Forum Home Forum Home > Site News, Newbies, Help and Improvements > Report abuse here
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Other websites ripping off your stuff
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Topic ClosedOther websites ripping off your stuff

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123 4>
Author
Message
Vibrationbaby View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member


Joined: February 13 2004
Status: Offline
Points: 6898
Direct Link To This Post Topic: Other websites ripping off your stuff
    Posted: August 17 2007 at 16:54
I don`t know if this has happened to anyone else here and I`ve brought it up in various PMs. Some of my reviews and the original Guru Guru bio I wrote for progarchives have been stolen by various sites.( I`ve since written a new one). Even parts of some of my reviews have been used in other bios on other sites. Sometimes reworded ,sometimes literally copied out. On a few ocassions this site and my handle for this site ( VB ) have been credited but still??????? Anyone want to comment? I`ve wrote a few pissed off emails to some of these sites but have never recieved any response or had them removed.
Back to Top
andu View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 27 2006
Location: Romania
Status: Offline
Points: 3089
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:00
You should ask the admin team to help you; I remember a case when Fitzcaraldo was shamelessly ripped of several reviews by a user from another site, and Tony R officially asked that site to take action. The results were good, but for that to happen again those sites need to be bona-fide parts. 
Back to Top
Wilcey View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar
VIP Member

Joined: August 11 2005
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 2696
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:04
I found a review I wrote on PA copied word by word (inc my username) on a torrent site......my words being used to ILLEGALLY promote theft from my partner.

THAT STINKS and it still rankles with me......badly. I felt in someway complicit, awful feeling.

Neither the torrent or the review have been removed....although it's in the hands of 'higher powers'........

I understand what you feel, but as long as it's not used in anyway detrimental be flattered, it means they couldn't write anything as well as you have done!

P-C

Edited by prog-chick - August 17 2007 at 17:04
Back to Top
Easy Livin View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: February 21 2004
Location: Scotland
Status: Offline
Points: 15585
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:05
It's a tricky one Vibe.
 
Our legal notice says "Please note that all the intellectual work you supply (reviews, articles, forum posts etc.) to the ProgArchives is also your property and you will be considered responsible for the contents". I think that proabbly means it is up to individuals to take it up with the website using it, if they wish to do so. 
Back to Top
Padraic View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: February 16 2006
Location: Pennsylvania
Status: Offline
Points: 31169
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:14
VB, as Bob says all your posts here (reviews, comments) are your intellectual property, and if you were really willing, you could get a lawyer to at least send the web sites a takedown/cease & desist type letter.  If they ignore you would probably have to sue for copyright infringement.  Is it worth your time and expense to pursue this course of action?  You'll have to decide.  Short of that, I don't anything can force these sites to remove the content.

Sorry VB, plagiarism is a crappy thing to have happen to you (it has happened to me in my professional career Ouch)
Back to Top
laplace View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar

Joined: October 06 2005
Location: popupControl();
Status: Offline
Points: 7606
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:16
I've seen a pair of my reviews appear on someone's blog but quite honestly, he's welcome to 'em ;P I'll only bother to contact people over this sort of thing if the site admins demand it
Back to Top
andu View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 27 2006
Location: Romania
Status: Offline
Points: 3089
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:18
Back to Top
Syzygy View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: December 16 2004
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 7003
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 17 2007 at 17:21
Originally posted by laplace laplace wrote:

I've seen a pair of my reviews appear on someone's blog but quite honestly, he's welcome to 'em ;P I'll only bother to contact people over this sort of thing if the site admins demand it
 
The same thing has happened to me. As long as I'm credited (preferably with a link back to PA) I don't mind, and on the one occasion that I know of where I wasn't credited I contacted the blog owner and he sorted it out almost immediately.
'Like so many of you
I've got my doubts about how much to contribute
to the already rich among us...'

Robert Wyatt, Gloria Gloom


Back to Top
PROGMAN View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar
VIP Member

Joined: February 03 2004
Location: Wales
Status: Offline
Points: 2664
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 31 2007 at 20:32
Is there a way Max and ProgLucky can disable copy/paste on reviews?? or even store them in a different format like flash or PDF kind of thing??

just wondering.


