Inappropriate reviews - Progressive Rock Music Forum

Author

Message

Topic Search

Topic Options

Easy Livin View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: February 21 2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 15585

Posted: November 11 2005 at 15:35

Those two gone SD. Wink

My thoughts were the same as your MR. I ended up sending one of my "your review is a bit weak" e-mails to encourage the reviewer to think in a bit more depth when reviewing. In the e-mail i offer to delete the review to allow another to be submitted.

sbrushfan

Forum Senior Member

Joined: November 07 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 1177

Posted: November 11 2005 at 15:45

chopper wrote:

Easy Livin wrote:

sbrushfan

You appear rather selective in the guidelines you wish to observe and which you demand observance of. What about the respect for fellow reviewers guideline?

The fact is that Gatot Widyanto, and Hugues Chantraine are highly respected reviewers on this site. If you don't enjoy their reviews that is up to you. I do not agree with your comments about their command of English. Even if I did, this is an international site and we wish to be as inclusive as we can practically be.

I have deleted your review above as it clearly breaches the guidelines. You have not reviewed that album at all, and your attack on a fellow member is unacceptable. You are quite at liberty to discuss whether or not any band should be listed on the site, but the forum is the place for that discussion, not the reviews section.

Sorry to come into this a bit late, but I'd just like to stick up for Gatot and Hugues as well - two of the best reviewers around. Also, please can we keep braindamage's reviews - they're one of the main reasons I joined this forum, although I must admit they're starting to make a bit of sense now so they're not so funny.

Sorry for my delay in responding to the post. I've been thking about it a lot...my original thought. still stands. And I DO have proof of the guidelines I mentioned not being followed. EXHIBIT A:

RUSH Hold Your Fire
Review (Permanent link) by Symphonic Age @ 4:15:38 PM EST, 6/17/2005

— "Hold Your Fire" contains songs thought for the execution live! Nevertheless is an excellent disc of AOR ( not Prog, POP or Hard Rock!). Is with this disc that I knowed the Rush and I should say that not the better manner was! However I do not regret in the to say that is not a disc that I would repurchase... If not pits of the Rush!

To the general public: Does this make ANY sense? Or...following that thread...how about this one? EXHIBIT B:

RUSH A Show of Hands (Live)
Review (Permanent link) by Symphonic Age @ 4:24:05 PM EST, 6/17/2005

— The disc more Prog of the Rush is paradoxically a Live! I believe that "A Show Of Hands" contains some of the more large moments than the Prog have given us! Certainty the Live LP of the '80 I am in a lot of parts of the fake... But this maintains all the freshness of the better Live! ...Not i know if I explain myself!

Hmmmm...again....does anyone understand this? ANYONE? I'm referring to a guideline, so bear with me....here it is.

1 - Write in ENGLISH, we regret that we cannot accept reviews in other languages. Avoid the use of on-line translators wherever possible, they will not do justice to your efforts. Do not use ALL CAPITAL LETTERS in your reviews, standard sentence case should be used at all times. Do not use abbreviations or “texting” language. Remember to check your review for spelling, grammar and punctuation. A poorly presented review can distract the reader from the well written content. Reviews should be a MINIMUM 50 words preferably substantially more, no maximum.

EasyLivin'....you mention respect. That's all fine and good...but how about respect for the BANDS we review? Yeah...we can rip and tear into their albums all we want to...but was/is it really necessary to post a "review" like this? EXHIBIT C:

RUSH Vapor Trails
Review (Permanent link) by Hugues Chantraine @ 11:00:19 AM EST, 2/3/2004
SPECIAL COLLABORATION

— 2,5 stars really!!!

OK ! So they are back! So what, you ask? This will allow them to make world tours and Live albums. Actually if this is not that a good record , I am very HAPPY that they did get back just for the sake of Peart's personal tragedies (who had lost a wife and daughter) and the fact that this had put Rush's career on hold so long. Nice to see them back in shape and it warms me very much to hear that Peart still has all of his great talent.

