Forum Home > Other music related lounges > Proto-Prog and Prog-Related Lounge

New Posts

FAQ

Queen?Prog Related?

Post Reply

Page 12 3 >

Author

Message

Topic Search

Topic Options

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Topic: Queen?Prog Related?
Posted: August 24 2006 at 10:15

toolis wrote:

Arrrghus wrote:

toolis wrote:

i strongly suggest that you put Queen under the Symphonic Prog genre...

NO!!!!

They should be in art rock.

maybe... anyways, as i have written in my previous posts i'm not the suitest person to decide which genre Queen should be under but there should definitely be X prog and not prog related...

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Posted: August 24 2006 at 10:13

Arrrghus wrote:

toolis wrote:

i strongly suggest that you put Queen under the Symphonic Prog genre...

NO!!!!

They should be in art rock.

Edited by toolis - August 24 2006 at 13:14

Arrrghus

Forum Senior Member

Joined: July 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 5296

Posted: August 23 2006 at 21:35

toolis wrote:

i strongly suggest that you put Queen under the Symphonic Prog genre...

NO!!!!

They should be in art rock.

Edited by Arrrghus - August 23 2006 at 21:36

Certif1ed

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 08 2004
Location: England
Status: Offline
Points: 7559

Posted: August 23 2006 at 03:38

Gah!

I had a beautiful response, all neatly laid out and everything... then the forum software borked and I lost it.

This time-out thing really is annoying - it only seems to time out when I'm actively composing a long reply, yet I can go away and leave it logged in and idle overnight, and it will remain logged in!

Anyway, that's a rant for the forum issues thread - here it would seem that once Art Rock has been tidied up, the term "Symphonic" should be addressed so that it is better rooted in reality - never mind what "everyone" thinks.

As for Queen, they bothered to put technicalities in their music like the other Prog Greats - so I think it's courteous to discover what they did and how before deciding whether they fit the category or not, instead of going by some arbitrary gut or herd feeling - as with the term "Symmphonic", and even "Prog Rock".

Edited by Certif1ed - August 23 2006 at 03:38

The important thing is not to stop questioning.

Ivan_Melgar_M View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 27 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 19535

Posted: August 21 2006 at 13:52

Certif1ed wrote:

Actually, not all the Prog community "gets them" - that is a generalisation of the "I've always believed this, therefore everyone does" type - hence this discussion. If the term was so clear-cut, everyone would know what it meant.

Actually Certified, in this case I insist thatthe whole community recignizes the term SAymphonic, there are more han 100 Prog sites in the net and ALL OF THEM include the word the SYMPHONIC to describe a sub-genre or category and bands like Yes, Genesis or ELP are in most of them

And the pronunication is not the issue here

It's not just pronuciation Cert Potato is English and Patata is Spanish, two different languages that seems sometimes we are talking.

The term Symphonic is not a fashion, it0's solid as a rock in the Prog community, there are others that have changed and Prog Archives tries to keep with times.

Art Rock, for example, is not bands like Roxy Music and their ilk - no matter who the term was first applied to. The two terms already have serviceable meanings, and there's no need to pollute them.

The definition on this site agrees, on the whole, with my take:

"Art Rock
This was the original name of progressive rock music."

...but then gets horribly confused:

We now use this within the umbrella of Prog or Progressive Rock as category that is used to refer to explorative works by bands that cross different genres or have an experimental nature that is not specific to one genre. Some of these bands may have had roots in other prog categories in their early years but later became more AOR or mainstream or vise versa starting out mainstream then becoming prog. These bands are considered primarily to be prog bands."

See how confused and vague this description is? (with apologies to the author, who I know put a lot of work into it).

You should visit the Collaborators section Cert, there is a new definition of the Art Rock category waitting for feedback, we know things are changing and we all are trying to keep.

Likewise symphonic.

Using the word in the way this site uses it, Queen are without a doubt symphonic in their early works - and some of their later material.

"In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music (...) using normally more complex structure than other related sub-genres (cut unnecessary uncomplimentary reference to Neo-Prog)"

Opera is part of the Classical repertoire.
Queen used very complex structures - and frequently on Queen I, II and ANATO.

This description - the main characteristic makes Gentle Giant Symphonic beyond question.