Edited by PROGMAN - August 31 2007 at 20:33
CYMRU AM BYTH
Back to Top
ClemofNazareth View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Prog Folk Researcher

Joined: August 17 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 4659
Direct Link To This Post Posted: August 31 2007 at 20:54
I Google'd my name once and found some reviews copied on other sites. Didn't really bother me except one which was on a download site. Sent the guy an email but never heard back. As far as I know it's still there.

Saw a Proto-Kaw review of mine in Japanese once - that was cool. Probably looked like a reverse-Mandrakeroot from a couple years ago.

(no offense Mandy!).

"Peace is the only battle worth waging."

Albert Camus
Back to Top
bhikkhu View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 06 2006
Location: A² Michigan
Status: Offline
Points: 5109
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 01 2007 at 00:24
My advice is that if you contact the offender as the author of the bio, chances are it will be removed pretty quickly.

The only ones I've seen of mine are being used by the bands to promote their albums. I kind of like that.

(Edit) O.K., on closer inspection it looks like It has happened to me too. Mostly with my biographies. The funniest one is on Timo Laine's website. He used my bio for Symhonic Slam. I can tell you with all honesty, I am not the leading authority on this band.



Edited by bhikkhu - September 01 2007 at 00:42
Back to Top
erik neuteboom View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer


Joined: July 27 2005
Location: Netherlands
Status: Offline
Points: 7659
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 01 2007 at 06:15
I noticed that a lot of commercial sites that are selling progrock album's/DVD's are using my reviews that I wrote for Prog Archives/Progwalhalla, even translated into Italian and Spanish. It's up to M@X to do something about it, I don't mind.
Back to Top
philippe View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: March 14 2004
Location: noosphere
Status: Offline
Points: 3597
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 01 2007 at 08:30
It also happened for me, notably on myspace music & a few  blogs...in most of cases my name is mentionned.
Back to Top
Shakespeare View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member


Joined: July 18 2006
Status: Offline
Points: 7744
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 01 2007 at 08:42
Originally posted by ClemofNazareth ClemofNazareth wrote:

I Google'd my name once and found some reviews copied on other sites.

Yeah, I can't exactly google my name and expect a bunch of prog reviews....LOL
Back to Top
Ivan_Melgar_M View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 27 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 19535
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 01 2007 at 09:04
I found at least 10 of my reviews being used, and even translated to japanese, Portuguese and other languages.
 
Some official band sites used some also.
 
But as long as they mention my name and credit Prog Archives I have no problem.
 
Iván
            
Back to Top
Ricochet View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: February 27 2005
Location: Nauru
Status: Offline
Points: 46301
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 01 2007 at 09:07
Someone copied my En=Trance review once.
Back to Top
Tony R View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: July 16 2004
Location: UK
Status: Offline
Points: 11979
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 04 2007 at 13:47
Be careful these are desperate people we are dealing with. They must be, they've even used my reviews...LOL
Back to Top
Peter View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: January 31 2004
Location: Canada
Status: Offline
Points: 9669
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 04 2007 at 22:02
ConfusedHmmmm... I Googled my name, and got this old review by our Maani (Ian Alterman), where he happened to mention my name. It's listed on Amazon.UK, but the problem is, it's credited to one Jonathan cadby (obviously a CAD!)Angry
 
Reviews Written by
Jonathan D Cadby
Reviewer Rank: 9176 Page: 1 | 2
pixel
Animals
Price: £11.99
< id=handleBuy_B000024D4R_1 name=handleBuy_B000024D4R_1 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B000024D4R name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=%2FevOe27gEz2eToo8mfl6in0lMGU1DUwm8GJMigZMciLhTcty5JVFRizESU%2B%2FxbFprulrE7PngXE%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
Excellent, 19 Aug 2005
Uh oh! This is the second time that Peter Rideout and I agree completely! The concept of this album is as timely now - if not moreso - than it was in 1977. The separation of society into "Pigs" (corporate fat-cats and politicians who "control" everything), "Dogs" (money-obsessed financial types and mid-level managers who do the Pigs' biddings), and "Sheep" (the populace (blue-collar, white-collar, labor) that simply "goes along" with all of it, rarely showing the courage to attempt to change the system) is almost beyond brilliant. And the lyrics reflect that brilliance. But, as Peter notes, it is the music that gives this album its "edge." Gilmour's best work (with the possible exception of The Wall), and Wright's and Mason's best work, all ably "orchestrated" by Waters into a flawless whole. Noe of the most "beautiful" works in prog-rock



