Gila and their second album - Progressive Rock Music Forum

Hrychu wrote:

At least the Gila album isn't as cheesy as the song of the same name by Buffy Sainte Marie (fyi a white person LARPing as a Native American).

Buffy was not a native-american, she had latin roots that made her look like one, though.

Some called her a fraud, but her heart was at the right place.

let's just stay above the moral melee
prefer the sink to the gutter
keep our sand-castle virtues
content to be a doer
as well as a thinker,
prefer lifting our pen
rather than un-sheath our sword

Sean Trane wrote:

Haven't heard this album in decades (it isn't that good either, compared with their debut), but I really don't think it should be qualified as racist back then, even with today's stoooooopid new woke revisionism that is in vogue.

It may surprise some, but when we (Europeans) were kids paying "cow-boys & indians", some had much more sympathies for the Amerindians, than the invading Unitedstatians..

It's an okayish album, nothing extraordinary after giving it a listen. I think the band had their heart at the right place when writing lyrics, they might not have been the perfect people to write about such a subject but either case, I don't think it's racist either.

Haven't heard this album in decades (it isn't that good either, compared with their debut), but I really don't think it should be qualified as racist back then, even with today's stoooooopid new woke revisionism that is in vogue.

It may surprise some, but when we (Europeans) were kids paying "cow-boys & indians", some had much more sympathies for the Amerindians, than the invading Unitedstatians..

let's just stay above the moral melee
prefer the sink to the gutter
keep our sand-castle virtues
content to be a doer
as well as a thinker,
prefer lifting our pen
rather than un-sheath our sword

BTW, there is this goofball comedy movie called Der Schuh des Manitu, and it self-critically ridicules the Germans' obsession with Native Americans. It's pure cartoony slapstick fun. I really enjoyed it.

The Polish dub is a little masterpiece in its own right.

Edited by Hrychu - February 02 2025 at 06:22

“On the day of my creation, I fell in love with education. And overcoming all frustration, a teacher I became.”
— Ernest Vong

Hrychu wrote:

And this album by Gila is just as racist. 🤮

Hrychu wrote:

Do you think I'm a jerk?

Yes

Hrychu wrote:

And this album by Gila is just as racist. 🤮

I mean, Gila, were probably not the first choice for anyone to do an album on Native Americans' massacre. Though I am not sure if it's racist. The lyrics (the one's I could make out :p) seemed okay and I thought the band had put in decent effort. Eithercase, I am sure other members' would have listened to it more intently and probably multiple times than me.

Wouldn't racist be like Genesis' doing an interpretation of Mexicans in the song Illegal Aliens [the music video]?

Yes, I think there are sonic difference between their debut and this. I don't think I have listened to the singular bonus track [only have listened to the standard version].

Since I have some issues with accents [while I can properly understand English, vocals sometimes create a problem for me due to singer's accents which is amplified probably because English isn't my mother tongue], for a long time, I used to pore over lyrics, be it either progressive rock like Can or punk rock like Clash.

The freewheelin debut by this band [often categorized under krautrock is lauded quite highly here at PA] though I wish to focus on their second more serious album.

With a more laidback sound structure for their second and final album, Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee takes a look at the Native American massacre at Wounded Knee and probably the album name from the book of the same name by Lee Brown.

I do not have much information except cursory knowledge of what I gleaned from Wikipedia about the event. To make matters worse, trusty old Genius .com doesn't have proper lyrics/annotations for this LP. Therefore, I am unable to know to what extent (and if to any specific events), the band is referring to in their lyrics exactly.

It's a rarity because progressive rock bands rarely write much overtly political songs [I am aware that a thread to Political Prog exists but it is still but a minority].

The album is decent musically and the second side seems stronger than the first one, especially the song Black Kettle's Ballad.