you know ....

i allready warn you....

 

i warn.....

WTF is Dreamthetre????

It's Dream Theater, FFS!!!

And I like Phil Collins and Pierre Moerlen better than Neil Peart!! 

peart of course....portnoy manages to be the most unemotional little prick i've ever witnessed on stage, along with every other member of DT minus Myung and sometimes Ruddess (mostly outside of DT for him)...DT is nothing but a technical powerhouse with little to no emotion per song (), this comes off as pleasing for about 6 months, then their charm wears off and all you hear is a bunch of notes that make you want to scream...while I appreciate their technical prowess I believe they could be a much better band than they are...Rush on the otherhand had emotion of sorts while not sacrificing technical prowess which comes off as ultimately satisfying. While this has nothing to do with drumming outwardly, indirectly it definately does. Peart was the greater of the two, you have my opinion.

yes lack of emotion...seeriously, listen to a Dream Theater followed by a TMV album, followed by a Rush album, followed by a Dredg album, followed by almost any other prog band (even freaking Tool, whom I don't much like, has more emotion than DT)...I own EVERY DT album...they just grow so old...i used to be infatuated also...but there is much better stuff out there, not that I don't respect your opinion as it also used to be mine, but DT is lacking for me.

I have but two questions: -

1. Why do we need another Peart vs Portnoy poll?
2. What the hell is Loverboy on?
   

loverboy wrote: ed the dead ( you are on the list ) bj 1 ( i'll .............i'm thinking)     i'm gonna kill you both so run     run like hell   run rabbit run rum rabbit rum

You can't kill me..... you're too small!!!!!

I like rum, tara rum tara rum!

Still Portnoy for me. Not because of his work with DT but his side projects ie. Liquid Tension Experiment, Transatlantic and in particular his drumming on Neal Morse's albums. Peart uses the same 'fills' much too often for me!

king volta wrote: portnoy manages to be the most unemotional little prick

... so that would make you an emotional, big prick then.

Not really trying to stir up sh*t here, but I'm sick of people here trying to blow up their egos by calling accomplished musicans names. It's simply pathetic.

And for the record, Peart is the better drummer.   

• I've seen DT live and as far as I was aware they didn't lack emotion. Not any less than any other band in paticular anyway. Same for Portnoy and other drummers.
• Neil Peart himself is not emotional when he drums.
• I love Pearts drumming
• I love Portnoys drumming
• At the moment I love Portnoy a bit more.
• Thank you