I had this list 2 years ago, not sure I would want to change it that much but perhaps would push out ELP and put in PG1 instead.

progaardvark wrote: I just copied and pasted my top 10 from Paul's thread as nothing has happened in the last two years to make feel like I need to re-evaluate...

Edited by omphaloskepsis - April 19 2023 at 06:13

David_D wrote: Sean Trane wrote: 12           Crucis     Los Delerios Del Mariscal  Arg         1977      According to RYM and Discogs, this one was released in 1976.

Logan wrote: When going to Search, you have to click on advanced search. Then Find Posts, click on Any Date from the dropdown. If I were to look it up, then the fields I would use and ones to choose to limit results: Search by Keyword: 1977 Search Forum: Top 10s and lists Search in: Topic Subject Find Posts: Any Date Display Results As: Topics Start Search and Paul's is the second result.

Wallenstein-No More Love

14           Circus     Movin' On            Swz        1977     

13           Genesis  Seconds Out         Eng         1977     

13           Pink Floyd            Animals Eng         1977     

13           Plat du Jour          Plat du Jour          Fra          1977     

12           Brel, Jacques        Les Marquises     Bel          1977     

12           Cano      Au Nord de Notre Vie         Can         1977     

12           Cherry, Don          Hear & Now         USA        1977     

12           Conventum          A l'Affut d'un Complot       Can         1977     

12           Dionne - Bregent                Deux       Can         1977     

12           F.M.       Black Noise           Can         1977     

12           Iceberg   Sentiments          Spa         1977     

12           Maneige Ni Vent... Ni Nouvellle        Can         1977     

12           Meat Loaf             Bat Out of Hell     USA        1977     

12           Rush       A Farewell to Kings             Can         1977     

12           Supertramp         Even in the Quietest Moments        Eng         1977     

11           Jeff Beck & Jan Hammer Group       Live        Var         1977     

11           Fermata Huascaran            Svk         1977      Fusion

11           Golden Earring     Live        Net         1977     

11           Gong      Live Etc. Var         1977     

11           Ibrahim, Abdullah (Dollar Brand)     Journey  SAf         1977     

11           Island     Pictures Swz        1977     

11           Klaatu    Hope      Can         1977     

11           Lard Free              Lard Free III          Fra          1977     

11           Max Webster       High Class in Borrowed Shoes          Can         1977     

11           Mitchell, Joni       Don Juan's Reckless Daughter          Can         1977     

11           Modry Efekt         Svitanie Cze         1977     

11           Potemkine           Triton     Fra          1977     

11           Rainbow On Stage               Var         1977     

11           Tangerine Dream                Encore   Ger         1977     

11           Triumph      Rock & Roll Machine     Can         1977     

11                Univers Zero        Univers Zero (aka 1313)    Bel          1977

Edited by Sean Trane - April 19 2023 at 04:14

Lewian wrote: Logan wrote: David_D wrote: Lewian wrote: Paul has done a series of top 10 per year that was later extended by Mirakaze up to the present. The 1977 one is currently on page 12 of the Top 10s subforum. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=126820 Just saying... still have fun doing new lists! And Paul's 1977 was almost 2 years ago, so I guess, fine to have a fresh one.  Actually, we do encourage people to use the search (search all dates if using PA search) to see if the same topic (or similar enough) has been done before, and especially if it is unlocked then to respond to that instead of making a new topic. We discourage duplicates commonly. It helps keep the place more organised, we get to see what other posters who may not still be around thought, and those still here who posted can edit their old posts to show if it changed or can add that to the old topic. That said, I wasn't going to comment on just doing this the one time for one year, but if any more years were to be done, then please do search for the older topic and respond there. Cheers. Sorry for this somewhat off topic question, but how exactly do you find this using the PA search? How can you specify "all dates"? I actually tried looking for 1977 but found a thread from 2005 and Paul's recent "prog line" but not the one I wanted to find, which I eventually only could nail down going back the pages in the Top 10s subforum, somewhat tediously. In my experience the forum search is a mess, but then I may not use it properly!?

When going to Search, you have to click on advanced search. Then Find Posts, click on Any Date from the dropdown.

If I were to look it up, then the fields I would use and ones to choose to limit results:
Search by Keyword: 1977
Search Forum: Top 10s and lists
Search in: Topic Subject
Find Posts: Any Date
Display Results As: Topics

Start Search

and Paul's is the second result.

EDIT: I was too slow as I was more detailed than necessary.
I was going to mention that I have been asked to unlock old topic various times and am usually willing if not inflammatory ones. Many old topics auto-locked. SO just because a topic is locked like the one you want to start, often it can be good to PM me asking for it to be unlocked.

Edited by Logan - April 18 2023 at 16:19

Lewian wrote: Logan wrote: David_D wrote: Lewian wrote: Paul has done a series of top 10 per year that was later extended by Mirakaze up to the present. The 1977 one is currently on page 12 of the Top 10s subforum. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=126820 Just saying... still have fun doing new lists! And Paul's 1977 was almost 2 years ago, so I guess, fine to have a fresh one.  Actually, we do encourage people to use the search (search all dates if using PA search) to see if the same topic (or similar enough) has been done before, and especially if it is unlocked then to respond to that instead of making a new topic. We discourage duplicates commonly. It helps keep the place more organised, we get to see what other posters who may not still be around thought, and those still here who posted can edit their old posts to show if it changed or can add that to the old topic. That said, I wasn't going to comment on just doing this the one time for one year, but if any more years were to be done, then please do search for the older topic and respond there. Cheers. Sorry for this somewhat off topic question, but how exactly do you find this using the PA search? How can you specify "all dates"? I actually tried looking for 1977 but found a thread from 2005 and Paul's recent "prog line" but not the one I wanted to find, which I eventually only could nail down going back the pages in the Top 10s subforum, somewhat tediously. In my experience the forum search is a mess, but then I may not use it properly!?

Edited by Cristi - April 18 2023 at 16:07

David_D wrote: Lewian wrote: Paul has done a series of top 10 per year that was later extended by Mirakaze up to the present. The 1977 one is currently on page 12 of the Top 10s subforum. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=126820 Just saying... still have fun doing new lists! And Paul's 1977 was almost 2 years ago, so I guess, fine to have a fresh one.

Actually, we do encourage people to use the search (search all dates if using PA search) to see if the same topic (or similar enough) has been done before, and especially if it is unlocked then to respond to that instead of making a new topic. We discourage duplicates commonly. It helps keep the place more organised, we get to see what other posters who may not still be around thought, and those still here who posted can edit their old posts to show if it changed or can add that to the old topic. That said, I wasn't going to comment on just doing this the one time for one year, but if any more years were to be done, then please do search for the older topic and respond there. Cheers.