As for the album , we have here one of the hardest sounding Rush album a bit in the vein of the previous Test For Echoes , but in this one there is a sense of energy and urgency/spontaneity I found absent in a lot of 90's Rush releases. But by all means , this first hour fan is still not convinced by such records , although I am awed that these guys are still playing so tight. Lifeson's ever present guitar riffs fills out this album and the keyboards have it seems definitely a lesser role than in their 80's albums which were defintely not much to my tastes!

A return to form!

Was mentioning Neil's tragedies at ALL pertinent to the review of the album? No, I think not. To prove it, I want to post this as well...

4 - Write in an intelligent and considerate manner. Rude or insulting language (including blatant vulgarity) will not be tolerated! Show respect for other reviewers, readers, the artists, and the CD and song titles. Do not belittle reviews posted by others, their opinions are as welcome and valid as yours. It is generally best to avoid commenting on other reviews altogether.

Tell me something...how can his comments NOT be rude and insulting? Check out that 1st paragraph.

As far as my being "selective"...darn right! It wasn't me who posted the guidelines, but it's me and other people who get nailed if the guidelines are broken. How about this: EXHIBIT D:

Or...better yet...try this one on for size.

EMERSON LAKE & PALMER (ELP) Works Vol. 1
Review (Permanent link) by Tony R @ 8:18:30 PM EST, 7/5/2005
SPECIAL COLLABORATION

— I really love this album,from the ham-fisted keyboards to the twee vocals and from every over-blown piece of orchestration right up to the masterpiece of mirth that is Pirates. Long years in the making,due to ego clashes and arguments about makeup,Elton John being part of the recording process then not and finally producer Pete Waterman being replaced by Little Jimmy Osmond,the band finally got this meisterwerk out into the public consciousness.Once out there it was a smash,spending 16 weeks at Number One in Albania and going Quadruple Platinum in Belize. When one listens to Emerson's Piano Concertos one is immediately reminded of Les Dawson's egregious masterpieces of the early 70's.I can think of no higher praise than that. I find that "The Enemy God Dances With The Black Spirits" fills me with nostalgia,or should that be neuralgia? I'm not sure but I know that Mrs Palmer should have decided against that shiny red kit for young Carl's 6th Birthday.Pirates- what can I say?I nearly walked the plank the first time I heard this 13 minute epic.It sounds like the ungodly product of a demonic union between WS Gilbert and The Village People and is breath-taking in its excrutiating awfulness and willfull over-ambition.There is nothing like a great Prog Rock Album and this is nothing like a great Prog Rock Album

Hmmmm...seems to me like this is exactly like another review...I seem to recall a review of Rush's HEMISPHERES, if you guys would care to read it. Oh...hell with it...I'll simply cut and paste it. Here we go.

RUSH Hemispheres
Review (Permanent link) by Rich @ 2:38:41 AM EST, 7/6/2005

— I really love this album,from the ham-fisted guitar to the girlie vocals and from the over- blown concept right up to the masterpiece of mirth that is Cignus X-1 Book11. Long years in the making,due to ego clashes and arguments about makeup,Elton John being part of the recording process then not and finally producer Pete Waterman being replaced by Little Jimmy Osmond,the band finally got this meisterwerk out into the public consciousness.Once out there it was a smash,spending 16 weeks at Number One in Albania and going Quadruple Platinum in Belize. When one listens to Geddy Lee's bass one is immediately reminded of Chas n Dave's egregious masterpieces of the early 80's.I can think of no higher praise than that. I find that "La Villa Strangiato" fills me with nostalgia,or should that be neuralgia? I'm not sure but I know that Mrs Peart should have decided against that shiny red kit for young Neal's 6th Birthday.- what can I say? Cignus X-1 Book11 I nearly choked to death the first time I heard this 18 minute epic.It sounds like the ungodly product of a demonic union between WS Gilbert and The Village People and is breath-taking in its excrutiating awfulness and willfull over-ambition.There is nothing like a great Prog Rock Album and this is nothing like a great Prog Rock Album

I also recall another guidlines that seems to have not been followed...I think it's this one.

10 - Any impersonation of another reviewer will be treated as an abuse of the Prog Archives site, and the offender will be barred from further use of the site.

I've done nothing to tamper with these "reviews"...simply copied and pasted them.