Gentle Giant has also Medieval Folk influences, even the Folk team leaded by Sean Trane asked for it, a poll was done in this section and most of the voting members (Ariound 80%) decided they were not Symphonic.

Let's go back and look at Toolis' earlier post:

Proportion of material is not important for classification - you know that, Ivan. If it was, then we would be considering Genesis for eviction...

Yes it's important, we try to appreciate if a band is mainly Symphonic or Fusion depending in the number of albums that they released in that gemnre, take King Crimson for example, they were in Symphonic but out oftheir more than ten albums only their two first ones were Symphonic.

It was a simple option, due to this fact we decided that they are not mainly Symphonic, so you see, it's a ptoportion thing also.

"Bohemian Rhapsody", as a single example, mixes up the styles, as does "Prophet's Song" - Queen did mix and match, but it depends how pedantic you want to be about it. If you take the hard line route, then you could make the same argument about almost any Prog band - take ELP (I wish someone would...)

Already mentioned that Prophet's Song is a 100% Prog track, but you forgot to quote that part opf my posts.

I've never had this hangup for complex time sigs, and I don't think it's a qualifier - just a characteristic, as in free jazz and even complex electronica and pop music - so not really an important issue.

Again you forgot to quote that I mentioned this wasn't dseterminant, only one of many characteristics

No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. "Seven Seas of Rye" (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

From Genesis to the Revelation is full of beautiful piano, Richard Clayderman plays piano, but this doesn't make the Genes9is debut and Mr Clayderman Symphonic.

The phrase clearly states "keyboards", so "synths" are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

Also mentioned that when I said thattheir albums had piano., but still I believe Queen is more a vocal and guitar oriented band.

The "no synths" phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

I wouldn't call Queen liers, everybody knows what you refer to whentalking about Synths, and guitar isn't unles you trefer to MIDI guitar.

We kbnow that guitar produces a sinthetized sound strictly, but that's not what we're talking about when speaking of synths in Prog or Rock, unless not 99% of the people

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly "lush".

Yes Cert, we know you are an expert, but 99% of the people isn't and 99% of the people here understan other thing when the word Synths is used.

Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

Genesis had an ocasional love somng, ELP had a lot more (Lake was an expert on this) but Queen, better check their songs

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

I find them simpler, that's my opinion.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing "Bohemian Rhapsody" as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

Cert, Queen music always was commercial, created for the massivepublic and accepted for them, this is not bad Dark Side of the Mon was a commercial album, but in this case all Queen albums are mpstly based in Rock with SOME vocal arrangements and some eclectic songs.

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.

Seems you like to partially quote what I say Cert, read my posts, Isaid that time isn't too important, but Prog bands with 12 or 14 tracks per LP are not common.

Now you look confused - saying that "Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical" may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of "Symphonic Prog", but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

That was a typying error, instead of Orchestral Arrangements aren't necesarilly Rock, should had said that Orchestral arrangements aren't necesarilly PROG.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

It's the same typying mistake Micky, I was pretending to say:

" Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas iare not necesarilly Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure PROG and Queen in cases as Somebody to Love just Blues."

Sorry fopr the mistake, I will send myself to detention .

That is not true.

"Somebody to Love" is not a blues song either.

Cert, IMO is mostly a Blues structured and inspired track with some Gospel influences.

- hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

Well, I don't believe he has a case, the vast majority ofthis forum believes he didn't have a case and the also vast majority of¨Prog sites and Prog luiterature that consider Queen a marginally Prog or semi Prog band agree.

Most of Prog Rock is Rock with frills - where do you draw the line?

Again Certified and you know this, there are no strict rules or laws carved in stone, just with a bit of common sense and agreement between the members we almost always reach an agreement before we even ask the question.

Queen was accepted against the majority opposition of the members of the forum, and I'm glad they were, I was even happier when added to Prog Related because IMHO there's where they belong.

And the interlude is not really Operatic - it comes from operettas. The influence is clearly more Gilbert and Sullivan than Wagner - and that is not splitting hairs.

That's your problem Certified, you worry aboput sutile differemnces that most people won't even care, we all know that Queen is not Opera in the exact sense as La Boheme or La Traviatta, but it's inspured in them as Operetta is also inspired in Opera (Even the name is dericvative).

