Print Page | Close Window

Your first and latest review for Prog Archives

Printed From: Progarchives.com
Category: Progressive Music Lounges
Forum Name: Prog Music Lounge
Forum Description: General progressive music discussions
URL: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=125683
Printed Date: February 18 2025 at 16:52
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: Your first and latest review for Prog Archives
Posted By: Logan
Subject: Your first and latest review for Prog Archives
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 09:53
I haven't written a lot of reviews (mostly just when I added an act), but I thought it might be fun to compare our first and latest album review written for Prog Archives.  If you haven't written any reviews, but have done ratings-without-reviews, then please do share your first and latest rating.  If you only have one review and various ratings-without-reviews, then please share your first review and latest rating-without-review.  If you have written only one review or rating, then please post that....  And please mention the categories that the albums are in.

Aside from posting your reviews/ ratings,  if you can hyperlink (embeds cause some people issues) to music off each album, that would be much appreciated (especially if its an obscurity).

Also, please mention the average rating at PA and number of reviews each act has/

In my case, both of these are the sole album by the act and both are quite obscure.

Here is my first review for Pascal Duffard's 1976 album Dieu est Fou (God is Insane), which is included in the  RIO/Avant Prog category.  It was added in 2007 (my first addition), has two reviews and has an average rating of 3.59  with 8 ratings in total.  

4 stars God, this is insane! Well, not really, but it is zany.

No review of this album would be complete without discourse on the lyrical themes of this irreverently titled French album ("God is Insane"). Unfortunately, French is not my lingua franca, and so, perhaps, an analysis of the music shall suffice (well, it won't, but...) However, not being a musicologist, and being rather tone deaf, I shall not be able to offer much in the way of learned observations of the music. Oh, I could bluff my way through it, focusing on tone, rhythm, harmony, and texture to make myself seem semi-intelligent, but instead I shall vaguely focus on my vague impressions, tangential commentary, and share my love of the music. Anyway, if music is the universal language, and French is the language of love, perhaps my love of this French music shall suffice.

This is a very good album to my ear, and this highly collectible and eccentric vinyl obscurity deserves a proper CD release. Since Duffard was able to secure the necessary requirements for such an ambitious and accomplished release with a large and talented group of performers, it is surprising that there is so little information readily available about him. However, he had worked on a project with Pascal Lami before who was quite a popular French pop artist, and so he must have been quite connected within the music industry. Both projects utilized a large array of performers, some of which worked on both.

I might say that this theatrical avant/ folk/ pop/ rock/ jazzy/ operatic/ Zeuhl-related album sounds as if it is Henri Gougaud meets Magma, meets Laurent Thibault, Pierrot Lunaire, and Ripaille. Additionally, I might say that it meets Hellebore, Zao, Ange, Schonberg's Les Miserables, Arthur Brown, Gyorgy Ligeti, Jerry Goldsmith and Claude Francois for a philosophical and ecclesiastical discussion over a cup of tea (champignon infused perhaps) . I could do this, or use a different set of names, but that seems excessively silly and I fear that it would not provide much help besides. Moreover, I would probably miss the best examples! More correctly, and inarguably, it is composer Pascal Duffard meets all those who participated on his project, and with some research on all those names, I could provide a more useful list than the one I presented. Suffice to say, I like to think of this project as an avant French answer to Andrew Lloyd Weber's "Jesus Christ Superstar." Musical theatre of the absurd in another way to describe this dramatic, wacky, and beautiful recording. Whether you think it absurdly good is another matter. Each vocalist plays a role in the pantomime which is unfolding -- from folk/pop to dialogue, to opera to chant, to laughter and ecstasy (each section has a dialogue of sorts with contrasting textures and tone, and the whole album feels cohesive despite jarring interjections/ juxtapositions and diverse musical expression). It seems a terrific concept even if the finer points of the concept elude me.

The album opens with a trippy, spacey piece (a la some music in "2001: A Space Odyssey") with bleeping electronics that would suit some acid-enhancing sci-fiish movie from the late 60's/ early 70's. From there, it moves into dramatic, operatic, weird free jazzy territory interspersed with experimental avant madness and beautiful poignant-sounding chanson and acoustic passages that provide good contrast and a satisfying playfulness. Bombastic, pretty, strange, pretty strange, and I think pretty wonderful. I also discern a delicious sense of irony in the proceedings.

The direction, arrangements, and performers are very good, as is the production. Although I fully want to give it five stars as it's one of my favourite albums, I find the finale a bit of a letdown. I would not expect an epic, majestic finale, but I would have liked it to end on a very dramatic note. Instead, it tails off and fizzles; not necessarily in a bad way, however. It may work well for the concept, but I would have liked something grander (perhaps of the Grand Guignal variety). The way it ends is just a bit too anti-climactic for me. So I give it four stars for the lack of "kaboom." The Earth getting blown up at the end due to a deus ex machina, now THAT'S a finale, but, though a rather Prog concept, may be too Hollywoody (especially if "the guy" and "the girl" were to live happily ever after against all odds). Considering that the vinyl can set one back hundreds of dollars, one may expect plenty of "bang" for the buck! If only there was a sequel....

http://www.progarchives.com/review.asp?id=152588#social-comments" rel="nofollow - http://www.progarchives.com/review.asp?id=152588" rel="nofollow - - 0 social review comments   |  http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=152588" rel="nofollow - Review Permalink
Posted Saturday, November 24, 2007 |  http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=17175#postAReview" rel="nofollow - Review this album  |  http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=28343" rel="nofollow - Report  (Review #152588)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4gOwb2boM0" rel="nofollow - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n4gOwb2boM0

------------------------------------------------

My latest review was for These Trails's self-titled from 1973. I added it in early 2020 to Prog Folk, and it has my sole review and one other rating.  The average rating is 3.95 over 2 ratings.

4 stars These Trails are made for walking.

These Trails released just one album, which was a very limited, private pressing release in 1973. It wouldn't be until considerable years later that it got any significant attention, albeit this is still an obscurity. An obscurity that I find charming. While I place this roughly in the acid folk category, most of it is not really psychedelic. It's a mix.