To close..if you want to ban me from the site, I have absolutely NO problem with it. I can find somewhere more hospitable to post...somewhere that doesn't pick on the bands themselves and a place in which the reviews are easy to comprehend.

Edited by sbrushfan

Some world views are spacious, and some are merely spaced...

Easy Livin View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: February 21 2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 15585

Posted: November 11 2005 at 16:16

Hi sbrushfan,

I see no need to ban you from the site, you are quite entitled to your opinion.

If a review does not comply with the guidelines, then I'll deal with it, banning someone because of a review would seem like a rather drastic step, and would only be taken as a last resort, perhaps due to constant abuse, etc.

You may not be aware that I only took on moderating the reviews in July this year. Before that, it was done informally on a best efforts basis. I'm now working my way through the thousands of reviews posted before July 2005, and weeding out those which need dealt with. As I'm sure you will appreciate, this will take a long time to complete.

I'll take a look at the reviews you've posted above, and if I think action is needed, I'll take it. I would make the point once again though, you cannot be selective in the rules you choose to subscribe to. Making a point about one rule by breaking another is hypocritical and not constructive.

Instead of wasting your energy worrying about other people's reviews, why not show them how you think it should be done in your own?

TheProgtologist View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: May 23 2005
Location: Baltimore,Md US
Status: Offline
Points: 27802

Posted: November 12 2005 at 00:32

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=55997

Just terrible.This isn't a review,it's a rant.All the bad language and the use of the word "faggot" in a review is totally unecessary.

The Miracle View Drop Down

Prog Reviewer

Joined: May 29 2005
Location: hell
Status: Offline
Points: 28427

Posted: November 12 2005 at 00:41

^Yes... "Drew" wrote and keeps writing crappy reviews, half are inappropriate. Is it the forum member Drew? Because I know he is a huge Rush fan... but from his posts he doesn't seem that crazy... If it's him, maybe warn him?

last.fm

TheProgtologist View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: May 23 2005
Location: Baltimore,Md US
Status: Offline
Points: 27802

Posted: November 12 2005 at 01:49

The Miracle wrote:

^Yes... "Drew" wrote and keeps writing crappy reviews, half are inappropriate. Is it the forum member Drew? Because I know he is a huge Rush fan... but from his posts he doesn't seem that crazy... If it's him, maybe warn him?

I was wondering the same thing.If it's the same Drew as in the forum I am pretty surprised,because he acts nothing like that in the forum.

Bj-1

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: June 04 2005
Location: No(r)Way
Status: Online
Points: 31634

Posted: November 12 2005 at 10:04

TheProgtologist wrote:

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=55997

Just terrible.This isn't a review,it's a rant.All the bad language and the use of the word "faggot" in a review is totally unecessary.

Agree!! Crap review!! Delete it!!

Edited by Bj-1

RIO/AVANT/ZEUHL - The best thing you can get with yer pants on!

sbrushfan

Forum Senior Member

Joined: November 07 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 1177

Posted: November 12 2005 at 12:43

EasyLivin' (nice Uriah Heep refernce there, by the way)...I DO apologize for my moment of, shall we say..."shark jumping"....(where did I hear that?). I'm content that you've decided to hear this out, and not jump the gun as is MY wont. Thank you.

And I DO agree with the others who feel that review should be deleted....I mention Drew in particular. (BTW...I DO hope I'm not crossing any boundaries.). Thank you.

Edited by sbrushfan

Some world views are spacious, and some are merely spaced...

Bj-1

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: June 04 2005
Location: No(r)Way
Status: Online
Points: 31634

Posted: November 12 2005 at 14:57

This "review" just came up on the main site:

CARAVAN In the Land of Grey and Pink progressive rock album and reviews

Canterbury Scene
(Studio Album, 1971)

CARAVAN "In the Land of Grey and Pink"
Review (Permanent link) by Cho Yi Hang
Posted 2:50:33 PM EST, 11/12/2005

Excellent i love this album makes me wanna live in the land of grey and pink and smoke that weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed all day and night

a must listen too people brilliant 5 out of 5 stars

amazing vocals/lyrics and instrumental pieces

buy it or die hahahhahahahahaha

RIO/AVANT/ZEUHL - The best thing you can get with yer pants on!

sbrushfan

Forum Senior Member

Joined: November 07 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 1177

Posted: November 12 2005 at 15:17

Bj-1 wrote:

This "review" just came up on the main site:

Canterbury Scene
(Studio Album, 1971)

CARAVAN "In the Land of Grey and Pink"
Review (Permanent link) by Cho Yi Hang
Posted 2:50:33 PM EST, 11/12/2005

What the hell is THAT?

