Testimony

debrewguy wrote: Not to disagree, but .... When I was still in high school ( about a century or two ago), I had an old stereo that had speakers with ONE speaker each. NO Tweeter, Mid Range or subwoofer or any other animal like sound sounding name. I wired these old Radio Shack Realistic car speakers (the plastic one you put on the top behind your rear seats) to give me 4 speakers. I then played a few AC/DC & Foghat LPs. And I kid you not, I still have not heard a better sounding guitar tone since. Of course, the bass was not exactly prominent, not the drums, but the guitars sounded like buzzsaws. But anyways, does anyone remember when Canadian speakers were considered reliably well built ?

Many guitar amps come with one membrane only ... usually one 12" or 15" membrane is quite enough, since the guitar tone contains no ultra-high frequencies you don't need a tweeter.

mystic fred wrote: i rarely listen to other people's hi fi systems, no one  i know is really interested, they have their dvd set-up and they're happy with that. i have spent years and months getting a sound i enjoy from my system, and i'm amazed how some old records i dig out from time to time sound so good, better than i've ever heard them before! also my view of what a good system should sound like may differ from others - some like too much bass for instance.  i have the highest respect for Olivier's opinion and experience, and i'm sure sometimes forum members get the wrong impression from his style of writing, but if i went to listen to his system, though i am sure it sounds absolutely fantastic, i would have to come back home to mine and it wouldn't sound the same.   i haven't the money to make any further major upgrades in the near future, so to a degree ignorance is bliss. i am not an expert but i know enough to advise others of the basics of  getting good sound, though i would not call anyone's system crappy, i would just point out the deficiencies and advise how to improve the sound, i was a salesman for 12 years after all - diplomacy gains respect.

Not to disagree, but ....
When I was still in high school ( about a century or two ago), I had an old stereo that had speakers with ONE speaker each. NO Tweeter, Mid Range or subwoofer or any other animal like sound sounding name. I wired these old Radio Shack Realistic car speakers (the plastic one you put on the top behind your rear seats) to give me 4 speakers. I then played a few AC/DC & Foghat LPs. And I kid you not, I still have not heard a better sounding guitar tone since. Of course, the bass was not exactly prominent, not the drums, but the guitars sounded like buzzsaws.
But anyways, does anyone remember when Canadian speakers were considered reliably well built ?

Glueman, you are...sticky!

i rarely listen to other people's hi fi systems, no one  i know is really interested, they have their dvd set-up and they're happy with that.

Edited by mystic fred - May 30 2007 at 06:15

Glueman wrote: Oliver - I certainly wasn't referring to MP3. Although, the premise would still apply to MP3 playback. I, personally, don't think that mp3 has a place in hi-fi. It's fine for i-pods and computer playback but they're a country mile from hi-fi. (Here's where Mike steps in and damns me............again   )

So what are you talking about?

Oliver - I certainly wasn't referring to MP3. Although, the premise would still apply to MP3 playback.

It still has to be said that there are many, many combinations of kit that can produce "awesome" sounds. Not all of those will match Oliver's criteria.

Edited by Glueman - May 30 2007 at 03:31

That's funny - I consider my system "awesome" ( and it is) and yet you insulted that! And I know for sure that you didn't know some of my kit. Amazing ability - to hear and trash by telepathy.

Edited by Glueman - May 30 2007 at 03:32

I don't see why people should feel insulted. Unless one identifies himself with an object, for instance.

I can't help myself, cause that's what it is.

My system is very modest, compared to others.
But indeed it's awesome, compared to what everybody has.
There's absolutely no insult here. It's a very sad thing that most people don't listen to music at home anymore and it's mostly due to digital.
I'm also very sad for the young generations who grow up with bad music and bad sound (sub-digital), and it goes together. That's why i keep on trying to convince evrybody that good Hifi works and is a fantastic source of musical pleasure. I want to share that.