I thought about doing a full track breakdown, but instead I'll mention some that may be of particular interest. While the initial highlight for me was the weird, psychedelic "Psyche I & Share Your Water", which starts off so beautifully, then turns so strange, the rather more conventional "El Rey Pescador" I find so utterly gorgeous that were I to make a mix album with but one song from this album, that would be my choice. It features the terrific vocals of Carlos Pardeiro, who clearly comes across, and was, a professional singer. Such beautiful guitar work, and that addition of sitar gives it something of a Spanish music meets raga quality. "Garden Botanum" is another of the stranger tracks, and the synths give it an unusual off-kilter feel. And tracks like "Hello Lou" and "Waipou" are wonderful.

While I wouldn't so much describe it as folk-rock, I think that the way the synthesizer is incorporated gives it more Prog appeal (of the electronic Prog, Dionne- Bregent ilk). Mostly I would recommend it to those who can appreciate both Acid Folk and sunshine folk,

I think it can fit alongside various acid folk acts in the archives such as Linda Perhacs ( Parallelograms), Vashti Bunyan, Shelagh McDonald, and various acid folk or acid folk related ones outside of it. It has some of Joni Mitchell's qualities, and in parts it reminds me of Comus' To Keep From Crying, which is hardly a bad thing in my estimation. While the mix of Hawaiian music, Spanish, hippyish folk, electronics, chamber folk , and psychedelia is quite unique, certainly to my collection, for those who like this, I would recommend listening to the wondrous Extradition's Hush as well as Linda Perhacs Parallelograms , Additionally, I would suggest that it has something of a "The Wicker Man" (1973) soundtrack (a favourite of mine) vibe to it, only more so if "The Wicker Man" took place on a lovely, breezy, laid back Hawaiian island and was more luau than sinister sacrifice. Still, I rather sense something slightly sinister lurking under the surface of this hippyish album, and perhaps a pig was sinisterly sacrificed for that luau (I'd rather think they were vegans). But that may merely be a product of my disturbed psyche.

If I have a quibble, a minor one, the vibrato of Margaret Morgan can be a little too distracting, but I absolutely love this album. Not that ratings matter much methinks, but five for me, and four for PA purposes (although I would not claim that it is an "excellent addition to any prog rock collection". I would say that it's likely to be an excellent addition to well rounded folkies who like Hawaiian folk music, hippy stuff, and acid folk -- how odd that that is not an option for the rating. I would sooner recommend this to folkies than proggers, and to those into gentle, pastoral music rather than thrash metal, as one might expect of a folk album. This is an essential album in my collection that I have returned to again and again.

http://www.progarchives.com/review.asp?id=2316056#social-comments" rel="nofollow - http://www.progarchives.com/review.asp?id=2316056" rel="nofollow - - 0 social review comments   |  http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=2316056" rel="nofollow - Review Permalink
Posted Thursday, February 13, 2020 |  http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=61921#postAReview" rel="nofollow - Review this album  |  http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=28343" rel="nofollow - Report  (Review #2316056)


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WA8Nrk9-ayo" rel="nofollow - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WA8Nrk9-ayo

----------------------------------------
Maybe this should have been in top 10s and lists, but your review and ratings might not be at all about your favourites.  Or some other place.  



Replies:
Posted By: dougmcauliffe
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 10:05
I think I went back and altered my first reviews cause they were so.... not good, vague and poorly written. So unfortunately my really poor ones are probably lost.

Latest: King Gizzard LW

4 stars L.W. follows up last years release of K.G. which continued the bands exploration into the middle eastern shaded psychedelic rock they started on Flying Microtonal Banana, which happens to be my favorite album by the band. I really enjoyed K.G. last year, to me it felt like maybe their most collaborative sounding album to date bringing a little bit of all their past styles together under the umbrella of microtonal instrumentation. I rated it 4 stars back then and i'd say I still hold it right around that 3.5-4 star range. To me it was a very solid record with a lot of good groove, but for some reason it just didn't have the same shelf life as some of their other records did for me. Now we have L.W. which seems to be the conclusion to this style, these two albums really go hand in hand with the closing track off K.G. flowing right into the opening track here with "If Not Now, Then When?"

Now it's important to mention K.G. came under fire from some fans and critics of the band for sounding like the band was treading water and repeating themselves. Personally though, I just thought musically start to finish the album was really solid and at the end of the day, I had a lot of fun with it. I don't think such complaints are unfounded, as when I listen to a song like Some of Us or Straws in the Wind, it sounds comfortably King Gizzard to me, but this certainly wasn't something I felt across the whole record. Personally I always judge an album on its own merits, if I like the songs, than we're chillin! Now the reason I bring all of this up is because this record is coming under even more fire from some camps for apparently being a worse offender than the last one and i'm seeing a lot of people completely write it off for this reason. However... I don't know.... I just think this album is pretty... awesome honestly! After several listens I absolutely prefer this one to K.G. and I think this delivers on the same level as many of the high points of K.G. but on a very consistent basis between its 9 songs. The tracks all jive really well together for me and it makes a really groovy, fun and relatively easy listen. This record falls heavily into their psychedelic rock camp, while still carrying some of the odd times and unconventional riffage they've picked up over time. I love the production value here and all the super psychedelic ear candy sounds scattered throughout the songs. Listening through, I just feel like I've delved into a big dusty cloud of psychedelia and I love it.

Getting into the songs now, opening up is the aforementioned "If Not Now, Then When?" It opens with somewhat of an abrasive transition from The Hungry Wolf of Fate, K.G.'s closer. But it all fizzles out as this real crunchy clavinet comes in. When the rhythm section fires off it's a super groovy and satisfying payoff that I just have to move to while listening. Lot's of great melodies throughout, just a super solid opener and a pretty unique one for the band at that. Following that is O.N.E which reminds me of Automation off the last album because I feel they both serve a similar purpose, and that being getting the ball rolling and getting some momentum kicked off for the next suite of songs. This one opens with a bit of a hypnotic and floaty start, before kicking into that very driving rhythm section. Lot's of stuff to grab onto within this song with a cool little guitar breakdown in the middle. "Pleura," follows this up and this has a real headbanging riff to it, you kinda have to headbang in a weird rhythmic pattern though but it works. This ones got a pretty frantic feel to it, towards the middle it settles down a little into a slightly toned down sounding spin on the verse before calming completely down right before we hear a good ol' "woooOOOO" bringing us right back into that main riff coming through at full power. Awesome, high energy song. Supreme Ascendancy is where the album actually steps thing up a little bit for me, and I really feel it keeps the bar at this high level for the remainder of its runtime. It's got this super upbeat psychedelic Anatolian rock instrumentation opening things up, i'm actually having a little trouble describing it but for what that's worth, I think that's the mark of something pretty cool! Just a great vibe to this one, the instrumentals here are some of their most textured if you ask me with some nice organ coming through to accompany the main hook. The following track Static Electricity is easily one of the best songs, arguably the best for my money. It opens with this super menacing guitar riff backed by a real brooding electronic soundscape. The vocals got this ghosty tone to it while in the rhythm department I really feel the now singular drummer has really stepped things up and distinguished himself as a very key member of the band now that the two drummer dynamic is no more. Everything about this song just touches all the bases for me, I love the super earthy sounding passage at the 3:00 mark, the song reaches a sweet crescendo and playout towards the end, great stuff.