To use the term opera correctly, the whole thing is a mini-opera (or operetta) - it even has an elaborate and theatrical music video to go with it.

Thanks for the lesson Cert, but as I told you before, most of us are not so exquisite, we stay witrh rougher and more common terms.

The fact that it's performed by a Rock band only underlines my point about Prog Rock in general.

I do believe Queen is related to Prog, that's a fact, but again remember the example of the Disco version of the Fifth Symphony of Beethoven, it was clearly inspired in Classical music (In every sense) but it was just bare DISCO.


/edit - apologies on behalf of my browser for the formatting issues - I guess that's what comes of using the latest and greatest

Don't worry about sutile things, the last thing we care about is the format of the posts, people who used old Mac versions had a problem alligning theirposyts to the right and never crossing he centerof the screen.

As always it was a pleasure discussing for you, I know you want te exact technical terms, I understand your point, but I stay with a coloquial language that is accepted by MOST of the Prog community.

Iván

Certif1ed

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 08 2004
Location: England
Status: Offline
Points: 7559

Posted: August 21 2006 at 03:17

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

Potato, Patata...at the end is the same, we both agreed many times that the words Symphonic and classical have different meanings than the ones we use them for, but all the Prog community gets them and it's enough.}

Actually, not all the Prog community "gets them" - that is a generalisation of the "I've always believed this, therefore everyone does" type - hence this discussion. If the term was so clear-cut, everyone would know what it meant.

And the pronunication is not the issue here

As Erik has already intimated in his re-labelling suggestions, it's time for change - and we should use the terms where they have proper meaning rather than in some loose and haphazard fashion that only leads to confusion.

Art Rock, for example, is not bands like Roxy Music and their ilk - no matter who the term was first applied to. The two terms already have serviceable meanings, and there's no need to pollute them.

The definition on this site agrees, on the whole, with my take:

"Art Rock
This was the original name of progressive rock music."

...but then gets horribly confused:

We now use this within the umbrella of Prog or Progressive Rock as category that is used to refer to explorative works by bands that cross different genres or have an experimental nature that is not specific to one genre. Some of these bands may have had roots in other prog categories in their early years but later became more AOR or mainstream or vise versa starting out mainstream then becoming prog. These bands are considered primarily to be prog bands."

See how confused and vague this description is? (with apologies to the author, who I know put a lot of work into it).

Likewise symphonic.

Using the word in the way this site uses it, Queen are without a doubt symphonic in their early works - and some of their later material.

"In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music (...) using normally more complex structure than other related sub-genres (cut unnecessary uncomplimentary reference to Neo-Prog)"

Opera is part of the Classical repertoire.
Queen used very complex structures - and frequently on Queen I, II and ANATO.

This description - the main characteristic makes Gentle Giant Symphonic beyond question.

Let's go back and look at Toolis' earlier post:

toolis wrote:

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

toolis wrote:

The main characteristics of Symphonic are the ones that defined all Progressive Rock: (There's nothing 100% new under the sun) which among others are: Mixture of elements from different genres: I don't think so, they were eclectic but most of their material is pure Rock with soime Orchestral or vocal arrangements, but the main structure was basically Rock, they also played diffeent genres like Blues and even some Ragtime but rarely mixed them, the most you can say it's that they were versatile.

Proportion of material is not important for classification - you know that, Ivan. If it was, then we would be considering Genesis for eviction...

"Bohemian Rhapsody", as a single example, mixes up the styles, as does "Prophet's Song" - Queen did mix and match, but it depends how pedantic you want to be about it. If you take the hard line route, then you could make the same argument about almost any Prog band - take ELP (I wish someone would...)

toolis wrote:

Complex time signatures. In a few cases but not common in them either.

