Print Page | Close Window

Top Mellotron albums of all time

Printed From: Progarchives.com
Category: Progressive Music Lounges
Forum Name: Top 10s and lists
Forum Description: List all your favourites here
URL: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=48099
Printed Date: February 22 2025 at 22:38
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Top Mellotron albums of all time
Posted By: Squonkman
Subject: Top Mellotron albums of all time
Date Posted: April 24 2008 at 17:43

I don't know if this has been posted before, but this site is a great resource and interesting reading. Here is his list of the most mellotron heavy albums of all.

 
 
http://www.planetmellotron.com/toptron.htm - http://www.planetmellotron.com/toptron.htm
 
 
anyone here have that Schicke, Fuhrs, Frohling live album he has at the top? I keep meaning to get that, but I don't see it pop up much. It obviously must have gobs of mellotron on it.



Replies:
Posted By: pierreolivier
Date Posted: April 24 2008 at 22:29
Originally posted by Squonkman Squonkman wrote:

I don't know if this has been posted before, but this site is a great resource and interesting reading. Here is his list of the most mellotron heavy albums of all.

 
 
http://www.planetmellotron.com/toptron.htm - http://www.planetmellotron.com/toptron.htm
 
 
anyone here have that Schicke, Fuhrs, Frohling live album he has at the top? I keep meaning to get that, but I don't see it pop up much. It obviously must have gobs of mellotron on it.
 
Yes, Andy Thompson's website is known here for a source for Mellotron infos.  I sometimes collaborates to help Andy find new albums, specially french language albums featuring it.
 
I Have that SFF live album, and if you like mellotron , you should buy it but personnally I don't think that'st the best mellotron album of all time.  It's sure it contain a lot of the instrument but for me, SFF music is a bit cold but it certainly the album that had the most of it.  The album just below SFF in the list, wich is Air "Virgins Suicide" soundtrack is awesome.ClapVery recommended.


Posted By: Philip
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 15:03
Originally posted by pierreolivier pierreolivier wrote:

The album just below SFF in the list, wich is Air "Virgins Suicide" soundtrack is awesome.ClapVery recommended.
 
Yeah. Very good album in deed.
 
When I listen to the word Mellotron, it is impossible not to think, (at least for me, but I'm portuguese), in José Cid's work, particularly his masterpiece of symphonic prog and mellotron using "10000 anos Depois entre Vénus e Marte" and the single "Vida (Sons do Quotidiano)", and the magnum opus of Quarteto 1111, "...Cantamos Pessoas Vivas" which appears first than the other records in planetmellotron. Today, it's a very good day for this album, because conceptually, it is about Liberty, and, as it was released in 1974, it is dedicated to the Liberty that was gained in the revolution of the 25th April, 1974 (Clap applauses to the constructers of that revolution, mainly the soldiers of MFA), 34 years ago.
 
It's a very good way to comemorate, listening to this album and trying to feel the music that is infested of mellotron, but today, the lyrics have more attention particularly,, they deserve it. Next 5th may, the album will be available to more people in it's first CD edition.
 
Today, I will make my comemoration ritual with my lovely vinyl copy, which is a relic.


Posted By: pierreolivier
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 16:35
Originally posted by Philip Philip wrote:

Originally posted by pierreolivier pierreolivier wrote:

The album just below SFF in the list, wich is Air "Virgins Suicide" soundtrack is awesome.ClapVery recommended.
 
Yeah. Very good album in deed.
 
When I listen to the word Mellotron, it is impossible not to think, (at least for me, but I'm portuguese), in José Cid's work, particularly his masterpiece of symphonic prog and mellotron using "10000 anos Depois entre Vénus e Marte" and the single "Vida (Sons do Quotidiano)", and the magnum opus of Quarteto 1111, "...Cantamos Pessoas Vivas" which appears first than the other records in planetmellotron. Today, it's a very good day for this album, because conceptually, it is about Liberty, and, as it was released in 1974, it is dedicated to the Liberty that was gained in the revolution of the 25th April, 1974 (Clap applauses to the constructers of that revolution, mainly the soldiers of MFA), 34 years ago.
 
