Is anyone else getting kind of sick of Pink Floyd?

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

       [/QUOTE] 
You've said a lot here and not much that I can agree with,

If all a kid hears while he is growing up is Clapton and that does not inspire him to go and explore other guitarists then he's not a music fan. If someone hasn't by this stage in the game worked out that there are many flavours of Progressive Rock, of which Pink Floyd is but one example then they are not a Progressive Rock fan: if someone likes Gentle Giant or Van der Graaf Generator then they are not going to have false expectations of Pink Floyd unless they've lived in a GG & VdGG only vacuum for the past 40 years; similarily if a symphonic rock fan doesn't think Floyd sounds Prog to them then they need to get out more. Whether you compare The Beatles with 1910 Fruit Gum Company or Simon Dupree And The Big Sound matters little when all of them had hit singles, you need to compare them to all the millions of wannabe failed pop songs to get a true picture of how difficult it is to write a hit.

Progressive rock fans gauge their music on merit and merit alone, we are (relatively) immune to promotional advertising and hype, we make our own minds-up based on what we hear. If Pink Floyd were a fly-by-night one hit wonder then I'd agree with your incredulity at their success, but that they have acquired this acclaim over the course of 40 years, long after the EMI/Capitol publicity machine had ground to a lumbering halt, then I cannot agree; that they have acquired fans young and old along the way without excessive hype, pretty-boy posters, charismatic front-men and dayglo lunchboxes in Wal*mart suggests to me that it is the music alone that is doing this, that somewhere in that lack lustre musicianship and technoflash guitar playing, the music is enough and that the music is Prog enough. (Look through the 5-star reviews for any PF album ... most of them are not by die-hard Floyd fans)

Floyd fans are not touchy, they are not confused, nor do they place them on some mythical Prog pedestal. Floyd fans are well aware of the band's problems and limitations. After all they've been told enough times, some of it must be getting through by now. 
 [/QUOTE] 

Everything you have said for the most part is true and I agree with your insight a hundred percent. It's great to read your post reply. You are very informative and have fantastic insight. Some people dread reading this type of conversing but, I love your view points and I am really impressed with your knowledge. It's true that a kid who does not investigate more than Clapton is not a true music fan. Experience with musicians and students is a real awakening for me at times. I know that you may not believe me and I am not intent on going against your word. I have met many fantastic guitar players and keyboardists who sadly do not travel a road beyond Clapton. That realization within itself kills me. I have always been a bit confused about it. It might be the area that I reside in. Or possibly some really talented adults and  kids do not absorb music culture to that degree. It's hard to believe that a person would have abundance of talent and close doors on music history. It's quite insane when a kid has been working so hard to play a Clapton or Beck piece and progresses at a slow pace, while the next student has the ability to learn and play a technical fusion piece without effort in about 20 minutes time, then turns to me and says: please don't ask me to play this kind of music again, lets get back to playing Mississippi Queen by Mountain.    This example (which is based on years of experience), is what drives me to pose the simple but un-answered question in my mind as to how and why this happens? I am blown away by this reality and don't really have an answer for it. I am positive and more than willing to give adults and kids what they really want out of music. They just baffle me beyond belief. How do you describe the meaning of this? Or if there even is one? Don't you think this is strange? or is the reason or rhyme staring me in the face? But I think that your point sums it up, no matter how many musicians I have witnessed with this mentality.  