I've never had this hangup for complex time sigs, and I don't think it's a qualifier - just a characteristic, as in free jazz and even complex electronica and pop music - so not really an important issue. [/quote>

Originally posted by toolis> </strong></em>
<br />Lush keyboards<font color=#0000ff> <strong>For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album</strong></font></td></tr></table>
<br /><font color=green>No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their <strong>debut</strong>, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.
<br />
<br />The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.
<br />
<br />The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.
<br />
<br />And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.
<br /></font>
<br />
<table width=

Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis> </strong></em>
<br />Lush keyboards<font color=#0000ff> <strong>For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album</strong></font></td></tr></table>
<br /><font color=green>No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their <strong>debut</strong>, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.
<br />
<br />The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.
<br />
<br />The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.
<br />
<br />And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.
<br /></font>
<br />
<table width=

Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> <strong>toolis> </strong></em>
<br />Lush keyboards<font color=#0000ff> <strong>For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album</strong></font></td></tr></table>
<br /><font color=green>No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their <strong>debut</strong>, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.
<br />
<br />The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.
<br />
<br />The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.
<br />
<br />And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.
<br /></font>
<br />
<table width=

Originally posted by toolis wrote:</strong><br /><br />
<br />Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. <font color=#0000ff><strong>Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.</strong></font></td></tr></table><font color=green>
<br />Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.
<br />
<br />And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?</font>
<br />
<br />
<table width=

Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis> </strong></em>
<br />Lush keyboards<font color=#0000ff> <strong>For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album</strong></font></td></tr></table>
<br /><font color=green>No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their <strong>debut</strong>, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.
<br />
<br />The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.
<br />
<br />The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.
<br />
<br />And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.
<br /></font>
<br />
<table width=

toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.

No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album

No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.

Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

[QUOTE=Certif1ed alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

[QUOTE=Certif1ed style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis alt=Originally posted by toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis style=vertical-align: text-bottom; /> toolis>
Lush keyboards For God's sake, they rarely used piano and until Jazz (I believe) they included proudly a phrase No Synths used in this album
No - there's piano all over their early work, e.g. Seven Seas of Rye (on their debut, and Freddie played as well as many Prog Rockers - if not better than a lot of them.

The phrase clearly states keyboards, so synths are not a pre-requisite for a symphonic sound.

The no synths phrase is actually a bit of a lie, if you think about it - an electric guitar makes a synthesised sound.

And multiple tape loops give a synthetic sound equal to any synth band of the time - half the time Brian May's orchestrated guitar combined with the complex hamonies in the vocal parts make a thick wall of sound that is most certainly lush.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Explorative and intelligent lyrics, in some cases close to fantasy literature, Sci Fi and even political issues. Intelligent yes but excplorative no way, mostly Love songs with good arrangements.
Come on, man! On their early albums you have Sci-fi themes all over the place, and only the occasional love song. Genesis and ELP weren't above doing Love songs either.

And the lyrics are very deep and explorative - whatever makes you think they're not?

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Non commercial approach Oh man, Queen is the commercial band for excelence, their approach was totally commercial, good music but you can't close your eyes.

You're saying that about Queen's early albums? Queen II doesn't sound commercial to me - and releasing Bohemian Rhapsody as a single was a very daring move at the time - it was way too long and complex for radio play. It only achieved success because Kenny Everett gave it such a hammering.

[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

Longer format of songs Hey man, they have an average of 10 songs per album in LP format (40 to 45 minutes) , their average was 4 minutes at the most being that they used to have one longer song

Wrong again, Ivan - ANATO (for example) has more than one song over 4 minutes, and number of songs is not the issue here.
[QUOTE=toolis wrote:

In this specific case the main characteristic is the influence of Classical music.... : Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical, the structure of Genesis songs was pure Rock and in cases as S0omebody to Love just Blues.

Now you look confused - saying that Using Orchestral arrangements or Operatic vocal extravaganzas is not Classical may be correct - indeed, it's the biggest problem I have with the classification of Symphonic Prog, but since it's the argument you use to define a band as symphonic, you can't make an exception for Queen.

I don't understand the reference to Genesis - you're saying Genesis song structures were pure rock?

That is not true.

Somebody to Love is not a blues song either.

This is not about terminology (or prononunciation!), but about reality.

[QUOTE=toolis>
i rest my case.... Sorry, you don't have a case.

It was a bit sketchy as a case - hence I fleshed it out a little - but it was a good one and deserved better than a trashing based on simple opinions that do not appear to be founded in reality.

For example:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

[QUOTE=Certif1ed wrote:

[QUOTE=Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

Honestly I like Bohemian Rhapsody more than Gentle Giant, but still I believe it's a rock track with operatic stravaganza that ends into a power ballad.