Wish You Were Here
Price: £8.98
< id=handleBuy_B000024D4S_2 name=handleBuy_B000024D4S_2 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B000024D4S name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=AkiBFUjzmNyYDMllwvg2ySlhhdxoaB6jz180dhWIiHJtVsFwHbFrprc6v2m%2B2l2lrSd86WAgp3w%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
Essential, 19 Aug 2005
How do you follow-up a global masterpiece like Dark Side? You change the rules. If Dark Side is about the uncatharted madness caused as a result of living in an insane world, Wish You Were Here is about the added madness that ensues as a result of having the world embrace that uncatharted madness on such an absurd scale. If WYWH is a "tribute to Syd Barrett," it is so because Barrett saw that insanity first. But WYWH is also a scathing remonstration of the music industry - a deliberate, mocking attempt to "bite the hand that feeds." And the album succeeds on both levels, as well as, most importantly, on the compositional and musical levels. Not only did Shine On and Wish You Were Here become anthems on a global scale, but the sales of Ovation guitars went through the roof when everyone old enough to play a guitar began playing these songs at every acid-laced party in the world. Floyd was not interested in "topping" themselves after Dark Side; they were simply interested in expressing new thoughts and feelings - and in that they succeeded brilliantly.



Dark Side of the Moon
Price: £8.98
< id=handleBuy_B000024D4P_3 name=handleBuy_B000024D4P_3 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B000024D4P name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=rDOOJPBHoUSLSc781GKGAF2DdlHJ7xk%2BDjgjUD2FukXHg1XHeE%2FgSH9Jg5ZOp%2B1Ku0YifmkKa3I%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
2 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
Essential, 19 Aug 2005
What exactly led to the almost unspeakable success of this album? There is probably no definite answer, but rather an indeterminate zeitgeist at the time of its release. The Apollo moon missions had just ended in 1972, Nixon had just been re-elected, the anti-war movement was at its peak, the "acid" culture was still thriving, and America was in the throes of a post-60s re-self-assessment and as "polarized" as it had been in quite some time. Most importantly, as was true immediately after the assassination of JFK - when the youth of America was looking for something "upbeat" to "fill the hole," and The Beatles materialized almost magically to fill that void - the youth of America in 1972 was looking for something to latch onto. Dark Side became that "thing," for reasons which may never be understood. Yet even bearing the burden of so powerful a "symbol," Dark Side stands on its own as a musical and production achievement with few equals, either then or since. For prog-rock to become not only cross-musical but cross-cultural was something none of us who were around at the time could ever have conceived of. Yet happen it did. Was it just the "commercial" quality of some of the "songs?" Personally, I doubt it. There was an "experience" in listening to Dark Side in toto that could not be gleaned, even minimally, from hearing "Money" or "Us and Them" on AOR radio. What made it so "special" was that it was a "shared" experience - like the first time we listened to Sgt. Pepper, Electric Ladyland or other "shared" musical experiences in the 60s and early 70s. Ultimately, Dark Side has both a "metaphysical" quality to it - vis-a-vis its place in time - and a broad-based compositional-musical quality that all but defined much of the music of its time. And although one can quibble over its internal flaws (assuming it has any, which I do not believe), or its place in Floyd's oeuvre - especially its alleged "commercial" qualities - it is the very impossibility of pinning down its brilliance that makes it a "masterpiece," and, along with Pepper and Court, one of the three absolutely quintessential albums of the genre.