Some world views are spacious, and some are merely spaced...

Ricochet

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: February 27 2005
Location: Nauru
Status: Offline
Points: 46301

Posted: November 12 2005 at 15:19

hilarious...

The Miracle View Drop Down

Prog Reviewer

Joined: May 29 2005
Location: hell
Status: Offline
Points: 28427

Posted: November 12 2005 at 15:24

TheProgtologist wrote:

I was wondering the same thing.If it's the same Drew as in the forum I am pretty surprised,because he acts nothing like that in the forum.

http://www.progarchives.com/?reviewer=drew

I tend to think it's him... A lot of high ratings for Rush, Porcupine Tree, and a lot of prog metal... As far as I know, that's in his interest.

last.fm

sbrushfan

Forum Senior Member

Joined: November 07 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 1177

Posted: November 12 2005 at 15:25

Ricochet wrote:

hilarious...

Ricochet: Do I not have a sense of humor if I don't find that trifling and idiotic? <smirk>

Edited by sbrushfan

Some world views are spacious, and some are merely spaced...

Bj-1

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: June 04 2005
Location: No(r)Way
Status: Online
Points: 31634

Posted: November 12 2005 at 18:01

PAIN OF SALVATION One Hour By The Concrete Lake
Review (Permanent link) by James D Hill @ 4:39:23 AM EST, 11/16/2003

— What is going on in sweden?I wish that kind of creatitivity was going on here in the states.Grunge meets prog metal and it works.Its a miricle and i live in the Seattle Tacoma area the land of grunge.

Another "off-topic" review. I Found it when I was looking after POS recommendations. Look how long it's been here

Edited by Bj-1

RIO/AVANT/ZEUHL - The best thing you can get with yer pants on!

horza

Prog Reviewer

Joined: August 31 2005
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 2530

Posted: November 12 2005 at 18:39

sbrushfan wrote:

Bj-1 wrote:

This "review" just came up on the main site:

[/COLOR">Canterbury Scene(Studio Album, 1971)

[COLOR=#0000ff">CARAVAN "In the Land of Grey and Pink"[/COLOR">[COLOR=#777777]Review ([COLOR=#0000ff">Permanent link[/COLOR">) by Cho Yi Hang Posted 2:50:33 PM EST, 11/12/2005

Excellent i love this album makes me wanna live in the land of grey and pink and smoke that weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeed all day and nighta must listen too people brilliant 5 out of 5 starsamazing vocals/lyrics and instrumental piecesbuy it or die hahahhahahahahaha

What the hell is THAT?

my thoughts exactly

Originally posted by darkshade:

Calling Mike Portnoy a bad drummer is like calling Stephen Hawking an idiot.

Tony R

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: July 16 2004
Location: UK
Status: Offline
Points: 11979

Posted: November 12 2005 at 19:07

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=56060

Well at least its concise Horza!

Tony R

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: July 16 2004
Location: UK
Status: Offline
Points: 11979

Posted: November 12 2005 at 19:08

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=56060

It mentions the W word,on a Sunday,by God!

Where's that haggis-hurling sporran juggler when you need him?

Probably out lookin for some Easy Lovin'

Edited by Tony R

Easy Livin View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: February 21 2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 15585

Posted: November 13 2005 at 15:27

TP, Dealt with.

Cheers sbrushfan, Thumbs Up

BJ-1 That one dealt with too, along with others by the same reviewer.

BJ-1 I've come across a few old JDH ones in need of attention, thanks fo that one.