No - it's not a standard rock track by any stretch of the imagination, as my analysis shows. Standard no way, I agree with you and never said it Cert, it's complex, but still IMO it's mainly Rock with an Operatic interlude.

Most of Prog Rock is Rock with frills - where do you draw the line?

And the interlude is not really Operatic - it comes from operettas. The influence is clearly more Gilbert and Sullivan than Wagner - and that is not splitting hairs.

To use the term opera correctly, the whole thing is a mini-opera (or operetta) - it even has an elaborate and theatrical music video to go with it.

The fact that it's performed by a Rock band only underlines my point about Prog Rock in general.




/edit - apologies on behalf of my browser for the formatting issues - I guess that's what comes of using the latest and greatest

Edited by Certif1ed - August 21 2006 at 03:43

The important thing is not to stop questioning.

Ivan_Melgar_M View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 27 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 19535

Posted: August 21 2006 at 02:33

Certif1ed wrote:

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

Honestly I like Bohemian Rhapsody more than Gentle Giant, but still I believe it's a rock track with operatic stravaganza that ends into a power ballad.

No - it's not a standard rock track by any stretch of the imagination, as my analysis shows.

Standard no way, I agree with you and never said it Cert, it's complex, but still IMO it's mainly Rock with an Operatic interlude.

Iván

Edited by Ivan_Melgar_M - August 21 2006 at 02:34

Certif1ed

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 08 2004
Location: England
Status: Offline
Points: 7559

Posted: August 20 2006 at 17:37

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

Honestly I like Bohemian Rhapsody more than Gentle Giant, but stoill I believe it's a rock track with operatic stravaganza that ends into a power ballad.

No - it's not a standard rock track by any stretch of the imagination, as my analysis shows.

To complicate matteres a little, given the subject of this thread, Rhapsodies fall under the remit of Symphonic, as symphonic composers also composed Rhapsodies and would schedule them into the same programmes.

And it emphatically does not end with a ballad, power or otherwise. A ballad is a completely different form.

I must admit, I would prefer to listen to Gentle Giant than Bohemian Rhapsody - but only because I've heard the latter soooo many times

Queen II still gives me goosebumps with its pure progginess, tho'

Edited by Certif1ed - August 20 2006 at 17:40

The important thing is not to stop questioning.

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Posted: August 20 2006 at 01:34

so, i guess the bottom line is that Queen are definitely not symph prog and that for most (well, all but two) people have only prog elements in their music, hence 'prog related' is the most suitable genre for them..

i'll stand by my opinion and continue to consider Queen as "Prog Monsters"... maybe i'm right, maybe you're wrong... who knows...

Ivan_Melgar_M View Drop Down

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 27 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 19535

Posted: August 18 2006 at 19:17

Certif1ed wrote:

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

Queen Symphonic?????

You know, I would say that about almost every rock band filed under symphonic - except The Enid.

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

They have some relation with Prog as they have with Blues, Pop and Classic Rock,

If youcheck out my previous pósts, probably the word that I repeated more in this thread is OPERA and if you read the first line of my quote which I have bolded, the PROG genre is the first one I mention.

Glam is what they looked like, Rock is what they sounded like, but Prog Rock is what they played - even though it upsets a lot of ostriches to think that.

Never mentioned Glam, they sounded as Rock, but they played Prog, Rock, Blues, Musical, Vaudeville or Music Hall style, etc.

They're not my favourite band - but it beggars belief that there are still people who question the status of Queen, who blatantly - even cheekily - out-progged many prog bands.

Queen outprogged many bands, but this is not a conytest, IMO they don't fit in any other sub-genre other than Prog Related, because they had some Prog moments but not a 100% Prog band.

/rant (not aimed at you personally, of course, Ivan - it just developed like that in this post!).

I know, I never asked to remove them from Prog Related, but I insist they are not remotely Symphonic.

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

they are outstanding but they never released a Symphonic track, not even Bohemian Rhapsody which is a Rock song with some stravaganzas.

Actually, Bohemian Rhapsody goes many miles beyond the standard rock song - it is, indeed, a true Rhapsody.