It's a very good way to comemorate, listening to this album and trying to feel the music that is infested of mellotron, but today, the lyrics have more attention particularly,, they deserve it. Next 5th may, the album will be available to more people in it's first CD edition.
 
Today, I will make my comemoration ritual with my lovely vinyl copy, which is a relic.
 
Yes, I heard that the Quaterto 1111 and José Cid's album contains great deal of mellotron but never heard them.  PlanetMellotron also add recently Ermelinda Duarte single "Somo livre" from 1974, wich also deal with the revolution and the ascension of the democracy in Portugual.  The mellotron of that track is played by José Cid. I hope that the Jose Cid album will be available in Quebec.
 
I think those albums are important for portugueses people as us, quebecers worship the Harmonium album "Si on avait besoin d'une cinquième saison"  wich also deal with politic.


Posted By: tszirmay
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 17:50
Dutch band Trion has 2 albums LOADED with 'tron !

-------------
I never post anything anywhere without doing more than basic research, often in depth.


Posted By: pierreolivier
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 18:10
Originally posted by tszirmay tszirmay wrote:

Dutch band Trion has 2 albums LOADED with 'tron !
 
Apparently, the mellotron is sampled, check this: http://www.planetmellotron.com/revsamt-z.htm#trion - http://www.planetmellotron.com/revsamt-z.htm#trion


Posted By: Squonkman
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 18:13
mellotron sampling is kind of ironic, since mellotrons themselves sampled other instruments and voices. I think Porcupine Tree uses mellotron samples on some albums, like Deadwing--as I don't think Barberi uses a mellotron.


Posted By: Philip
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 19:49
Originally posted by pierreolivier pierreolivier wrote:

  
Yes, I heard that the Quaterto 1111 and José Cid's album contains great deal of mellotron but never heard them.  PlanetMellotron also add recently Ermelinda Duarte single "Somo livre" from 1974, wich also deal with the revolution and the ascension of the democracy in Portugual.  The mellotron of that track is played by José Cid. I hope that the José Cid album will be available in Quebec.
 
I think those albums are important for portugueses people as us, quebecers worship the Harmonium album "Si on avait besoin d'une cinquième saison"  which also deal with politics.
 
Thanks for the information, I know the song but I had no idea that it was José Cid playing.
 
Yeah. Every year, in the day of the revolution, it is impossible not to listen to Zeca Afonso, musically the most important musician connnected to the revolution. Quarteto 1111 is no exception, they had problems with the censorship starting with their first album.. It is important to listen to these albums, as they are historical documents of that season.
 
  
I'm portuguese, but I'm also a lover of that fabulous album from your country, an absolutely masterpiece of progressive rock,Clap but I must say I had no idea of its lyrical content, but if It deals with politics, one more reason for your worship for it (historical value), and one more reason to say it's excellent.
I wish I knew and understood French properly, so I could analyse the album lyrically. Even without seeing that, the album is a rare pearl, and so, I worship it too, althought in other terms, just for music right now.(right now because someday I will understand It, after I try to remember what I've learned in French some years ago, I have forgotten almost everything)Cry


Posted By: King of Loss
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 21:59
Octane and Feel Euphoria made that list? Its a cool list overall, but some are of course a bit um... Skewed?


Posted By: pierreolivier
Date Posted: April 25 2008 at 23:39
Originally posted by Philip Philip wrote:

Originally posted by pierreolivier pierreolivier wrote:

  
Yes, I heard that the Quaterto 1111 and José Cid's album contains great deal of mellotron but never heard them.  PlanetMellotron also add recently Ermelinda Duarte single "Somo livre" from 1974, wich also deal with the revolution and the ascension of the democracy in Portugual.  The mellotron of that track is played by José Cid. I hope that the José Cid album will be available in Quebec.
 
I think those albums are important for portugueses people as us, quebecers worship the Harmonium album "Si on avait besoin d'une cinquième saison"  which also deal with politics.
 
