Their Prog approach vcan't bediscussed, I used to think they didn't belong here, but despite I don't like them, I believe they deserve to be added.

 

BTW: Can't vote don't know why a box with a message "You have already votted appears"

 

It has happened me twice toiday, so there must be a bug, anyway, count my vote as a YES.

 

Iván

I fail to see why they aren't here already. The Crane Wife is a full blown prog album. They are extremely progressive in their approach to music, their storybook grandoise lyrics, and the style they play in. This band has run the scope of progressive music from the phenomonal symphonic song "The Island" to the Crimson-esque freak-out of "I Was Meant for the Stage." This band constantly pushes the boundaries of their original genre and makes it something much more special and progressive. And this has been growing with time. I can't wait to hear what they put out next!

It totally floored me the first time I heard it (well, on the record). From the beginning it seemed to be a long song with a continuous repeating melody, but by the end I was doubting this was the same band. I love that song and that whole album.

I still say yes!

 

Yes, that was the quote. The shred-off episode was great.

 

I think they belong. The first few releases were just really creative, really good indie rock, but after The Tain, they started to exhibit prog qualities. Great, great band.

 

 

But The Decemberists is a very strange band, they keep evolving and going back to the Indie base that's undeniable, the Prog elements are present im mopst albums except the above mentioned  and 5 Songs.

 

 

The Tain has some reminiscences of many artists including King Crimson, nice release.

 

Her Majesty is a very rare blend of Folk, Indie and Prog.

 

5 Songs: Still that Indie sound is present, but nobody can deny the Prog Folk sound. Please somebody tell me if I'm crazy, but I listen some Beatles influence? Not Pure Prog though.

 

Castaways and Cutouts: Strange Celtic oriented album, some Indie but mostly Proggire to say the least.

 

Good band. the major part of their production is Celtic oriented Prog gently blended with Indie, maybe Folk Prog is still too much and Prog Related would be the best, but don't want to give a radical opinion until I get the DVD which is said will convince me.

 

Iván

 

 

 

If Their appearance in prog forums discussions is recent, I 'd have to thjink that for a group being around for seven years, only their later albums would be prog. Just an assumption of mine, though.

 

... I mean, an example: I LOVE Blackfield... but is it really proggier than The Decemberists? Listen please to the track The Crane Wife Pt 3, it is 100% prog!

 

I agree.

In two cases lately, I voted NO on two bands and one of them was proposed by Clem (Plastic People of the Universe). The other was supported by Sean (L'ensemble Raye).

But I said in both cases, that if my objection is in the only one in the way of addition and if the person proposing has presented a case for addition, I will not object to them being added, even though I do not agree with it.

I think that me not agreeing with a band being here is a small price to pay and makes much more sense to have them here for people to know of them, than for me to be "right" and nto have them here. That is if I am alone on this.

And maybe my subjectivity prevents me from seeing the prog in that particular band.

The same goes for other bands in PA I don't think should be in. If there are so many people who think it's prog and want them here and present a good case, let them have it.

 

As for this band, I have The Crane Wife. I think it's a good album, and like it and while it had it prog moments (The Island, The Crane Wife 1,2) the rest is mostly prog related to me. But again, as there's such strong feelings here and Bob did present his case, I'm fine with it.

Again, this is good (even very good) music and a case for prog-related is beyond a doubt. As for more, I want to listen to their other relaeses and read more opinions.

 

Another thing, I want you to read what the band wrote in their website:

http://www.decemberists.com/about.aspx - http://www.decemberists.com/about.aspx

 

"

Decemberists songwriter and frontman Colin Meloy first came across the story of The Crane Wife several years ago, in the children’s section of a bookstore in Portland. A venerable Japanese folk tale that has been handed down in countless variations and translations through the centuries (as venerable folk tales are wont to do), the deceptively simple story has stayed with Meloy ever since.

“I thought that it would be a great thing to try to put it to some sort of song form, be it a single tune or something longer,” he recalls. “So I struggled with that for years until finally I realized that it just needed more parts and set about building those.”