Going beyond doesn't necesarilly mean Progressive Rock, and much less Symphonic

Yes, it's got an intro - but a very intricate one with a cappella harmonies in a blend of simple classical and barbershop, but it breaks down almost instantly. When the piano line joins, it is playing something completely different to the vocals, and then when Freddie takes a lead line, it's not the first verse, but a continuation of the multi-threaded introduction.

Agree totally

The "first verse" is completely different in structure to the "second" - if separate verses can truly be marked out - and where is the chorus?

Answer: There isn't one.

Just unfolding material that develops crazily with new ideas being thrown into the mix all the time.

I''l save the rest for a review - but standard Rock Song BH most definitely ain't.

It's more elegant a composition than almost anything else a rock band produced in 1975, and both structurally and musically it's way beyond the capabilities of most Prog Rock bands - in terms of composition.

I'd bet that Gentle Giant wish they'd written it - it's in the same league.

Honestly I like Bohemian Rhapsody more than Gentle Giant, but stoill I believe it's a rock track with operatic stravaganza that ends into a power ballad.

But I agree - I would never call it symphonic.

Neither do I.

Iván

akin

Forum Senior Member

Joined: February 06 2004
Location: Brazil
Status: Offline
Points: 976

Posted: August 18 2006 at 16:58

maani wrote:

Hmm....

As the person who argued most vociferously not include Queen on PA (and in fact all but left the site over that debate), I will say only this:

If Queen is re-categorized as Symphonic Prog, I will create and introduce into PA a powerful virus that will change the Yes page into the Barry Manilow page, the Genesis page into the Lionel Ritchie page, the King Crimson page into the George Michael page, the Dream Theater page into the Britney Spears page, and the Pink Floyd page into the Kenny G page - just to name a few!

Peace. (or maybe not...)

Certif1ed

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 08 2004
Location: England
Status: Offline
Points: 7559

Posted: August 18 2006 at 16:49

I don't want to spoil the friendship at this delicate, nebulous phase, but I was actually agreeing with Ivan that Queen shouldn't be filed under symphonic...

But they're definitely Prog.

The important thing is not to stop questioning.

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Posted: August 18 2006 at 13:51

sniff... a tear runs down my cheek... at last, an ally... thank you my friend, Certif1ed... thank you...
as Freddie would say: "You're my best friend"...

Certif1ed

Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator

Joined: April 08 2004
Location: England
Status: Offline
Points: 7559

Posted: August 18 2006 at 08:38

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

Queen Symphonic?????

You know, I would say that about almost every rock band filed under symphonic - except The Enid.

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

They have some relation with Prog as they have with Blues, Pop and Classic Rock,

Don't forget Opera, early 1900s popular music idioms, and, of course, please don't forget Prog Rock itself - even their very first album shows more than just signs of being influenced by the overblown pomposity of Prog Rock - and the varied influences, richly complex harmonies, time changes etc all add up to music well within Prog Rock's remit.

Glam is what they looked like, Rock is what they sounded like, but Prog Rock is what they played - even though it upsets a lot of ostriches to think that.

They're not my favourite band - but it beggars belief that there are still people who question the status of Queen, who blatantly - even cheekily - out-progged many prog bands.

/rant (not aimed at you personally, of course, Ivan - it just developed like that in this post!).

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:

they are outstanding but they never released a Symphonic track, not even Bohemian Rhapsody which is a Rock song with some stravaganzas.

Actually, Bohemian Rhapsody goes many miles beyond the standard rock song - it is, indeed, a true Rhapsody.

Yes, it's got an intro - but a very intricate one with a cappella harmonies in a blend of simple classical and barbershop, but it breaks down almost instantly. When the piano line joins, it is playing something completely different to the vocals, and then when Freddie takes a lead line, it's not the first verse, but a continuation of the multi-threaded introduction.

The "first verse" is completely different in structure to the "second" - if separate verses can truly be marked out - and where is the chorus?

Answer: There isn't one.

Just unfolding material that develops crazily with new ideas being thrown into the mix all the time.

I''l save the rest for a review - but standard Rock Song BH most definitely ain't.

It's more elegant a composition than almost anything else a rock band produced in 1975, and both structurally and musically it's way beyond the capabilities of most Prog Rock bands - in terms of composition.