The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Price: £7.98
< id=handleBuy_B000026LE7_4 name=handleBuy_B000026LE7_4 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B000026LE7 name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=nxfIOcA%2BRFwiCbKGK5JGqnou9fP1G0dLuCghicrOHGxCv1BKUPIS%2BOmpNpPqI22Lqa2ghNAxUo4%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
Excellent addition, 19 Aug 2005
With the possible exception of Court of the Crimson King, the best debut album by any group in ANY genre. Maybe it was the acid, maybe its was the genius of Syd Barrett (and/or Roger Waters), maybe it was London in 1967. Whatever. Although comparatively "immature" next to their later work, Piper stands as a towering achievement in prog-rock, and remains among a handful of standard-bearers in the genre.



Misplaced Childhood
Price: £4.97
< id=handleBuy_B00004W3L3_5 name=handleBuy_B00004W3L3_5 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B00004W3L3 name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=Ym3TK8vrNCTEJ6k2IzwYwSlEGFf4UWiQkhP%2BP7GuvVb4%2B4R1w16E63wc2L1ekE%2FnxgiAqB4Rk%2FQ%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
Must-have, 19 Aug 2005
The best of the Fish-era Marillion albums, Childhood has an "edge" that was lacking on Script and Fugazi. From the sweetness of "Kayleigh" to the edgy jokiness of "Lavender," from the solid-rock brilliance of "Heart of Lothian" (one of the best rockers in prog-rock) to the cathartic "Childhood's End," Fish & Co. are at their combined musical peak here. A must-have for prog-rock fans.



Myths and Legends of King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table [CASSETTE]
Availability: Currently unavailable

 
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
Must-have, 19 Aug 2005
On "Six Wives" (1973), Wakeman experimented with his plethora of keyboards, playing around with different sounds and textures, and creating fabulous compositions using those sounds and textures. On "Journey to the Centre of the Earth" (1974), he made his first attempt to meld rock, orchestra and chorus in a storytelling genre, and was generally successful, though the effort was ultimately "immature." With "Myths and Legends," Wakeman hits the perfect blending of rock, orchestra and chorus, creating an amazing album that will send chills up your spine.

The album opens with a deep voice speaking the famous inscription on the stone that held the legendary sword, Excalibur: "Whosoever pulleth this sword from this stone and anvil is the trueborn king of all Britain." It then launches into the main theme - a majestic and perfect medieval motif - which segues directly into the first song, "Arthur," which tells of the quest to find a new king. Following this is "Lady of the Lake," the first of three short acappella vocal vingnettes, full of beautiful medieval harmonies. This brings us to "Guinevere," which tells of Arthur's wife's precarious situation - being loved by, and in love with, both Arthur and Lancelot. It also contains the first of many excellent Wakeman solos, during a beautiful, mellow jam. We then come to the centerpiece of the album, "Sir Lancelot and the Black Knight," which may not only be the most perfect single blending of rock, orchestra and chorus ever written, but among the best, most exciting prog-rock compositions ever written. Opening with a "restatement" of the main theme, it launches quickly into successive single measures of 7/8, 8/8, 9/8 and 10/8, settling into 7/8. After a couple of verses, it moves into an extended jam which contains some of Wakeman's most spine-tingling solos. I could listen to this single piece over and over and never tire of it. We then have the second of the brief acappella vocal vignettes, introducing us to the next composition, "Merlin the Magician," a multi-section instrumental. The second section, a 5/4 jam, contains more of Wakeman's most compelling solo work. The third section is repeated twice, the first time using multi-layered keyboards (including one that sounds like a banjo!), the second time arranged for orchestra. We then have the third and final acappella vignette, introducing us to our next character, "Sir Galahad," which segues into the final composition, "The Last Battle." Opening with a great double entendre - "Gone are the days of the knights" - it tells of the end of the Round Table, and Arthur's death, and features another mellow jam containing yet more marvelous Wakeman solo work, and ends with a masterfully orchestrated final statement of the main theme.

If a masterpiece is a work which is compositionally, musically, vocally and lyrically perfect, in which not a single note is out of place or misused, and which features exceptional production qualities, then "Myths and Legends" is an unequivocal masterpiece. So much so, in my opinion, that I have included it in my "desert island discs (DIDs)"; i.e., one of the ten albums I would choose to take to a desert island if I was confined to only ten albums. In any event, "Myths and Legends" is a must-have for any serious prog collection.