Tony, nice to see you're pining for me! Wink LOL

Ivan_Melgar_M View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 27 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 19557

Posted: November 13 2005 at 17:41

Ok guys this was only an annoying style but I believe it has gone too far:

PINK FLOYD "The Wall"
Review (Permanent link) by Marquês Van Prög
Posted 4:02:33 PM EST, 11/13/2005

Roger Waters insightful look into the world around him should be looked at as a lesson for us all. If you have seen the movie, you will really understand wha "The Wall" is about. The main character, aptly named Pink , is driven to insanity behind his "wall," a protective barrier that keeps him isolated from the real world. This wall is built of "bricks" of his past, such as his father's death in WWII, His overprotective mother, the forced conformity of his education, and his older life of Sex, Drugs, and Rock'n'roll. The album itself is very vague, but if you watch the film, it all comes out in plain daylight. Pink's younger life is loosely based on Roger Waters, and his adult life on Syd Barrett. The musical side of The Wall, while slightly overshadowed by the lyrics is also a splendid performance.

CD 1

1. In the flesh? - 5/5

2. The thin ice - 4.5/5

3. Another brick in the wall Part one - 5/5

4. The happiest days of our lives - 4/5

5. Another brick in the wall Part two - 5/5

6. Mother - 5/5

7. Goodbye blue sky - 4/5

8. Empty spaces - 4.5/5

9. Young lust - 4/5

10. One of my turns - 4/5

11. Don't leave me now - 4/5

12. Another brick in the wall Part three - 5/5

13. Goodbye cruel world - 4/5

5+4.5+5+4+5+5+4+4.5+4+4+4+5+4 = 4,46

CD 2

1. Hey you - 5/5

2. Is there anybody out there - 5/5

3. Nobody home - 5/5

4. Vera - 4.5/5

5. Bring the boys back home - 4/5

6. Comfortably numb - 5/5

7. The show must go on - 4.5/5

8. In the flesh - 5/5

9. Run like hell - 5/5

10. Waiting for the worms - 4.5/5

11. Stop - 4/5

12. The trial - 5/5

13. Outside the wall - 4/5

5+5+5+4.5+4+5+4.5+5+5+4.5+4+5+4 = 60,5

60,5 : 13 = 4,65

Final Note: The Wall is an Epic.The words mean more and make more sense if you listen to it a few times. The best thing about it is that there is nothing of pointless and meaningless babble that comprises most of todays music. The music speaks volumes about our lives and struggles, about chaos in our society, and most of all, about hope. If you are going to listen to only one album in your life, this should be it. Highly Recommended.!!!

4,46 + 4,65 = 9,11

9,11 : 2 = 4,6

Essential: a masterpiece of progressive music

Curiosity: There is a secret reversed message on Empty Spaces that starts about 15 seconds before the singing and ends right before "What..." It says: "Congratulations. You have just discovered the secret message. Please send your answer to old Pink, in care of the funny farm-" "ROGER!" "Chalfont!" "Carolyn's on the phone!" "Okay."

4 lines of review
3 lines of anecdotical and unnecessary information.
9 lines of absurd psychobabble by a guy who's credentials are not in Psychology (apparently)
33 lines of a math formula (Double space so it takes almost 90% of the space of the page)

If I want o see the song list I go to the album page, so this is absurd waste of valuable space..

I believe it's healthy to call the guy and if he doesn't change, delete all this math nonsense.

Iván

Edited by ivan_2068

Bj-1

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: June 04 2005
Location: No(r)Way
Status: Online
Points: 31634

Posted: November 13 2005 at 18:17

ivan_2068 wrote:

Ok guys this was only an annoying style but I believe it has gone too far:

PINK FLOYD "The Wall"
Review (Permanent link) by Marquês Van Prög
Posted 4:02:33 PM EST, 11/13/2005

4 lines of review
3 lines of anecdotical and unnecessary information.
9 lines of absurd psychobabble by a guy who's credentials are not in Psychology (apparently)
33 lines of a math formula (Double space so it takes almost 90% of the space of the page)

If I want o see the song list I go to the album page, so this is absurd waste of valuable space..

I believe it's healthy to call the guy and if he doesn't change, delete all this math nonsense.

Iván

Agree!! That review was just annoying!!

RIO/AVANT/ZEUHL - The best thing you can get with yer pants on!