I'd bet that Gentle Giant wish they'd written it - it's in the same league.

But I agree - I would never call it symphonic.

richardh wrote:

I would put Queen into a new sub genre 'glam prog' (..or preferably out the site altogether...even The Sweet were proggier)

Not even close.

The Sweet vs Queen - Blockbuster vs Bohemian Rhapsody?

Good joke, Richard

Edited by Certif1ed - August 18 2006 at 13:08

The important thing is not to stop questioning.

richardh

Prog Reviewer

Joined: February 18 2004
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 28059

Posted: August 18 2006 at 02:41

I would put Queen into a new sub genre 'glam prog' (..or preferably out the site altogether...even The Sweet were proggier)

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Posted: August 16 2006 at 09:25

maani wrote:

Ivan and Sean:

[IMG]height=17 alt=Hug src="http://www.progarchives.com/forum/smileys/smiley31.gif" width=45 align=absMiddle>

Peace.

huh?

maani

Special Collaborator

Founding Moderator

Joined: January 30 2004
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 2632

Posted: August 15 2006 at 19:11

Ivan and Sean:

Peace.

Philéas

Forum Senior Member

Joined: June 14 2006
Status: Offline
Points: 6419

Posted: August 15 2006 at 09:42

toolis wrote:

i'm afraid i'm going to need a stronger arguement my friend...

It wasn't an arguement, just a comment in general Wink

toolis wrote:

i mean, their sound is unique, they all are excellent players, they have all these different styles from track to track, they really progressed from album to album, and, let's face it, the essence of their music, the diathesis their music emits, if you like, is absolutely progressive....

apart from that, it's really unfair for Queen to be under the 'prog related' category, given that IMHO, their music is far more progressive and really closer to other bands considered prog... and i'm pretty sure that all of you agree that compared to many of the bands/artists that you oppose being in the PA, Queen are more progressive...

Yes, Queen were progressive in their own right, but progressive and Prog are not the same thing. Prog is a style of music, and a band can be progressive without being prog. A good example is Rage Against the Machine. Progressive, but very, very far from Prog.

Furthermore, I don't think it's unjust at all to have Queen in Prog Related. The category was created to house bands just like Queen.

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Posted: August 15 2006 at 05:16

first of all, i would like to thank Ivan for not ignoring my opinion and fairly took a lot of time of his own and eloquently argued with me...

additionaly, i want to apologise about the "LAME" thing.. nobody's opinion is lame.. terribly sorry, i got carried away...

now, about the Queen been prog issue...let's forget the arguement whether Queen are Symph,i obviously didn't convince anyone and you are probably right... technicalities and definitions aside.. i have been listening to prog for only 10 years, but from the first time i listened to early Queen, i said to myself: "now,
that's what i call good prog..."

i mean, their sound is unique, they all are excellent players, they have all these different styles from track to track, they really progressed from album to album, and, let's face it, the essence of their music, the diathesis their music emits, if you like, is absolutely progressive....

apart from that, it's really unfair for Queen to be under the 'prog related' category, given that IMHO, their music is far more progressive and really closer to other bands considered prog... and i'm pretty sure that all of you agree that compared to many of the bands/artists that you oppose being in the PA, Queen are more progressive...

i don't know what else to say.. it's not that the world will stop turning if Queen remain 'prog related' not that if they go 'X prog' i will finally go to sleep.. it's sth i strongly believe and i wanted to know your thought pattern you followed and placed Queen there...

i think, i'll finish my coffee and go 'kill' "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" with my guitar...

be back soon.. apparently...

Edited by toolis - August 15 2006 at 06:31

toolis

Forum Senior Member

Joined: April 26 2006
Location: MacedoniaGreece
Status: Offline
Points: 1678

Posted: August 15 2006 at 04:06

Philéas wrote:

toolis wrote:

sorry you can't argue my case...

I'm sorry but, like Ivan says, you have no case. But then again, if you have no case, of course he can't argue it.

i'm afraid i'm going to need a stronger arguement my friend...

Edited by toolis - August 15 2006 at 04:15

Post Reply	Page 12 3 >

Forum Jump

Forum Permissions View Drop Down

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

This page was generated in 1.129 seconds.

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.