Reviews reporting thread

PAIN OF SALVATION — Scarsick
Review by kentavros (Stavros)

Alot won't understand it Alot will critisize it But for those who appreciate a testimony of thoughts by one of the biggest genius in our time in music will see the agony of the man about the future of all of us. Progressivness to its limit.Anger and suddness.The agony of what a human being is. Have we lost our goal in life? Questions that seek answer.And the vehicle to that is music.Rage for order of 2007? At least few understood that record then.The same will happen here.

If you're reviewing an album that isn't OUT yet, I think the goal would be to try to clarify for other people who haven't heard that album yet what it sounds like... but this review just says "I'm smart, you aren't; I COULD UNDERSTAND the lyric subject matter of Scarsick, MOST PEOPLE WON'T".  And about the MUSIC? ZERO. Zero comments about the music. Just a "I know a lot" review.... It doesn't help nor serves any purpose for people who want to read a good opinion about an album that ISNT OUT YET.

Edited by The T - December 12 2006 at 13:38

    YES — Close to the Edge
Review by FloydFree
This is a solid Yes album, but I have to say that it is definitely overrated. I love Siberian Khatru but Close to the Edge and And You And I don't do anything for me. This a good album, but definitely not worthy of being rated #1 on all of progarchives.com. I would recommend Fragile over Close to the Edge to a prog fan trying to get into Yes.

Posted Tuesday, December 12, 2006, 17:01 EST | Permanent link



Not a good review IMO, citing its position in the PA charts.

Dealing with them all, folks!

Atkingani wrote: Tux and SD chat being moved to Help Us Improve The Site?Reviews Discussion!

Thanks, didn't realise there was such a thread!

Angelo wrote: http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=103004 Review by rekabat This is a 5 partly because it needs to be higher on the list (I've heard all the albums in between) and mostly because it's amazing. The whole band works great together and McLaughlin is an expert guitarist. Just about every song is amazing Grrrrr.... I like the album, but this is not the way.

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=102699


http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=103018



The 2nd review copies material from the 1st review, Collaborator Chris Stacey is the first, 2nd appears to be the much reported floyd tree...





Edited by OpethGuitarist - December 13 2006 at 20:44

Guigo

This was posted in the Errors & Omissions forum:

Glueman wrote: Has anyone noticed the two recent reviews for "The Bends"? We have two identical reviews from users entitled "eljokregime" and "Mathewrenforth".

The offending review is this one ....

Regards
Joolz

RADIOHEAD — The Bends

Review by eljokregime

RADIOHEAD — The Bends Review by Mathewrenforth Radiohead: The Bends (1995)

Thom Yorke: Vocals, Guitar

Johnny Greenwood: Lead Guitar, Organ, Synthesizer, Piano

Colin Greenwood: Bass

Phil Selway: Drums

Ed O’Brian: Guitar, Backing Vocals

It may be hard to believe that the hard-hitting alternative band Radiohead was once called ‘a lily livered excuse for a rock band’. The release of the first LP “Pablo Honey” and their subsequent well known single “Creep” were somewhat heavily criticised. They were described as a one hit wonder as they failed to release any other track on the record prior to the fame of “Creep”. It seemed that “Creep” was the only track on the record with any potential of fame.

Stung by the criticism Radiohead released their second LP known as “The Bends” in 1995. The album followed the popular path of Indie Rock with tracks such as “High and Dry”, “Fake Plastic Trees” and “Street Spirit (Fade Out)”. These are now widely regarded as genuine Indie anthem tracks. The album was voted 100th best album of all time out of 500 in the Rolling Stones magazine; it became clearer that all critics had been proved wrong.

The album name “Bends” refers to decompression sickness. This medical condition develops when deep-sea divers come up to the sea surface too quickly. Many perceive the name of the album as a metaphor of Radiohead’s sudden and unexpected fame. The lyrics throughout are written by Thom Yorke an commonly relate to hid unhappiness. Hid lyrics are mostly seen to be metaphors referring to health matters in songs such as “Bones” and “My Iron Lung”. These songs are related to genuine problems in society that we live in and the suffering that some people endure during their lifetime. Thom Yorke uses themes such as alienation and technology and his lyrics are notorious for giving the feeling of depression and dissatisfaction.

There are two sides to the album. The first being the classic Indie Rock most famous in the time of 1995, the second being an array of orchestra and synthesized loops. Radiohead’s alternative style heard in the album differs to the bleach blonde Indie Rock that was usually heard in 1995.



The album opens with possibly the most contemporary track on the record. “Planet Telex” sways with its synthesized background loop alongside keyboard and spaced out guitar rhythm. Lead guitarist Johnny Greenwood shows his matchless style of playing with classic heavy riffs to clean cut solos. Johnny was originally given the roll of playing the Harmonica, but ironically became the backbone of the band with his superb skills on lead guitar.

Five songs were released on the album; “My Iron Lung”, “High and Dry”, “Fake Plastic Trees”, “Just” and “Street Spirit (fade out)”. “Fake plastic Trees” was a huge hit in the U.S and quickly became an album favourite. The song begins with a soft acoustic touch alongside the light, high vocals from Yorke, Which leads one into a trance by the ending of the song. A very unique sound in the Brit pop era of 1995.

“Just” shows that there was still a fast, strong side to Radiohead, as the striking acoustic riff leads to a heavily distorted introduction. It shows that Radiohead had not diverted away from Indie Rock and the fast riffs and textbook vocals were what earlier fans wanted to hear. The song can be compared to You, the opener from Pablo Honey, both being very strong and aggressive. The critically acclaimed video shows the seriousness in the song, the ending has boggled minds from all over the globe.

Other songs such as “Street Spirit (Fade out)” or “High and Dry” were seen as Radiohead’s best work ever. The incomparable acoustic riff in “Street Spirit” has shown that the song is one of the biggest cult anthems of the 90’s. Vocally, the song is more emotional than ever before, as the lengthy elevated sound of Thom’s voice was yet another first for Radiohead. Yorke may have stretched his voice to such a pitch in “Pablo Honey”, but never before had he kept the note for such a long time. “High and Dry” also shows a more sad and unhappy feeling, as lyrically the song is about being hated, and left out. The song begins with a customized drum beat leading to an acoustic rhythm alongside the faded lead guitar in the background.

“The Bends” has been and still is considered not only one of Radiohead’s best albums, but one of the very best albums of al time. Although, “The Bends” seemed to have been firmly pushed off the shelf due to the release of their follow-up album, “OK Computer”. “OK Computer” was recently voted by million of English television viewers as the greatest album of all time, beating critically acclaimed albums The Beatles and U2. In a way both “The Bends” and “OK Computer” are similar guitar-wise, although the latter was the beginning f Radiohead’s experimental era which can still be heard to date in “Amnesiac”, “Kid A’” and “Hail to the Thief”.

Posted Friday, December 15, 2006, 04:17 EST

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=103314

Edited by SevenColoured - December 17 2006 at 08:49

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=103426

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=103458

Too short. He only bashes the album and doesn't explain anything.