Hi,
Nice review all around.
The "classical" context of KC's performance has been there for many years, and it is something that a lot of "rock music" fans do not care for, and sometimes, it even becomes one of the reasons why those folks dislike KC ... RF is sitting down, and does not "acknowledge" the audience when playing ... for the most part within an orchestra the only person dealing with the audience is the conductor, not the players ... and we do not make usually snag remark comments about the 5th or the 9th. Or the 3rd!
For me, the most important part of KC is the fact that it separates the "men from the boys" (so to speak) when it comes to musicianship and performance. Too many bands rely on the cheap tricks of the trade, or the hardons due to a few girls in the first row, and this takes a lot of the music's value away from it all, in the end, but then, if most of the material is vain, I guess it makes sense to show up and be vain, right?
KC draws the line, and there are a lot of fans that do not like it. I've always said that KC in concert, specially in the past 10 years, is probably the best "classical concert" that you will ever see in your life, and well, it just happens to be electric! But, for me, RF is just as good up there doing his thing, as Yehudi Menuhin was, just as Isaac Stern was, or as much as Ravi Shankar was, and so many others. Even the venerable PF members do not get that much, since the days before DSOTM, when parts of their material was actually played by someone else, until you realized that the musicianship required, was not really designed for a rock audience, but ... there it is ... given to make it look like it is a show for the audience, many of which only wanted a piece of the pig, btw ... which ought to tell you about the actual performance, and how the band did not really think they could hold it up without the effects, which would have been done better with film on their massive screen?
The saddest part of it all, was watching some of these dinosaur bands, and many of them still wanting the "love" that an audience can give them ... and while watching RW and a couple members of the old YES, in my book it took away from the music ... he just about demanded an applause after each little solo ... use the burhaha instrument, and then pause for the applause kind of thing, and to me, this is the difference between greatness and just over-bearing ego ... RW, did not show me musicianship on the stage ... all we saw was a handful of chops ... and honestly, I was disappointed, and felt like the YES concert at the Casino here in Oregon, when the only fans were the dressed up and perfumed hippies of the day, applauding each HIT ... and never closing their eyes and appreciating the music, and applauding the bass solo pieces in the middle of some parts!
Somewhere along the way, it becomes obvious that the music itself is not as important as the showmanship that the musician stoops to conquer! For me, it has always cheapen the music, if the most you can do is try to sway the audience into loving what you are doing! What the heck are you paying for, then?
And this is what is missing in the "progressive music" history ... an audience appreciation that transcends the fan manipulation that so many bands rely on. I'm not sure that "progressive" can make its name, if the most it has to offer is just formatted music and a few trix in the box to ensure that you and I can make it to the show ... well, I know I won't, and KC might have been my last show EVER. But then, I have seen a lot more than most and have seen things that many people wish they had seen .... and I won't complaint about my chances and the time that I lived and got to see these great bands.
Kinda reminds me of Rachel Flowers doing her piano version of TARKUS ... you really think that the audience that liked and saw ELP would have sat for almost 20 minutes and applauded a piece of music on a solo piano? I really doubt it! And those same fans would have killed the band for its lousy show and music! And it is, in her hands, one of the finest piano pieces EVER written in American music!
The sheer lack of appreciation for the music itself ... is the most scary thing of all! It's the killer of all music and the arts! You might as well go back to the daily mill and grind! f**k the music!
------------- Music is not just for listening ... it is for LIVING ... you got to feel it to know what's it about! Not being told! www.pedrosena.com
|