East West Link follows that awesome track up and keeps the album moving carrying a similar drive to Static Electricity. We see more nice subtle rhythmic choices with some bongos? Hell yeah! There's a really cool instrumental section around the halfway mark. On it's own, this is a song I have a little less to say about, but it fits like a glove in the context of a full album listen. The following track "Ataraxia," is another highlight and contender for the best song. The riffage in this song is tied for the best on the album for me, more on that later! When the full band comes in the main riff is just absolutely filthy and once again, I think a lot of credit for this can be placed on the drumming. When it suddenly moves right into the verse like a light switch, it's just so satisfying, pardon me for sounding like a broken record here but once again, the stars of the show here are the drums and bass seamlessly playing around the riffs and vocal melodies. I just cant rave about this track enough, a real mastery of rises and falls, build ups and payoffs. Now in the final stretch, "See Me" comes through next taking you through a dusty maze of music. It has a pretty bouncy feel to it with more of those uhhh... hard to describe psychedelic chiming instrumentals taking the lead. I'll group this one with East West Link as being less of a track you'll just throw on out of context, but in a full album listen, this is a nice bridge between two of the goliath songs. That brings me into the closing track, the familiarly titled "K.G.L.W" which ties these two albums all together. This song, clocking in at over 8 minutes King Gizzard pulls through with in my opinion, one of their best songs ever. Combing elements of Prog Metal, Doom/Stoner Metal and Pysch Rock, it's like a fever dream for me. I'd have to argue it's much more successful and original on all fronts than K.G.'s closer "The Hungry Wolf of Fate." The riffs are so crunchy throughout and these eight minutes and change just melt away as King Gizzard takes you on a hellish tour through evil L.W. land or.... something? One thing I really like about this song is that there's very little downtime and they come at you basically right out the gate with an aggression. At 2:07 it drops into this awesome rhythmic riff and I think the fact that it comes out of a stretch of 7/4 into this 4/4 section makes it a very enjoyable and hard hitting transition. Some of the more doomy elements follow with larger than life walls of muddy distortion followed by some sweet slow and fiery riffage. The band has proved to be more than competent at this style, and I'd love to see them embrace it more on a full album basis, even the fact that you could classify parts of this song as Progressive Metal makes me very excited. The prospect of King Gizzard tackling that style.... oh man.

So yeah, I just really love this record and I really can't really get behind some of the flak getting thrown its way. There's been times in the past where I feel like the band has missed the mark or undelivered a little bit, but that's just not the case for this album. Every song hits the mark, I have a ton of fun listening to this record on repeat and I think it stands sturdy and comfortably against some of their other really good albums! Thanks for reading, giving this one 4.5 stars. Am I going against the grain here? If so, that's okay, this bands got something for everyone in my opinion and I'm just happy that they're one of the premier modern rock bands and I get to be a fan during their reign! Cheers!

(For progarchives sake, I'm going to begrudgingly round down to 4 stars, time will tell where it ultimately falls!)


First: Foxtrot - Genesis 


5 stars Foxtrot is my favorite album ever made, period. My list of top 10 changes quite frequently but in all my time listening to prog, this has remained constant

We open with the soaring Mellotron of Watcher of the Skies, if this isn't the best use of a mellotron in prog, I don't know what is. The band progressively joins in and holds no punches. It's also worth noting Collins also has some carpel-tunnel inducing drumming going on.

The production on Collins drums and the album overall is fantastic as well. Gabriel sounds great and everything has a punch behind it

We have two softer tracks with Time Tables and Horizons. Time Tables is more of a banks song, it has a real comfortable old-english vibe, it's got a nice hook. While horizons is Hacketts classical inspired piece. Makes me feel like in sitting on a beach all alone during the sunset.

Get em Out By Friday has always been a favorite, awesome explosive intro (drumming is worth noting) with a hard hitting verse. It's a song in the same style as Epping Forest or Hogweed where gabriel plays several different characters. My favorite part is when it turns to acoustic ("After all this time...") Gabriels vocals actually have some real emotion behind it in this section.

Can Utility and the Coastliners is a real gem. It starts light and builds into a heavy song with the dark organs found throughout nursery cryme. The band plays with such a great intensity throughout the song

Well... you already know Suppers Ready im sure!

I'll keep it short but it is never boring and the climax at the end is chilling. Its perfection, and I'll leave it at that.

In my opinion, this is the best album ever made, a few come close for me (Animals, Court of the Crimson King, Moonmadness) but I doubt that in my lifetime i'll hear an album better than this.


We've come a long way, foxtrot is no longer my favorite prog album ever made :) I think over the last couple years i've really improved my writing quite a bit, likely through reading others more descriptive reviews.