He had plenty to occupy him in the meantime: the past three years have seen his band, The Decemberists rise to the first rank of the indie music world with a series of bold, beautiful albums, including 2005’s Picaresque and Her Majesty, The Decemberists (2003). On these albums, Meloy’s crafty compositions marry an infallible melodic knack with a venturesome lyrical palette equally suitable for painting fantastical songs full of sea captains, legionnaires, chimney sweeps and seekers of all kinds.

Led by these songs, and by a group dynamic that embraces experimentation even as it celebrates classic pop and folk forms -- to say nothing of klezmer, Irish jig, sea chantey, and prog rock -- The Decemberists are firmly established as a completely original happening in the world of contemporary indie rock: sold out tours across the nation, widespread popular and critical acclaim, and an aesthetic all their own.

Still, as their star rose in the demimonde, Meloy noticed that the band -- himself, multi-instrumentalist Chris Funk, keyboardist Jenny Conlee, bassist Nate Query and drummer John Moen -- had its eyes trained on broader horizons. “It wasn’t like we needed to force the change,” he explains, “but the change was happening. I could tell when I was sitting down with the guitar… what was coming out wasn’t the same old stuff.”

The stuff that was coming out would become the band’s most ambitious record to date. Drawing on the long-simmering inspiration of the Crane Wife story, Meloy has written a collection of songs that leap off from the folk tale and into a rich, complex musical landscape. It’s tempting to think of The Crane Wife as a concept album, but that’s not really accurate. The album is more like an extrapolation of the folk tale, a re-imagining of its themes on a broader canvas. For every song that touches directly on Meloy’s interpretation of the Japanese legend (gorgeous album opener “The Crane Wife 3,” or its prequel, “The Crane Wife 1 and 2”), several more take their cue from the fabric of the story, only to stretch outward into other visions.

Sometimes the visions are of bleak urban murderers on the prowl in “The Shankhill Butchers”; sometimes the waterlogged mingling of love and death in “Summersong.” And though death, war, greed, and murder enshroud the album’s thematic framework, The Crane Wife is a resounding celebration of life. No matter how dark the words may get, the album’s spirit is buoyed by boundless energy and an expansive musical vocabulary. Styles and influences abound -- shades of Pink Floyd, Yes, and Fairport Convention trade off with more anthemic touchstones like middle-period R.E.M., The Waterboys, and even early U2 -- but the sound of The Decemberists is unique in contemporary pop music.

This blend of dark and light was informed by the recording process, during which the band was able, for the first time in its career, to take time building their arrangements in a well-equipped studio setting in Portland. Granted the luxury of preparation, the band and co-producers Chris Walla (guitarist/producer for Death Cab for Cutie) and Tucker Martine (Laura Veirs) cultivated an atmosphere of total creative freedom for the two-and-a-half months the group spent making The Crane Wife.

The album’s unquestionable centerpiece is the 13-minute murder ballad “The Island,” with its subsections “Come and See,” “The Landlord’s Daughter,” and “You’ll Not Feel the Drowning.” As the lyrics chronicle a tale of abduction, rape, and murder, the instruments chart a far-flung course through multiple musical genres and influences. In short, a masterpiece in itself. However, set alongside the urgent, anguished rock of “When the War Came,” and perfect pop confections like “O, Valencia” and “Sons and Daughters,” it begins to seem like a statement of purpose.





“There was a real strong sense among the band that we were not going to try to make a record that somebody would typically make for a major label,” Meloy explains. “We didn’t want the fact that we had signed onto a major label change our approach or aesthetic. In some ways, I think it pushed us farther to the left, farther out of the comfortable Decemberists zone.”

The Crane Wife may be many things -- a deconstructed folk tale, an intimate epic, a great new record by an essential American band -- but it could never be called typical.

"

 

 

Also read the DPRP review of the album - http://www.dprp.net/reviews/200705.php#decemberists - http://www.dprp.net/reviews/200705.php#decemberists

 

 

Think about it.

 

 

 

I agree. I would say that anybody who hears Crane Wife will understand why many of us ask fot the band's inclusion in the Archives. For me, of folk they only have the main tracks in the album, but thay should belong in the art-rock category, they're way past the related category.

 

Iván

 

Thanks for the recommendations, I'll make it happen!

 

Great addition... Finally one that agrees with... ME!

 

Ha! This is a scene out of HTM-Hell

Although the main page in italics is cool. Seriously, it needs a bit o' fixing