Hello, I want to report this error:

http://www.progarchives.com/post_commentreview.asp



This is like the first 3rd time I want to comment about a review and it's just a waste of time, I guess you did this on purpose to prevent who knows what. I think you should fix it or remove it.

The first 2 messages were meant to thank a prog reviewer for the one of the best reviews I read in this site. And now that I wrote the 3rd comment I don't feel like letting it go, so I'll paste it here:

""Man, why reviewing an album by a band you hate so much?
Reading this review is really sickening. I don't know if I should use the report link 'cause it's really sickening.
PS: I read a fair amount of XXXX albums reviews, some are then are harsh and I don't care, but yours is an insult to any reviewer or reader""

I added the album The High Road by The Present Moment, but something seems to have gone wrong with the album artwork and I think I may have uploaded something other than the image file by accident.

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=34

thanks, NotAProghead.

Another small thing:

Charlie & Esdor -

GRÖNT ÄR SKÖNT

is actually an EP/single and not a full album.

please urgently remove existing link of the band!!!!

BLAND BLADEN

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=3710

careful, the band's homepage is no longer there. Even worse: it links to some "never ending junk"! Be careful. Don't click it! I am not sure if it doesn't do any harm to your computer... I will now scan for viruses & trojans... no nothing bad...



Edited by tendst - December 28 2011 at 09:46

The link to the Fish official website on Fish's PA page is not actual.

ExittheLemming wrote: ^ They have rather a convoluted discography don't they? There's a similar bonus CD with the 12 Stories Down album entitled '8 days later' but  no duplication of tracks from the bonus CD that you got with Variations of a Dream so I'll add the details to the latter as 'releases info' as there is no evidence it's available separately. BTW the band's website states the bonus CD you have was limited to the first 1000 copies of Variations and they have no plans to re-release it (You sure your version is a new copy?) I also notice that 10 Stories Down is a remastered, remixed and re-arranged version of 12 Stories Down (different number and order of tracks but are they completely different performances?) I'm assuming that September Sampler and Limited Edition Free CD are just different names for the same entity?

There is definitely a re-release of Variations with 8 Days as a bonus disk.  I just saw it at the store a couple of days ago.  I didn't buy it, though, as I'm not exactly sure how fond of TPT I actually am. 
Anyway, here's a quote from the Burning Shed web site:
" Originally released in 2004, Variations On A Dream was The Pineapple Thief's third studio album.
Re-mixed and re-mastered by Bruce Soord, this 2011 Kscope edition also comes with a new cover.
Presented in the same way as the original limited release, the rare 8 Days album appears on CD 2. "

I also have the 10 stories down (not 12 stories down, which I believe is rare) re-release with 8 Days Later.

As for whether or not they should be listed here as separate releases, I have no idea.  Do they have official album covers?

^ They have rather a convoluted discography don't they? There's a similar bonus CD with the 12 Stories Down album entitled '8 days later' but  no duplication of tracks from the bonus CD that you got with Variations of a Dream so I'll add the details to the latter as 'releases info' as there is no evidence it's available separately. BTW the band's website states the bonus CD you have was limited to the first 1000 copies of Variations and they have no plans to re-release it (You sure your version is a new copy?)

I also notice that 10 Stories Down is a remastered, remixed and re-arranged version of 12 Stories Down (different number and order of tracks but are they completely different performances?)

I'm assuming that September Sampler and Limited Edition Free CD are just different names for the same entity?


Edited by ExittheLemming - December 25 2011 at 23:25

I could not find anything but I wouldn't be suprised if one of the members in the band is a member here

Why was there a track 8 on an album with 7 tracks, also I gave you the musicians names in an earlier post