-------------
The sun has left the sky...
...Now you can close your eyes


Posted By: SteveG
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 10:26
STRAWBS - Full Bloom, Acoustic Strawbs Live
10:45:00 AM EST, 2/24/2021
Four Stars. This live album finds the early Acoustic Strawbs trio of Dave Cousins, Dave Lambert and Brian Willoughby (Chas Cronk would replace Willoughby after this tour) flashing their wares at an audio shop in Canada that was captured with excellent, if slightly amateurish, sound quality (a slightly lopsided sound mix on occasion being the culprit) that was taken from the soundboard. What the band performs best are the songs taken from their all acoustic album "Baroque And Roll" like "Ghosts" and "Tears And Pavan". These songs showcase the trio's amazing ability to supplement all the melodies, counter melodies and electric guitar leads, naturally, found on the studio versions. The trio also does an amazing acoustic version of "Autumn" from the "Hero And Heroine" album, with Lambert and Willoughby doing a clinic on guitar interplay on that song's magnificent opening musical section. Cousins and Lambert cover the alternating lead and harmony vocals flawlessly and do the same on all of the songs. Where the little band struggles is on a couple of the more heavily orchestrated songs like "Down By The Sea" and the title track to "Hero And Heroine", where no amount of loud manic strumming or deft playing can make up for the missing orchestra and mellotron/keyboard parts found on the original studio versions. Still, it's fascinating to hear them try. For playing and singing their hearts out so marvelously, 3.5 stars rounded up to 4 seems quite deserving for these hard working veteran prog rockers caught on a great night with exceptional sound quality.
STRAWBS - Acoustic Strawbs: Baroque & Roll
4:53:52 PM EST, 4/11/2014
 Four Stars. On second thought... I, like many, was disappointed when I first heard this album. What? No new material? No bass or drums? No keyboards? This is a new recording by one of the greatest prog groups ever. Are you kidding? Well, after a few years of second listens (after hearing Painted Sky without all the preconceived baggage) all I can say is that this album is an under appreciated jewel. The low key and, no doubt, low cost production adds a warm homemade vibe to this recording and Dave Cousins is still in relatively good voice at this stage. The guitar interplay between Dave Lambert and Brian Willobougby is stellar despite a couple of awkward moments. Indeed, there is even a croaked vocal by Cousins and an obvious flubbed lyric from Lambert that were no doubt deliberately left uncorrected. An inside joke, perhaps, that makes the album all the more endearing to me. It's also fascinating to hear all three guitarists recreate all the keyboards and orchestrations of the songs almost to the point that they are not even missed. If you liked Deja Fou and Painted Sky, but found this album lacking the first time around, please give it a second chance in order to appreciate it for what is and not what we thought it was supposed to be.
 
The first and last with two similar albums 7 years apart. I don't know why my cut and paste keeps coming up in a blue font, but c'est la vie.


-------------
This message was brought to you by a proud supporter of the Deep State.


Posted By: lazland
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 10:43
What a fantastic idea.

My first review on the site was Marillion’s Happiness is the Road. I gave it five stars, whereas, if I were to write it now, or edit it, my rating would be reduced to four stars.

5 stars I have been a fan of the band since the very start, watching them at The Marquee when Market Square Heroes was released. So, I get a little depressed when people post how disappointed they are with Hogarth. Please[- you will not get Fish, so get over it!!

The new LP is right up there with Brave and Marbles, two works of utter genius, and by far the finest works by the band. Happiness Is The Road comes at a particularly creative period for the band.

I will not review track by track - it would take too long.

The LP is produced magnificently and the soundscapes and atmosphere are intriguing and beautiful. Mark Kelly's work is particularly to the fore in this LP and Steve Rothery is used somewhat sparingly, but, as ever, adds so much. And yes - Steve Hogarth dominates with his vocals, and rightly so. Listen to Essence to see why I regard the man as the greatest vocalist in modern day progressive rock.

So....you will not get any early Genesis sounding tracks (and I love these, by the way). What you get is a modern band still pushingthe boundaries of progressive music and creating true radical music - surely what we are all after?

Download this from the Marillion website. You will not regret it.


My latest of 343 reviews is Steven Wilson’s latest.


4 stars When I get an album and start listening to it, I do not stop to think about what particular sub-genre it might belong to in Prog Archives, or whether, in fact, it should be here in the first place. I am slightly old fashioned in that my first thought is; is this any good? Do I like it? Will I like it moving forward after that initial rush of excitement on the first few listens?

The answer to the (as far as the so-called hardcore fan base is concerned) "sellout" electronica pop/rock album that is The Future Bites is yes. I do like it. It is clever conceptually regarding rampant commercialism and its use of technology (Follower is a very clever commentary, as well as including a fantastic guitar riff). Musically, it is as tight as one would expect from a maestro musician. In terms of its sound, it is as polished as one would expect from the man most in demand for remixes on the planet. And in the 10 or so listens thus far, each time I find myself foot-tapping and head-nodding in appreciation at what I am hearing, most definitively on the quite marvellous 12 Things I Forgot, which, perhaps deliberately, reminds one strongly of my favourite Porcupine Tree track, Lazarus. 

Elsewhere, we have a guest slot by Elton John on Personal Shopper, an extremely clever exposé of all those utterly inessential "essential" items of shopping we are so addicted to, showing if nothing else that Sir John has a nice sense of irony about himself. The passage where he reels out the list of items is a dreamy sequence in stark contrast to the relentlessly upbeat opening themes, and this continues before the corporate electronica reasserts itself.

Most of the music here is beat driven and electronically upbeat, and certainly a massive contrast to the relentless, if brilliant, gloom of Hand. Cannot. Erase, although there are a couple of tracks which can be identified as natural progressions from that album in their melancholy, namely Man of the People and Count of Unease.

All in all, I admire this album and the driving force behind it. Wilson is progressing, and taking his musical vision to places he wants them to go, rather than the somewhat obsessive minority who demand a repeat of In Absentia every time he records something.

In closing, I might also add that this album reminds me quite a bit of that period in the early 1980's when every "proper" Genesis fan decried the commerciality of ATTWT and Duke, and wanted Collins strung up after the massive success of Face Value. Let me tell you something. There are a great many people about now who love a lot of the music we hold dear on this site because of the accessibility of those albums, and others such as 90125. They listened, and thought, "this ain't half bad", and explored further.

Steven Wilson is a man who I think is becoming more and more like the man he obviously holds in the highest regard (and it is reciprocated), namely one Robert Fripp, an artist and leader who spent an entire 50+ career reinventing himself and his music.

I for one look forward very much to the next instalment of Wilson's journey, because The Future Bites is an excellent album those with an open mind to class pop/prog/rock will take a great deal of enjoyment from.

And you know what? As much of a masterpiece I regard aforementioned Hand....this one will be on the deck quite a bit more often, even if it is as background whilst I work. Yep. Accessible. Easy to listen to, but still oozing intelligence in every note and word. That will do for me.




-------------
Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org

Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!


Posted By: Logan
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 11:09
^ Thanks.  What I love about reading the reviews is not just the insight into  the music, but the insight into the people (their thinking) writing the reviews (especially if they are people I "know" at the forum) and it is interesting to compare how we started to our latest efforts....