Forget Yourself
Price: £7.98
< id=handleBuy_B0000AZKI6_7 name=handleBuy_B0000AZKI6_7 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B0000AZKI6 name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=wcEJ6qMjc4PBJfM5aUJp62DUUrgAZKrmcyiylJte5x803NKKdM%2BrCQjDyH6HfNFHaW7t%2FbH5G1w%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
Thirteenth in a series, 19 Aug 2005
(Note: Prior to releasing "Forget Yourself," The Church released a two-disc CD entitled "Parallel Universe." The first disc contains techno "remixes" of songs on "After Everything Now This," done by various people, and is, to my mind, unlistenable. However, the second disc contains six new songs from the AENT sessions, and is highly recommended.)

Although it is gratifying to see this album called "so different" and "the first album of the new millenium justified to have been recorded in it" (high praise indeed!), there is actually little on this album that was not presaged by "Hologram of Baal" and "After Everything Now This." That said, "Forget Yourself" IS an exceptional, immensely creative, virtually flawless album that shows yet again that The Church has become one of the chief standard-bearers of the prog-rock genre.

"Sealine" launches us immediately into a textured atmosphere as dense as anything the band has ever created, with fuzzed-out echo-guitars and treated drums, a radical chord progression (there are quite a few on the album), great guitar work, and a strong vocal from Kilbey, delivering yet another brilliant song-poem. "Song in Space" (a fave, with yet another amazing Kilbey song-poem) is a sound-filled composition full of retro-60s psychedelia, with hints of Beatles, Cream, and Moody Blues, filtered through the band's unique approach. "The Theater and Its Double" opens with one of the most wonderful guitar/drum beat figures the band has yet employed, moving into a quasi-arhythmic chorus section of arpeggiated guitar and breathy, hypnotic vocals, and ends with some great guitar work. "Telepath" opens with the band's most beautiful harmonies to date, moving into a nice arrangement of arpeggiated guitar, a nice drum figure, solid bass, and (need I say it?) yet another brilliant Kilbey song-poem, all surrounded in a dense atmosphere, especially in the middle and end sections. "See Your Lights" is a slight more straight-ahead light rocker propelled by dual guitars, solid drumming and bass work, and a truly neat guitar figure separating chorus from verse. "Lay Low" (another fave) opens with a bizarre keyboard, a neat guitar figure, and solid bass and drums, and quickly becomes one of the band's most compelling arrangements, with off-time drumming in the verses, stop-and-start vocals, and a powerful, sound-filled chorus that is uniquely The Church. "Maya" is a textured ballad, beautifully executed in a classic Church arrangement, with verses reminiscent of "Tranquility" (from "Hologram of Baal"). Recalling both "Louisiana" and "Buffalo" (from "Hologram of Baal"), "Appalatia" is a gorgeous arrangement (and another fave), and possibly Koppes' best work, including his strongest-ever vocal. "June" is a strange, almost solemn ballad with a straight-ahead approach. "Don't You Fall" - a nice, if mildly paranoid, light rocker - is a true Church original, harking back to their "Heyday" and "Starfish" period. With a similar opening figure to "Dome" (from "Priest=Aura"), "I Kept Everything" (yet another fave) has a fabulous Kilbey song-poem, supported by a beautiful arrangement of echo-guitar, great bass work, and heavily textured atmosphere. "Nothing Seeker" opens with powerful bass work, wild wah-wah guitar, heavy drumming and ultra-texture, and has a quick-stop chorus and a wild finish. "Reversal" (yup, another fave) has one of the band's best-ever textured arrangements, including a neat Beatle-esque bridge, and some of the best vocal textures the band has created. "Summer" (another ballad heavily reminiscent of "Tranquility") closes the first disc in true Church style with a beautiful, heavily textured, sound-filled arrangement, including an increasingly present grand piano. (Needless to say, as with any album containing heavily-textured music, this should be listened to first with headphones. And the first time it is played externally, it should be played loud.)

