Arent Yes Just Great?

I think Yes are the best band technically speaking but I just think they lack in the emotion department. Their songs are just not emotionally intense IMO.

But congratulations for their skills ! They sure can play

 

  Yes Floyd and Genesis are clearly the top 3

BaldFriede wrote: There are better bands than Yes, in my opinion.

The went by the name, The Beatles!

 

To answer your question, YES.

 

#1floydfan wrote: any yes hater desirves to die they right up there with floyd if you ask me

I haven't seen a single Yes hater in this thread, unless you consider those of us who love Yes but don't believe they are N° 1 as haters.

I love Yes, have all their albums (Except Big Generator which I heard many times but never bought), all their videos and DVD's but they are not in my top 10.

BTW: Didn't mentioned Floyd despite they are in my top 5 because Pink Floyd is not a Symphonic band so not suitable for this case.

Iván

Edited by ivan_2068

Yes was the first Prog' band I ever heard (Knowing what Prog means, because I am an Uriah Heep fan before even knowing there was something called Prog Rock).

But they are not the best Prog' band IMO, they have great musicians, Howe, Wakeman, Bruford and Squire are top 10 on their respective instruments but honestly I can't stand Jon Anderson's voice and their lirycs say nothing to me plus the fact that Alan White (who plays during most Yes career) is not a great drummer, good, but not outstanding.

But the music is incredible, I like most of their early albums and I would recommend you to buy them in this order:

1. Close to the Edge
2. Relayer
3. The Yes Album
4. Drama

If you become a fan, then go for the rest, but there are at least 10 or more bands that you should explore simultaneously only in the symphonic sub-genre (If you try other sub-gentres, you would have many more to explore):

• Genesis
• Anglagard
• ELP: Not exactly symphonic, but mostly considered by the progheads as part of the genre
• VDGG
• Gentle Giant
• Kansas
• Banco del Mutuo Soccorso
• Par Lindh Project
• Le Orme
• Focus
• Triumvirat
• Renaisance

Iván

Edited by ivan_2068

Relayer - All the passion spent in one place. (as Anderson sings on TfTO)

Very accurate description. I could do without the other Yes albums. CttE has it's moments, but no match for Relayer!    

matti meikäläin wrote: BaldFriede wrote: When it comes down to instrumental virtuosity, Yes certainly are hard to beat; the individual abilities of the musicians on their instruments are excellent. But that's not all that counts, in my opinion. And other bands have virtuosos too.  totally agreed with that, like close to the edge is intresting and well composed work but i can hear no feeling at all !! It doesen't move me at all

That is strange. This is perhaps the album I have heard that moves me the most.

When it comes down to instrumental virtuosity, Yes certainly are hard to beat; the individual abilities of the musicians on their instruments are excellent. But that's not all that counts, in my opinion. And other bands have virtuosos too. 

I havent really heard too much vdgg

NO !!!!