Thanks for the information, I know the song but I had no idea that it was José Cid playing.
 
Yeah. Every year, in the day of the revolution, it is impossible not to listen to Zeca Afonso, musically the most important musician connnected to the revolution. Quarteto 1111 is no exception, they had problems with the censorship starting with their first album.. It is important to listen to these albums, as they are historical documents of that season.
 
  
I'm portuguese, but I'm also a lover of that fabulous album from your country, an absolutely masterpiece of progressive rock,Clap but I must say I had no idea of its lyrical content, but if It deals with politics, one more reason for your worship for it (historical value), and one more reason to say it's excellent.
I wish I knew and understood French properly, so I could analyse the album lyrically. Even without seeing that, the album is a rare pearl, and so, I worship it too, althought in other terms, just for music right now.(right now because someday I will understand It, after I try to remember what I've learned in French some years ago, I have forgotten almost everything)Cry
 
Yes, Harmonium "Si on avait besoin d'une ciquième saison" , specially the song "Depuis l'automne" told the events that took place in October 1970 and relates the event that historians here names "La crise d'Octobre" (October crisis) where the "Front de libération du Québec" kidnapped a minister in order to  speed up the independance of Quebec.  The minister was killed and the independance of Quebec never happened. The album also told the rise of the independantist party "Parti Québecois" who took the power in 1976 (the Harmonium album is from 1975, so some months before). Harmonium was an independantist band and was closely associated with the "Parti Québecois".
 
But to compare it with the revolution that took place in your country in 1974 is pretty lame.  Portugual before 1974 was a military dictature where the artists and dissidents  where tortured, sometimes killed. The urgence of a revolution was more evident than here . In Quebec, we were relativity free of speech but there were inegalities that were more about differences between the english speaking people vs. the french speaking. But it's sure that the album told events that took place in 1970.
 
To change subject ( on a lighter side) , I've read you are from Porto.  There's a lot of good wines in your place that I liked a lot(i'm a fan), so Cheers! Clap


Posted By: Philip
Date Posted: April 26 2008 at 10:50
Originally posted by pierreolivier pierreolivier wrote:

Yes, Harmonium "Si on avait besoin d'une ciquième saison" , specially the song "Depuis l'automne" told the events that took place in October 1970 and relates the event that historians here names "La crise d'Octobre" (October crisis) where the "Front de libération du Québec" kidnapped a minister in order to  speed up the independance of Quebec.  The minister was killed and the independance of Quebec never happened. The album also told the rise of the independantist party "Parti Québecois" who took the power in 1976 (the Harmonium album is from 1975, so some months before). Harmonium was an independentist band and was closely associated with the "Parti Québecois".
 
But to compare it with the revolution that took place in your country in 1974 is pretty lame.  Portugual before 1974 was a military dictature where the artists and dissidents  where tortured, sometimes killed. The urgence of a revolution was more evident than here . In Quebec, we were relativity free of speech but there were inegalities that were more about differences between the english speaking people vs. the french speaking. But it's sure that the album told events that took place in 1970.
 
Thanks. Very interesting. I will read more about the history of Quebec in wikipedia.
 
I think I forgot to say that this Harmonium's masterpiece is also a great album of the mellotron use, too.
 
Originally posted by pierreolivier pierreolivier wrote:

To change subject (on a lighter side) , I've read you are from Porto.  There's a lot of good wines in your place that I liked a lot (i'm a fan), so Cheers! Clap
Yeah, thanks, the "Port" is superb, a trademark of my city, a unique wine in the world, and from the world's oldest wine region. 
As this is about mellotrons, there is a connection between this old keyboard (and others, as the moog, for example), and the wine from my city, in the term "vintage", borrowed from the classification of exceptional quality wines, to classify these instruments as "vintage keyboards" for their exceptional quality too.
 
 
 


Posted By: Dr. Prog
Date Posted: April 29 2008 at 00:43
that is a great site with some great articles and history on the majestic 'tron. I frequent that site.



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2014 Web Wiz Ltd. - http://www.webwiz.co.uk