prog ballad - Progressive Rock Music Forum

I'm surprised nobody has mentioned this beautiful Gentle Giant ballad. https://youtu.be/DYyMsBSnJ88

Edited by klaatuarethebeatles - February 11 2019 at 01:51

Angra - Deep Blue (from Holy Land).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Czfox3aTJ00

moshkito wrote:

Hi,

Unbelievable ... the listing is all songs with lyrics ... as if a "ballad" has not existed for hundreds of years ... it only shows how musically unawares we are?

I'll take Albinoni's Adagio in G ... maybe followed by Terje Rypdal's Adagietto!

No, what is unbelievable is you continue to infer other people are ignorant when your ignorance is quite clear. The irony here is other posters are using the proper context, whether popular or in the more proper historical sense, for a ballad, but you are not.

Perhaps it is because English is not your first language (and based on how you write, more likely third or fourth down the list), but a "ballad" by its very nature requires lyrics. This has been the nature of ballads since the 13th century. They are narrative songs, originally styled in quatrains (ballad stanzas). With words/lyrics as a requirement.

From a non-song compositional point of view, poetic ballads (literary ballads) are written in the same style. With words. Robert Burns, Walter Scott, Goethe, Coleridge, Keats, Poe, Wordsworth, Oscar Wilde, Christine Rossetti, Kipling -- all wrote literary ballads. Not surprisingly, each of these poets used words for their ballads.

So, in the sense of an "adagio", you may call it whatever you want beyond "adagio", but it is not a "ballad" in the literary and historical perspective. So no one who has commented thus far is wrong or "unaware" about their selections, per se. In fact, they are using the term in a far more correct sense than you have.

Edited by The Dark Elf - February 17 2019 at 09:41

...a vigorous circular motion hitherto unknown to the people of this area, but destined
to take the place of the mud shark in your mythology...

Cristi wrote:

Originally posted by klaatuarethebeatles

klaatuarethebeatles wrote:

I'm surprised nobody has mentioned this beautiful Gentle Giant ballad. https://youtu.be/DYyMsBSnJ88

link does not work for me, why you don't just mention the song name.

or use the Insert Movie function.

Yes - And You And I

Arena - Mea Culpa

Arena - Friday's Dream

The Flower Kings - The Way the Waters Are Moving

The Flower Kings - A King's Prayer

Genesis - Undertow

IQ - One Fatal Mistake

Kate Bush - A Coral Room

Kate Bush - The Man with the Child In His Eyes

Kate Bush - This Woman's Work

King Crimson - Matte Kudasai

King Crimson - Epitaph

King Crimson - Islands

Marillion - Runaway

Marillion - The Hollow Man

Marillion - Sugar Mice

Marillion - Fantastic Place

Marillion - Seasons End

Marillion - The Sky Above the Rain

Marillion - Estonia

Opeth - Isolation Years

Opeth - Burden

Pain of Salvation - Iter Impius

Pain of Salvation - Second Love

Pendragon - Starfish and the Moon

Pendragon - Whirlwind

Pendragon - If I Were the Wind (And You Were the Rain)

Pendragon - It's Only Me

Peter Gabriel - Here Comes the Flood

Peter Gabriel - Biko

Peter Gabriel - Wallflower

Peter Gabriel - Don't Give Up

Peter Gabriel - Washing of the Water

Phideaux - Crumble

Phideaux - Infinite Supply

Pink Floyd - Nobody Home

Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here

Radiohead - Nude

Radiohead - Motion Picture Soundtrack

Radiohead - Exit Music (For a Film)

Rush - The Garden

Rush - Nobody's Hero

Rush - Closer to the Heart

Yes - Turn of the Century

Yes - Soon

Here's another cool one. Another Day Like Superman by Anyone's Daughter.

“On the day of my creation, I fell in love with education. And overcoming all frustration, a teacher I became.”
— Ernest Vong