Posted By: progaardvark
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 11:32
It's hard to believe my first review was written back in 2007. Like most newcomers to the site I generally stuck with the more well-known prog acts and I generally kept my reviews on the short side since there were so many better and longer written reviews for these more well-known albums. Where I would make my reviews longer and go into more detail were, what I thought of at the time, lesser-known or not-as-well-known bands. For some reason I went on a hiatus after 2013 (a combination of lack of time and laziness) and only just recently wrote three reviews at the end of last year. I do have a good deal of more obscure things in my collection and should try and write more reviews specifically for that stuff, but writing something coherent takes some time and I need to be in the right mood for it.

Anyway... first one was Genesis - From Genesis to Revelation, June 14, 2007:

2 stars Being introduced to Genesis in the mid-1980s, I worked my way backwards through their catalogue from the self-titled Genesis album of 1983. As I progressed with each album, they got better and better. What an amazing group this was. Alas, I finally reached their first album and was quite disappointed with it.

Here we have the humble beginnings of what will become one of the greatest prog bands of the 1970s. It's basically a collection of mellow 1960s pop songs, sorely lacking the musical and lyrical skill of Trespass and all other albums that followed. Still, you can hear potential here and there on this oddity of a record. On some of the songs, Gabriel's voice carries that raw energy he would be widely known for on later recordings, especially on the song "In the Beginning." The music though, has an almost demo feel to it.

Not the best place to start if you want to get into Genesis. I would recommend starting with Trespass and then acquiring each album chronologically after that. Only for the curious, thus two stars.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Latest review was Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets - Live at the Roundhouse, December 3, 2020:

5 stars This review is for the 2 CD/DVD version.

Nick Mason's Saucerful of Secrets had its origins not with Nick Mason, but with guitarist Lee Harris (formerly with the new wave, post-punk band Blockheads). Harris realized that no one asks Nick Mason to do anything anymore and no one was really performing the ancient stuff from Pink Floyd's oeuvre. Harris happened to be good friends with bassist Guy Pratt, Pink Floyd's bassist since the A Momentary Lapse of Reason tour. Harris didn't think Mason would ever consider his idea, so he sold it to Pratt and Pratt loved it. And so Pratt took it to Mason and the idea took off.

So, Pratt was also friends with Gary Kemp, lead guitarist and backing vocalist of new wave band Spandau Ballet, and Dom Beken, keyboardist from The Orb and collaborator of Rick Wright who is responsible for maintaining Wright's archive. He suggested them to Mason and they started rehearsing just to see what would happen. A rehearsal with family and friends was well-received and then a sold-out test show at Dingwalls, a 500-seat club in London in May 2018. A couple more small shows eventually led to a European tour in September 2018, followed by a North American tour in 2019.

This package contains 2 CDs of the live set recorded from concerts held at The Roundhouse in London, on May 3 and 4, 2019. It also includes a DVD of the performance. The live set included performances of selected songs from Pink Floyd's albums from 1967 to 1972, all pre-Dark Side material. The only album that no material was taken from was the studio portion of Ummagumma. The set list also included the singles Arnold Layne, See Emily Play, and Point Me at the Sky. It also included the song Vegetable Man which was considered for either their second album or as their third single, but was scrapped (it later appeared in the The Early Years box set).

So, Mason didn't want this to be just a covers band. He let the members add their personalities to the songs. Some of them were extended, some of the bass lines were modified, additional guitar solos were added, more modern keyboards were melded into it, and slight rearrangements here and there. But although they had this freedom to put their own stamp on these early songs, they tried to be respectful of the originals. The end result is a refreshing experience giving us not just a taste of what these might have sounded like back in the day, but bringing them into the present in a very tasteful manner for newer generations to hear.

One thing that really touches me with this one is it's diversity. They pulled a wide range of different types of songs from a five-year period in which Pink Floyd was experimenting in many ways just find who they were as a band. From dizzying psychedelic wipeouts using many interesting effects, to whimsical fairy-tale psychedelic pop songs, to heavy rock and rollers, to grandiose and pompous displays of instrumental prog rock. The gang here really put some thought into these selections so that they would gel together in a seamless manner,

Highlights for me were performances of Astronomy Domine; the amazing riff of Lucifer Sam; the very robotic and electronic feel they gave to Obscured by Clouds/When You're In; a stunning performance of Remember a Day that would make Rick Wright proud; the seamless integration of the first part of "If" with selections from the Atom Heart Mother suite, ending with a reprise of the second part of "If"; the wonderfully complex bass riff of Let There Be More Light; an extended performance of Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun (complete with gong); the whimsical Bike; the fan classic One of These Days; and an amazing performance of the band's namesake, the instrumental A Saucerful of Secrets.

The band is tight, plays well together, and plays off of each other skillfully. Lee Harris is no David Gilmour or Syd Barrett, but he pulls off all the solos with grace and skill. Pratt's bass playing is, in my opinion, an improvement over Waters. Kemp's guitar work is also skilled and definitely has the effects down pat. Both Kemp's and Pratt's vocals are no replacement for the originals and that might be the only thing somebody might have something negative to say. However, they made these songs their own and stamped their personalities on it. The harmonies the two do together are a nice fit. Beken very much nailed Wright's style of playing and you even hear a little bit of his experience from The Orb here and there. He keeps with the original sounds when it seems right and ventures off into new territory in places where it seems to make the songs better than the originals. It's a nice and refreshing touch.

The star of the show is of course, Nick Mason. The pre-Dark Side period of Pink Floyd has some of the most complex and adventurous drumming Mason did during his career. At the age of 74 (at the time of the recording of this concert), he can still perform this amazing stuff in all its glory. I was quite impressed with his performance. And he hasn't forgotten how to use the mallets.

The lighting at the show was in the true Pink Floyd fashion. The Victorian features of The Roundhouse give it an almost surreal atmosphere. The building was originally constructed in 1847 and it contained a railway turntable inside of it. It reopened in 1964, first as a cultural centre with a theatre, and in 1966 as an arts venue. Both Pink Floyd and Soft Machine performed on its opening night. Performances were on a makeshift stage with power running from nearby buildings. So in a way, this 2019 performance was a way of making a full circle back to the beginnings of Mason's career.

The DVD also has some bonus features. There is a short film of some of their band rehearsals. This was nice and all that, but it was too short and not enough band banter to make it interesting. The meat of the bonus features are interviews with each of the band's members. This was a joy to watch to learn about how they all knew each other and how the band evolved and some of the history of Pink Floyd.

So, in closing, a big thank you to Lee Harris for having this gem of an idea. And a big thank you to Nick Mason for having the guts to bring this early period of Pink Floyd back to life and presenting it in such a refreshing and tasteful manner.

