John Lennon right or wrong?

earlyprog wrote: ^you could start listening to the f*****g song yourself

earlyprog wrote: Kati wrote: Fact: Sargent Pepper Lonely Hearts Club - written and composed by McCartney. A 41 piece orchestra played on this song.  The orchestra was conducted by Paul McCartney, who told them to start with the lowest note of their instruments and gradually play to the highest. Notwithstanding the valdhorns, what orchestra?! Are you referring to the first 10 seconds of the song? Nonetheless, a proto type heavy metal song.

Kati wrote: ExittheLemming wrote: Kati wrote: to all who have no idea or clue plus have the audacity to diss Paul McCartney, you might also want to know he wrote this track in 1973, as you obviously will go ha! Yes, Guns n Roses made a cover of this track   Paul McCartney Live and Let Die  - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZdsIj4pAzQ&index=116&list=PLMyHPEAFkfwPB0XJheppVe6ZIcpMm9ZrA What does McCartney winning a very lucrative Bond theme song franchise have to do with his ability to write innovative and ground breaking music?. I like the song 'Live and Let Die' but the lyrics are Hollywood mandated drivel and the music, albeit excellent, is deliberately aimed at those cinema goers gauche enough to actually believe that tempo and key changes within the one song were hitherto entirely unprecedented. Fact: Sargent Pepper Lonely Hearts Club - written and composed by McCartney. A 41 piece orchestra played on this song.  The orchestra was conducted by Paul McCartney, who told them to start with the lowest note of their instruments and gradually play to the highest.

Meaning?

Kati wrote: to all who have no idea or clue plus have the audacity to diss Paul McCartney, you might also want to know he wrote this track in 1973, as you obviously will go ha! Yes, Guns n Roses made a cover of this track   Paul McCartney Live and Let Die  - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZdsIj4pAzQ&index=116&list=PLMyHPEAFkfwPB0XJheppVe6ZIcpMm9ZrA

What does McCartney winning a very lucrative Bond theme song franchise have to do with his ability to write innovative and ground breaking music?. No-one is arguing that he hasn't written some brilliant music. I like the song 'Live and Let Die' but the lyrics are Hollywood mandated drivel and the music, albeit excellent, is deliberately aimed at those cinema goers gauche enough to actually believe that tempo and key changes within the one song were hitherto entirely unprecedented.


Edited by ExittheLemming - April 05 2015 at 08:51

Paul McCartney wrote Helter Skelter, arguably the first metal song ever written. The Beatles - Helter Skelter-HD https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbY_oFHqdgsnot a mom nor dad song.

McCartney II is supposed to be Paul at his most experimental - at least that is the hype I heard.
Hearing this I actually spent a whole $8 on a pristine copy. ("II" is not that easy to find hereabouts.)

Big disappointment. Far from exptal. (But then again, I understand the 2cd set(??) has more.)

Speaking of exptal diddling, ever hear  moog pioneer, Bernie Kraus' take on Harrison?
You always hear what a****les Lennon & McCartney were in real life, but not George.

You should read what Kraus had to say about him.

McCartney naysayers need to pick-up the book 'The Unknown Paul McCartney and the Avant Garde' by Ian Peel. It's the best book I've read on the man, and shows he was the more experimental of the Fab 4 and certainly more than Lennon. A great read and show's Macca is much more than silly love songs. 

I only have one or two early McCartney albums but I did see the band during the Wings Over America tour

Paul writes music to make his mom smile.