Duplicated entries

JLocke wrote: snobb wrote: Someone just added new Hendrix album once again. This should be deleted:   http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=27871 Well, if it would quite being moved to the 'compilations' section and be left alone in the 'studio albums' section where it belongs, people would actually see it, and quite uploading it.  The content on that album wasn't taken from previous releases, and the songs WERE taken from a studio session by Hendrix that are unique to this release. So it's a studio album.

I like your reasoning on that Micah, even if the idea of a post-humus studio album is a little creepy.

I thought long before adding Hendrix under compilations ( to be honest, I added it first under studio albums, but than transfered). I believe that label would like to see it as studio one, in fact all the marketing is done as this. But in real life there are all but one slightly different versions of previously released songs ( so one really new could be counted as "bonus"), and nothing was recorded specially for this album.

snobb wrote: I thought long before adding Hendrix under compilations ( to be honest, I added it first under studio albums, but than transfered). I believe that label would like to see it as studio one, in fact all the marketing is done as this. But in real life there are all but one slightly different versions of previously released songs ( so one really new could be counted as "bonus"), and nothing was recorded specially for this album.   So, I decided it's more true compilation,than studio one ( we understand that no one never worked in studio to record material FOR this album). But doesn't matter, this, firstly added version has firs review as well,so it should stay. It's not a big deal just to transfer it into studio albums (if).

JLocke wrote: Rune2000 wrote: What is the reasoning behind two versions of Transatlantic's Bridge Across Forever album listed? http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=1342 http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=1343 Their latest album The Whirlwind has also a Limited Edition version so should it be added as well? ^ I've never understood that, either. The same thing has been done with Henry Cow's reissues. It's basically an excuse for us to boost our reviews number by simply reviewing the same album twice (one review per version). While I do enjoy that quite a bit, it makes for some confused newcomers, I'm sure.

Thank you for your response!
I completely agree with you on Henry Cow reissues as well. Just like with Transatlantic albums those were also added back-to-back which, together with the lack of any info on the issue, would suggest that this whole discussion has been taken up before. In that case, could somebody please guide me to that forum topic.
Otherwise I will have to start adding all the Special Edition versions of Dream Theater/Transatlantic etc. just to see what happens.

thanks, it's gone

Rune2000 wrote: I'm not sure that this entry should be listed as a studio album: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=28062

I might be mistaking but aren't these two Bowie live albums the same:

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=24991

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=18804

snobb wrote: Rune2000 wrote: I might be mistaking but aren't these two Bowie live albums the same: http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=24991 http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=18804 It is an old discussion   IMO, 1972 release was kind of bootleg (or specific limited edition), and all re-releases circulated mostly in form of different bootlegs as well. (Some info about this release is placed on its page on PA).   According to David Bowie official site, which should be counted as serious source, the first official release of this concert is next one, you mention.So - it still exists on PA as you see

Thanks for the info and fast response!
In that case I guess it makes sense to keep both.

Double entries here for Porcupine Tree's Ilosaarirock.

Original:
http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=22673

Duplicate:
http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=28926

These two Omar Rodriguez Lopez & John Frusciante releases look the same:

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=29176

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=28799