A well deserved five stars.



-------------
----------
i'm shopping for a new oil-cured sinus bag
that's a happy bag of lettuce
this car smells like cartilage
nothing beats a good video about fractions


Posted By: nick_h_nz
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 11:42
Probably not worth doing mine, since the first was sometime last year, and the last was probably also sometime last year (or possibly this). 😄



-------------
https://tinyurl.com/nickhnz-tpa" rel="nofollow - Reviewer for The Progressive Aspect


Posted By: siLLy puPPy
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 11:49
1st review

Comus

First Utterance
As my FIRST UTTERANCE on PA, I have chosen one of my all time favorite albums, one that needs no introduction on this site as I see it has many ratings and is situated in the top 300 best albums.

This album remains an anomaly even today. I still have never heard anything else quite like this. A strange alchemy of folk instrumentation, psychedelic rock schizophrenia, progressive time signatures, tribal drumming, tortured strings and subject matter that makes me want to consider this the first black metal album. Well, black folk maybe? Whatever you call it – it is undoubtedly one of the most successful fusion albums of folk, rock and the avant-garde.

In Greek mythology, Comus was the god of festivity and represents anarchy and chaos. This is the only album by this group that lives up to that description and does it perfectly from beginning to end. After listening to the follow-up albums TO KEEP FROM CRYING and the 2012 comeback album OUT OF THE COMA, it appears that this was the only album where they channeled the very essence of the Greek god himself and took the listener to a entirely different realm where demons frolicked freely throughout the darkened lands.

This was love at first listen because it was so different from anything I had ever heard before, but it took many listens to really get it and appreciate its complexity. After a gazillion listens I can honestly say that I never get tired of hearing it. It's one that continues to amaze me now as it did the first time I heard it. Five big fat demented stars. And oh yeah, loooove that album cover.

Handshake

1998th review

Ad Nauseam
Imperative Imperceptible Impulse
4 Mar 2021
4.5 stars rounded up to 5

AD NAUSEUM hit the ground running in the world of avant-garde tech death metal in 2015 with its lauded “Nihil Quam Vacuitas Ordinatum Est” which proved to be the second coming of Gorguts’ classic “Obscura” wrapped in completely new clothing. With bantering wails of sonic swarms of atonal and jagged guitar riffs teased out into unthinkable detachment, AD NAUSEUM proved they were worthy successors and pretty much handed honorable post doctorates in “Obscura” studies which they so successfully took to the next level in the world of avant-garde metal excess.

If any band can be accused of nerding out to the max, surely it’s this quartet of unorthodox musicians hailing from Scio, Italy which is just a hop, skip and a jump from the city of Venice. Having gotten the unrelenting angst out of their system after a debut album that excelled in a relentless attack so frighteningly intense that it was advised to avoid for those who were faint of heart, after six long years AD NAUSEUM returns with its second coming in the form of IMPERATIVE IMPERCEPTIBLE IMPULSE and as well as leaving the Latin locutions behind, so too does AD NAUSEUM jettison the full speed throttle that dominated the debut.

While the 20th century integral serialism and avant-garde classical underpinnings of the debut rarely peeked out of the bantering din, IMPERATIVE IMPERCEPTIBLE IMPULSE showcases a more relaxed AD NAUSEUM that has allowed less abrasive moments of contemplation to intermingle within the incessant metal brawl that continues the bantering din of the Gorguts playbook. Album #2 features six tracks, all of which exceed the eight minute mark with “Coincidentia oppositorum” racing past the twelve. With a running time of 57 minutes, IMPERATIVE IMPERCEPTIBLE IMPULSE offers a more balanced approach laid down on the debut with an extraordinary attention to details that displays this band’s outstanding commitment to crafting some of the most forward thinking avant-garde metal of the decade.

While still steeped in tech death clothing with growly vocals, aggressive technical guitar wizardry and abrasive atonalities, AD NAUSEUM has like many of its contemporaries in reality drifted off into a totally new world of extreme metal that doesn’t really fit into the established orthodoxies of death, black, sludge, progressive etc metal. While currently only the term avant-garde can really fit the bill, AD NAUSEUM continues the death metal immediacy with the Deathspell Omega abstractness and Meshuggah-like disscontempt of established paradigms. On this sophomore release, AD NAUSEUM pretty much takes all the features of the debut and amplifies them severalfold.

This is the kind of metal monstrosity that has alienated a lot of traditional metalheads for sure as this type of experimental abstractness has totally left the gravitational pull of classic metal approaches and ventured into unknown territory where it seems there is no end in sight as these types of bands venture ever further into the unexplored terrains. AD NAUSEUM seems to have perfected a balancing act here as it delivers unrelenting brutality in the form of atonal dissonance riff barrages wrapped up in progressive tech death clothing however the moments of non-metal shine through much more brightly and feature interesting orchestrations that evoke a keen sense of 20th century classical composers ranging from Arnold Schoeberg and John Cage to free dissonance and experimentalism of Charles Ives and Edgard Verèse. Metal bands like this are truly the new avant-garde classical. There are more moments on this one that remind me of Kayo Dot or Maudlin of the Well than album #1.

This is truly abstractionist’s paradise as AD NAUSEUM really understands the dynamics of metal-in-opposition and develops their post-Obscura-ism even further. Graced with a keen attention to production values as well as over-the-top metal dynamism, this band has truly mastered the true intent of avant-garde extreme metal and showcases a more mature album although many will be instantly alienated by the jagged uninviting soundscapes presented. Advanced metal who study calculus for fun. This is not the instantly warm and fuzzy metal of decades prior but rather the ultimate expression in nerd metal run amok. Personally i love this sh*t and AD NAUSEUM has unleashed a brilliant followup to its already ambitious debut.


-------------

https://rateyourmusic.com/~siLLy_puPPy


Posted By: Meltdowner
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 12:00
Cool idea! I wrote my first review even before joining the forum and it's safe to say that my English greatly improved since I started exchanging musical thoughts with you all and read your reviews. It's still a bit broken but so is my Portuguese Tongue I only wrote 16 reviews in 7 years though, I rarely feel the urge to write.