Not content to leave well enough alone (thank God!), The Church included a bonus disc featuring three additional compositions. It is in the first of these that the band does something truly extraordinary: they add to the lexicon of sound textures possible using standard instruments and studio tricks. With the 14-minute experimental instrumental, "Serpent Easy," the band proves that not every possible sound/texture has already been created and/or used by Pink Floyd, Moody Blues, Yes, Genesis et al. Opening with a "2001: A Space Odyssey"-type rumble, the band moves through a succession of sounds and textures that run the gamut from fairly ordinary to highly creative, to absolutely mind-blowing. (Note that I do not recommend listening to this while under the influence of any hallucinogenic substances!) "Cantilever" is an extended composition with a neat, quasi-experimental, sound-filled arrangement, plus a truly great Kilbey song-poem, delivered using some of the strangest vocal inflections he has ever used. "Moodertronic" is a respectful nod to Frippertronics, with a couple of repeating guitar figures, plus a lightly synth-textured, Eno-esque atmosphere.

Although I am not prepared to call this the definitive Church album - and, although I want to, I'm not going to suggest that the band won't ever be able to top it, since I've been wrong not twice but thrice in this regard - there is no question that the sheer creativity on "Forget Yourself" is phenomenal, that the album may in fact set a new bar for the band, and that it belongs in any important collection of prog-rock. (As an aside, has anyone considered what the "real" name of this album is? Also, any thoughts as to what all the phrases on the insert refer to?)



Priest = Aura
Availability: Currently unavailable

 
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
Eighth in a series, 19 Aug 2005
With "Priest=Aura" - The Church's second "breakthrough" album - the band has unequivocally "arrived" as a progressive band to be reckoned with, exactly 10 years after their debut. Gone is any pretension of "hit-making," or even a "standard" approach. They have fully accepted who they are (and who their influences are), and have shaped and molded their sound into something mature, expansive, compelling and uncompromisingly creative. They have also mastered - truly mastered - the recording studio, taking full advantage of what can be done. (Needless to say, this album should be listened to with headphones.) In these regards, this album and its follow-up ("Sometime Anywhere") are their "Sgt. Pepper" and "Magical Mystery Tour," and belong in any collection of truly great prog-rock.

Beginning with the Moodies-like chords and expansive reverbed atmosphere at the opening of "Aura," you know that something different and wonderful has happened to the band. Kilbey then delivers a tour-de-force tale (in his now-trademark talk-singing style) of the power of love over hate, undergirded by a masterful arrangement full of solid keyboards, minimalist guitars, and almost impossibly lush atmospheres, all building to an outro that Floyd would be proud to claim as their own. "Ripple" has the band in superb form: solid beat, great guitar work, a truly haunting key change between verse and chorus, a wonderful instrumental break, another great outro, and another great "tale" from Kilbey. "Paradox" takes us into "dream" territory, with excellent interplay between guitars and keyboards, and hypnotic double vocals. "Lustre" is the "new" Church at its finest and most original, with a fantastic arrangement full of exciting key and texture changes, and yet another great "story" from Kilbey. "Swan Lake" is the first of three "mini-tunes" on the album (all under 2.5 minutes). Sardonically mocking, it is a beautifully concise waltz-time composition. "Feel" has a U2 feel, complete with a hopelessly infectious beat and Edge-like guitar riff, but filtered through the band's unique sensibilities. "Mistress" is a true Church original, clearly marking the band's unique brand of storytelling, arrangement and texture. "Kings" is another U2-ish song, with another Edge-inspired guitar riff and another infectious beat, along with another great Kilbey song-poem, again all filtered through the band's unique sensibilities. "Dome" is one of Kilbey's most poignant song-poems, underpinned by a deceptively simple arrangement. "Witch Hunt" is the second waltz-time "mini-tune," this time a humorous ditty about the dangers of helping people. "The Illusionist" is the story of a carnival-based pseudo-magician, with an extraordinary rhyming lyric supported by another deceptively simple arrangement (sort of like Dylan meets Floyd). "Old Flame" is the final "mini-tune," this one a gorgeous, bittersweet double-guitar piece. "Chaos" is an extended composition with the band's most aggressive performance thus far, including a neat beat (dig that subtle cabasa in the verses!), a Fripp-ish guitar figure, and a length Crimzoid instrumental section. "Film" closes the album with another great Church instrumental, this time an appropriately-titled composition that might have served well on a film score.

