Close To The Edge or Red?

am I the only one that loves Moonchild?

The Bearded Bard wrote: Red.   What's wrong with Providence? Better than most of the tracks, improvs or not, on SaBB, IMO.

Red.

This is the first X vs Y poll in which I'm wan't immediately certain who to vote for (and wish there were Both/Neither button). 



Edited by Argonaught - December 13 2012 at 17:44

thellama73 wrote: Mr. Maestro wrote: I feel like a weirdo.  Am I the only person in the world who thinks "Providence" is brilliant? m I the only one who thinks One More Red Nightmare is brillliant? People always talk about the title track and Starless (which is admittedly amazing) but I never hear much talk about that one. It's one of my all time favorite Crimson tracks.

Mine too.  Maybe if there was no title track, I'd still take Red over CTTE for this one.  Incredible work from both Bruford and McDonald, especially.

KC

There's no disputing the brilliance of CTTE but I probably enjoy Red a little more.

Yes - Close to the Edge; can't see Red in the same equation

Close to the Edge is the only album I know of where I would not change a thing if I could. The only track on Red that reaches the same level of perennial awesomeness is "Starless". There are other good tracks on it, but I always found it a bit inconsistent.

thellama73 wrote: Mr. Maestro wrote: I feel like a weirdo.  Am I the only person in the world who thinks "Providence" is brilliant? m I the only one who thinks One More Red Nightmare is brillliant? People always talk about the title track and Starless (which is admittedly amazing) but I never hear much talk about that one. It's one of my all time favorite Crimson tracks.

Not one of my favorite Crimson tracks, but I do think it's great. The lyrics are pretty awkward though.

Sumdeus wrote: still, i think it is simply ridiculous to say "composition>improvisation". imo the best compositions usually involve improvisation to a certain degree, and I also like a lot of music that is composed through improvisation itself...

I agree that it's an over-generalization to say that composition is always better than improvisation, but especially in the case of King Crimson I usually find their completely improvised pieces much less interesting than the ones that involve some kind of composition. I'd go as far as saying that "We'll Let You Know" and "Starless and Bible Black" kinda stink ("Providence" is better). On the other hand, LTIA1 is one of my favorite King Crimson tracks, even though it involves a large amount of improvisation. But what sets it apart is that this is planned improvisation. It revolves around a set of pre-composed themes and it's clearly structured.

Live versions of CttE would beat Red. But otherwise I prefer Red. Yes is just to sterile in the studio.