Led Zeppelin - Physical Graffiti (2014-1-13)
4 stars Physical Graffiti is a great album because it's like a compilation of all the Led Zeppelin's fases: from Blues Rock (Led Zeppelin IV), to acoustic (Led Zeppelin III) and Prog related (Houses of The Holy) songs. So this is a good starting point to someone who never heard any album from them. My favorite tracks are "Kashmir", "In The Light", "Down By The Seaside" and "Ten Years Gone" since they are the most interesting to anyone who want to discover their Prog side. I don't think it's a masterpiece because it has some weak moments: "Sick Again", "Boogie With Stu" and "In My Time Of Dying" is too long.


Michael Brückner - Footprints (2020-12-29)
5 stars Footprints was easily the new album I listened to the most this year and my favourite album from Michael Brückner (from the tiny portion of his catalogue I know). It was released by the recent Argentinian label Cyclical Dreams, dedicated to Berlin School and Michael brings us an album that harks back to the golden era of the genre while displaying his unique personality and deep understanding of electronic ambience.

I was immediately drawn by the mysterious and colourful liquid painting cover by Tony Jimenez that reminded me of Tangerine Dream's "Atem", and I think it reflects perfectly the music found on this album.

The opener "Everlasting Footprints" was initially recorded in 2015 as an homage to Edgar Froese who had recently passed away but was shelved for a few years (as he didn't want to capitalize on Edgar's passing) and then was reworked for this album. In this 22 minute piece Michael explores the whole Tangerine Dream sonic universe, from Mellotron flutes, to wavetable synthesis and pulsating sequencers with glimpses of piano, organ, guitar and drums. While it could seem like a huge mess on paper, he successfully managed to create a mastercrafted tapestry of sounds. Some elements are used sparingly while others come and go to provide an anchor in this relentless and constantly evolving epic.

After that long musical journey, "The Sequence of Memories" brings some stability while never losing momentum, with its bright sequencers, wobbly synths and reverberating pads.

"Carbon" is a very odd and unpreditable track (in a good way), even after a few dozen listens I never know where it will take me. Slightly deranging at first, percussive the next moment and suddenly becomes contemplative. On the second half it starts shifting gears and all these elements collide to form the most fascinating and indescribable mood.

The album ends with "Space Suit", a cinematic three-part suite. The story I imagine is of an astronaut in awe with the sight of a strange yet beautiful quartz based planet. Suddenly the floor crumbles under his feet and after regaining conscience he finds himself in a luminous cave. Realizing that he lost communication with the ship, he has to find a way out before the oxygen runs out.

As usual, bonus tracks are provided, for those who want to dig deeper in his work and creative process. The CD has the 2015 recording of the opening track (simpler but not less engaging) while the download also comes working versions of the other tracks and improvisation sessions.

Once again Michael Brückner takes us on a colourful and emotional ride, constantly engaging and immensely inspired.

5 stars.



Posted By: Psychedelic Paul
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 12:02
My first review for Bachdenkel's Lemmings album is really not worth reading, but this is my latest (133rd)  review for The Parlour Band's "Is a Friend" (1972):-

5 stars THE PARLOUR BAND have the unusual distinction of being from the Channel Island of Jersey near the French coast, which technically makes them a British band, even though they're not from Great Britain or the United Kingdom. The Parlour Band had a brief lunchtime in the spotlight with just one rare album to their name: "Is a Friend?" (1972), but they weren't about to hang up their instruments just yet, because they changed their name firstly to "A Band Called O", and then again to "The O Band" after moving to Leicester in the English Midlands. They recorded four more albums there in the mid-1970's, before the band finally went their separate ways in 1977.

These Jersey boys really know how to Rock!! The album opens in barnstorming style with the rip-roaring Jazz-Rock number "Forgotten Dreams". There's no chance of sleeping through this song though. It's a Hammond organ driven blast from the past (with shades of Brian Auger) that barrels along relentlessly for nearly three incredible minutes. The peaceful island of Bergerac and Beaujolais and Jersey cows will never be the same again. Onto Song No. 2 now and we're about to meet the "Pretty Haired Girl", a bright and bubbly Pop concoction about a girl who's sweet and nice, which sounds as warm and refreshing as a glass of pink champagne on ice. You can take comfort in the next lovely song too because it's "Springs' Sweet Comfort", a dreamy psychedelic flowers-in-your-hair number that's just as gently laid-back as the song title implies. You can almost smell the aromatic incense wafting over you in a purple haze of smoke. This song's as psychedelic as an explosion at a paint factory. After that dreamy song, it's time now to wake up and smell the coffee for "Early Morning Eyes", a lively jingly-jangly guitar number that's very reminiscent of the high- flying Byrds, and very good it is too. You can Turn Turn Turn and shake your Tambourine along to this danceable early morning wake-up call, or if you're not feeling that energetic, you can simply tap your feet along to the beat. It's all aboard the train now for "Follow Me", another catchy upbeat song to close out Side One, where the singer repeatedly urges us all to follow him around the mountain, until he finally runs out of steam.

And now we arrive at the big production number and the highlight of the album so far: "Evening". This gorgeous song features heavenly harmonies to die for, dynamic power chords and soaring vocals backed up by the tremendous sound of the Hammond organ. In fact, it's everything you could wish for in the best of Prog-Rock and had the potential to be a huge hit, if only... Sadly, the song was never released as a single, so it wasn't even a hit in Jersey, never mind the rest of the world. Anyway, don't be sad, because as Evening draws to a close it's time for some midnight romance with "Don't Be Sad". It's a gently lilting Folk refrain, so just lie back and relax and let this beautifully-crafted mellow ballad carry you away on a sea of blissful sweet dreams. This very impressive album continues with "Little Goldie", a warm- hearted song that sounds as sweet as honey and features some simply sublime guitar vibes. The penultimate song is an uplifting salute "To Happiness", when you're already halfway to happiness if you're lucky enough to have this wonderful long-lost album in your treasured prog collection. And finally, "Home" is where the prog is for an epic 3- piece suite to close the album. This sweeping seven-and-a-half minute long masterpiece is very reminiscent of The Beatles and makes a suitably fitting tribute to a marvellous album.

The Parlour Band's superb one-off album Is A Friend that deserves a warm welcome in any Prog-Rock fan's home.





Posted By: JD
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 12:07
I've done a massive 5 reviews since joining in 2009. I know, right?

The first was on Jan 30 2010

BUSKER - Northern Fantasies
5 Ratings with an average of 3.11

4 stars Full Disclosure :

Is it considered fair or unbiased to write a review for an album if you were involved in its making? I don't see why not, as long as you stay honest with yourself.

