Jethro Tull vs Led Zeppelin

Not a big fan of either of them, but Zeppelin 

Tull for me, very original band ,Led Zeppelin have faded badly in my view, can't get past the fact they are a band who built their career on plagiarism

Jethro Tull is my favorite band period! I do think Led Zeppelin was a great rock band!

Jethro Tull.

Because Jethro Tull.

I could care less who stole from what - I can simply relate more successfully to the work of Ian Anderson. That BABY BABY BABY OHHH WOMAN OHHH IM CONFUSED AND ICE AND SNOW AND LORD OF THE RINGS BABY OHHHHH sh*t really grates on my nerves. 

Alitare wrote: I could care less who stole from what - I can simply relate more successfully to the work of Ian Anderson. That BABY BABY BABY OHHH WOMAN OHHH IM CONFUSED AND ICE AND SNOW AND LORD OF THE RINGS BABY OHHHHH sh*t really grates on my nerves.

That is a really good summary of LZ lyrics.

thellama73 wrote: Alitare wrote: I could care less who stole from what - I can simply relate more successfully to the work of Ian Anderson. That BABY BABY BABY OHHH WOMAN OHHH IM CONFUSED AND ICE AND SNOW AND LORD OF THE RINGS BABY OHHHHH sh*t really grates on my nerves.  That is a really good summary of LZ lyrics.

And a completely retarded observation.

I really like many songs of Led Zeppelin, they have so many classics, not all of which I like as much, but those I do like are among the best songs I could think of. However, Jethro Tull has many such songs too, and I have ended up finding many more songs I really like from Tull, and that rocking flute is really wonderful, so I have to go with Tull. I would have thought that here Tull would have the clear advantage in votes, but I guess Zeppelin is just too great a band here. Once I did a poll comparing Zeppelin with Rush, and so far Rush did better, having the clear advantage for a long time. Though last time I saw the poll surfacing around, I think Zeppelin had at last gotten their (minor) lead.
On a bit unrelated question, anyone knows who plays the flute on Stairway to Heaven? I never saw it credited on the album, or anywhere else, and I believe it must be a real flute, not synths. I know both Zeppelin and Tull were on the same studio when Zeppelin recorded the fourth album, so I might like to wonder if by chance it could have been Anderson, though certainly I haven't read anything at all from him saying such thing might have happened.
Also, when Zeppelin and Tull toured together, I think it would have been great if Anderson had guested on that song playing the flute live with them, but I believe that never actually happened, quiet a lost oportunity, in my opinion.

Dellinger wrote: Also, when Zeppelin and Tull toured together, I think it would have been great if Anderson had guested on that song playing the flute live with them, but I believe that never actually happened, quiet a lost oportunity, in my opinion.

Anderson tells a story about that on the Aqualung remaster about how he once mentioned to Plant "with my lyrics and Zeppelin's music, we could really have something."        That was the end of any friendship between the bands.

Dellinger wrote: I really like many songs of Led Zeppelin, they have so many classics, not all of which I like as much, but those I do like are among the best songs I could think of. However, Jethro Tull has many such songs too, and I have ended up finding many more songs I really like from Tull, and that rocking flute is really wonderful, so I have to go with Tull. I would have thought that here Tull would have the clear advantage in votes, but I guess Zeppelin is just too great a band here. Once I did a poll comparing Zeppelin with Rush, and so far Rush did better, having the clear advantage for a long time. Though last time I saw the poll surfacing around, I think Zeppelin had at last gotten their (minor) lead. On a bit unrelated question, anyone knows who plays the flute on Stairway to Heaven? I never saw it credited on the album, or anywhere else, and I believe it must be a real flute, not synths. I know both Zeppelin and Tull were on the same studio when Zeppelin recorded the fourth album, so I might like to wonder if by chance it could have been Anderson, though certainly I haven't read anything at all from him saying such thing might have happened. Also, when Zeppelin and Tull toured together, I think it would have been great if Anderson had guested on that song playing the flute live with them, but I believe that never actually happened, quiet a lost oportunity, in my opinion.

JPJ is a multi instrumentalist, so it can be very much he who plays the flute, as he also does the most of the piano, arrangements, and mellotrons, as he have a degree in music, he knows more then play bass, he also can rock a warr bass and chapman stick.