"Priest=Aura" is not simply a perfect album (no bad, or even "lesser," songs), but one on which not a single note or idea is out of place. From this point forward, The Church would produce only top-quality progressive albums full of creative, compelling and often exciting music.



Seance
Price: £17.49
< id=handleBuy_B000069AUD_9 name=handleBuy_B000069AUD_9 =/gp/product/handle-buy-/ref=cm_cr-mr-add-to-cart/203-6370126-0815150 method=post>< id=ASIN = value=B000069AUD name=ASIN>< id=offerListingID = value=ndrz4QvcgHbODT7kGeqTeKREepFgvLXMq0Su%2BlVt7X5vfus4pKQXimFnW5U8217WW1Kai2Tvemc%3D name=offerListingID>< = height=22 width=109 ="http://ec1.s-amazon.com/s/G/02/x-locale/compare/add-to-cart--v2._V32698769_.gif" =3 border=0 name=submit.add-to-cart>
Availability: In stock

 
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
Even greater things to come, 19 Aug 2005
[Third in a series] From the opening notes of "Fly," you can tell that The Church had become a far more confident band, and was developing a more "textured" and (even if not fully developed yet) progressive sound: the keyboard in the chorus is both strong and perfect, the strings (a new element) are used tastefully and appropriately, and the use of percussion instead of drums signals a very different approach to writing and arrangement. (As an aside, "Fly" may be the most perfect 2-minute song in progressive rock.) "Fly" leads directly into "One Day" with a strong, Beatle-esque guitar, a slightly syncopated backbeat, and Kilbey's first virtually monotone delivery, which not only works effectively, but is actually quite compelling. (Peter Koppes also takes a neat solo.) "Electric" opens with a nice rhythm guitar/drum pattern again, and a very interesting lead guitar part. The keyboard and general arrangement of the chorus are lush with progressive sensibilities. "It's No Reason" is the first Church song to open with and feature keyboards, and the chorus is a beautiful, melancholy mix of acoustic guitar, keyboards, and a subtle string arrangement, giving it an almost Moody Blues-ish quality. "Travel By Thought" is a mish-mash of progressive elements, and seems more like an "experiment" than a cohesive idea (it also sounds like a "nod" to XTC's "Travels in Nihilon," which was released the year before and has a very similar drum figure and general arrangment). "Disappear" makes effective use of acoustic guitar, a simple syncopated beat (they were starting to get really good at this - and would get even better in the future), and Harrison-esque lead fills. "Electric Lash" finds the band having some fun with its former approach (even slyly bringing in the guitar figure from "Sisters"), although with a strange snare effect and a nice keyboard figure. "Now I Wonder Why" is underpinned by a wonderful McCartney-esque bass figure (is there a pattern developing here?...), which at times follows the vocal. The keyboards at the bridge add a nice touch. "Dropping Names" is an interesting amalgam of the band's former and current approaches: a solid rock beat and jangly guitars, mixed with subtle keyboards, sound effects, textures, etc. "It Doesn't Change" closes the album with a haunting, quasi-paranoid (read "Floydian"), minimalist arrangement of arpeggiated guitar, drums, solid bass, and increasingly present keyboards - an approach that would eventually become part of their "signature" sound. Overall, "Seance" is the band's first "progressive" album, in as much as they were clearly applying their growing progressive sensibilities in a conscious manner. And given the "basic rock" approach of the majority of their prior material, "Seance" is a truly unexpected and wonderful offering. As importantly, it was the beginning of the first of three short "periods" that the band would go through, all of which were initiated by breakthrough albums. "Seance" was to The Church's "growth" as "Foxtrot" was to Genesis, "Time and A Word" was to Yes, and "Atom Heart Mother" was to Pink Floyd - all of those albums were great, but presaged even greater things to come.



Space Revolver
Availability: Currently unavailable

 
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
Highly recommended, 19 Aug 2005
At first spin this album did not attract me because to me the music seemed like being forced to be like this and the band really neglect the melodic side of a composition. With couple of spins, my appreciation towards the album grew significantly - even I talked to myself that the key to enjoy this album is the complexity and abrupt change in style offered by the music. Yes, it's similar with my first experience in mid seventies with Yes "Tales from Topographic Ocean" album which I considered too complex and not melodic at all. But it grew significantly later. Now, come a question on how to enjoy a music from complexity standpoint? I only have one recipe: let the music flow into your mind and cascade down into your heart, steadily, even though it takes a long time.

Having done so, I even now amazed with the fact that by now I fully can enjoy the full stream (from start to end) of the opening track "I Am The Sun - Part One" (15:03) when at first listen I completely rejected. I don't really know why did I hate the song that is now becoming one of my favorite TFK tracks? Consciously, I really now enjoy this wonderful and energetic track from its intro, all the way through complex arrangements and variations until the music really ends. There are so many style changes from upbeat music into avant-garde and jazz improvisations in the middle of the track till end. It's really a wonderful composition. I even can enjoy the mellow track with jazz touch "Dream On Dreamer" (2:43).

"Rumble Fish Twist" (8:06) is an instrumental piece that starts off with sound effects followed with hard driving rhythm music in complex arrangements and relatively fast tempo. The keyboard provides great sound effects accompanied with solid bass lines, guitar rhythm and machine-gun drumming. The guitar solo is truly stunning. I like also the part where Michael Stolt is given a space to give his wonderful bass guitar solo even though in a short time. The music suddenly moves into quiet passage in a spacey nuance. Bass guitar shows off the talent here. What a great musical break!

Wow! "Monster Within" (12:55) is really an energetic song with a very uplifting mood. This track really elevates my emotion especially hearing the powerful vocal by Hasse Folberg and Roine Stolt. It's an adrenalin exploder, really. The music changes in style in the middle of the track with guitar solo and inventive keyboard work. The song ends in uplifting mood at the end part with a somewhat blues influence music. "Chicken Farmer Song" (5:09) and "Underdog" (5:29) are bit light in terms composition but it's still an excellent song. "You Don't Know What You've Got" (2:39) is a ballad with acoustic guitar rhythm.

"Slave To Money" (7:30) brings the music back into a rather complex arrangements but with a smooth flow from start to middle until it reaches a change in style and complexity. "A Kings Prayer" (6:02) is relatively slow track with ambient and ballad style, accessible to most listeners as it has memorable choruses. The album concludes with "I Am The Sun - Part Two" (10:48) beautifully.

Overall, it's a highly recommended album. Keep on proggin'

 
***************************************************************************************
I think  The Church reviews are Maani's too. Also, if I'm not mistaken, isn't that one of Gatot's, with his signature "keep on proggin!" closer?
 
You folks might recognize others. This "Cadby" guy is a rip-off artist -- this does not involve me directly, but now what to do? These are PA reviews, and this royal JERKSTAIN Cadby is taking the credit! ConfusedAngry


Edited by Peter - September 05 2007 at 00:00
"And, has thou slain the Jabberwock?
Come to my arms, my beamish boy!
O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!'
He chortled in his joy.
Back to Top
sircosick View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member


Joined: January 29 2007
Location: Chile
Status: Offline
Points: 1264
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 04 2007 at 22:54
LOLLOL
The best you can is good enough...
Back to Top
Peter View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: January 31 2004
Location: Canada
Status: Offline
Points: 9669
Direct Link To This Post Posted: September 05 2007 at 00:04
Originally posted by sircosick sircosick wrote:

LOLLOL
Confused I wasn't joking. This thieving dickweed Cadby  pisses me off!
 
(BTW, I did find some of my Tangerine Dream reviews elsewhere, but myself and PA were credited there.)
"And, has thou slain the Jabberwock?
Come to my arms, my beamish boy!
O frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!'
He chortled in his joy.
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123 4>

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.211 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.