In the late 70's and early 80's I performed sound engineering duties for BUSKER both live and in the studio. Northern Fantasies existed only as a demo recording, recorded in 1975 on a 4 track reel to reel using bounce tracking. It was with great satisfaction that I finally convinced BUSKER keyboardist Steve McCann to turn this demo into a proper release. The music was slightly rearranged and a few single songs from the band's past were added to round out the Northern Fantasies album in 2007. I personally mixed, edited and mastered this release as well as photographed and designed the CD packaging.

Production :

This album was recorded at the BUSKER home studio and mixed and mastered at my own White Pine Media studio. The overall sound of the album has stayed true to its '70's roots in order to capture the mood of the pieces at the time they were written (1974). Many of the keyboard parts utilize the vintage sound that listeners of early prog may appreciate. But rest assured, the production is modern, clean and dynamic and shows what can be accomplished without a big studio budget when the music comes from the heart

16/20

Song Writing :

Northern Fantasies is comprised of 20 tracks in all, although they are presented in a 'concept album' format with most songs running into the next for a full 45 minute piece of music. I prefer to think of it more as a musical travelogue since all of the pieces are written about, or inspired by visits to various locations across the great nation of Canada. Not to mention that when originally performed live Northern Fantasies was accompanied by a multimedia stage show that included film and a slide show. This eclectic collection of music spans everything from progressive rock "Overture, Run Sun, Finale" to east coast folk "Uncle Alexander Newfoundlander, Inverness", classical "Winterlude" to jazz "Gastown" to straight ahead rock "Dangerous Dan McGrew" and just a little comic relief for good measure "Looney Bird, Lumberjack's Song (Fifi)"

17/20

Originality :

Northern Fantasies is a very original piece of music. While it's hard not to hear the influence of ELP in "Rocky Mountain Fanfare and Fugue" or Gentle Giant in the vocal stylings of "Run Sun" and "Coureurs de Bois" this is by no means a copy cat band who strives to sound like any other. While many prog listeners might associate Rush with the voice of Canadian prog, BUSKER presents a truly Canadian voice that captures the diversity of the country and its people with unmistakable originality.

20/20

Performance :

In listening to Northern Fantasies it's clear that Steve McCann and Randy Dawdy are proficient musicians (see band bio). What's refreshing is that the band doesn't suffer from DTS (Dream Theater Syndrome) or MGM (Musical Gymnastic Meanderings), that sometimes annoying habit of speedy scales to prove ones musical ability. Here BUSKER shows that they are players, being thoughtful when the mood is right "Atlantic Fisherman's Saga" or downright pompous "Finale" when it suits their purpose. Admittedly Steve is not a top gun on the guitar, but the fact that there are only two musicians to create this full symphonic sound shows what masters the are in their respective fields.

15/20

General Impressions :

Northern Fantasies is a valiant effort by an independent band that has not let the fact that a recording contract eluded them stop them from turning out some incredibly interesting and unique music. Always a band to hold high the flag of Canada, BUSKER proudly waves the maple leaf banner and serves up a nice slice of Canadiana for all to hear. This is by far the band's best overall album both for production and continuity. Highly recommended for anyone wanting to hear more of the Canadian progressive scene

17/20

Total = 85/100 (85% of 5 stars)

4.25



The Last one was Dec. 25 2014

Keith Emerson / Greg Lake Live From Manticore Hall

19 ratings with an average of 3.49

2 stars Slow and steady may win the race But some of these tunes need to pick up the pace

Full Disclosure :

Emerson shaped my youth with his brash, attacking style and Lake's smooth full voice filled my head with wonder, but as is life, we all have our "Time and a Place". As much as I still tell people who care about such things that ELP is my favorite band, this is a 'stroll' down memory lane and not an 'invigorating raunch' as would have been preferred. So this 'Rocker Walker' tour release must be viewed from that perspective.

Production :

If only ELP had had this same production value on earlier live albums, clean, clear and punchy. But that's only a part of production. Not having a real drummer is one of the first scars I find on this recording. Through no fault of their own (or maybe it was?) Carl Palmer is clearly absent. This leaves the recording a little thin and as much as I appreciate what Keith and Greg wanted to provide here they should have had a drummer in the wings to provide that vital support.

15/20

Song Writing :

During Greg's intro to this concert he speaks of he and Keith getting together in his studio to write some songs as the inspiration for this concert. Yet no new songs appear on this album. I find this to be one of the biggest issues I have with this album. What better way to thank the fans that have stuck around this long but to dish up some new music. Unfortunately it's not to be. Instead we get another greatest hits live outing. There is really nothing to draw an audience to this album short of completionism and I plead guilty as charged.

5/20

Originality :

I've mentioned in other reviews that live albums are tough for me to score high unless the musicians make a concerted effort to elevate the songs beyond their original arrangements. Few musicians or bands have done this well although I place ELP among them for re-arranging their own songs from time to time to keep things interesting. Opening the album is a very pleasant rendition of "From the Beginning" which promises an album of sonic bliss to come. For the most part it does deliver. Tarkus on the other hand is the counterbalance to this with a slow trodding version that ends in a distracting noisy synth solo that does nothing to enhance this once excellent piece of music.

6/20

Performance :

Like the 40th anniversary High Voltage concert this performance suffers from a lack of raw energy. But at 70 years of age for Emerson and 67 years for Lake what's to be expected. All our bodies break down over time and none expose it so much as athletes or musician who built their legacy around sacrificing their bodies for the love of their craft. The speed that made many of these tunes legendary has been slowed considerably and still the boys have trouble staying in time with one another.

Without Carl's involvement here, turning to the infamous 'Japanese Drummer' when needed left me feeling hungry for a more rhythmic performance. A complete re-arrangement of songs like 'Bitches Crystal' to a more, jazzy piano guitar piece might have saved this album a little.

One of the few saving graces I found was the beautiful guitar serenade on "From the Beginning" and the sweet piano intro to Luck Man that concludes the album. There is little to no improvisation here and it's a quality I greatly miss in this recording, even the Lucky Man synth solo is weak and dull.

8/20

General Impressions :

This was certainly a disappointment after waiting so long to hear it. It could have been an excellent memoir of two of Prog's greatest contributors but instead turns out to be a soon forgotten night of two buddies kicking back, not quite sure how to remember the times of yore.

8/20

Total = 42/100 (42% of 5 stars)

2.10


Maybe a little harsh for my hero, but I had to be honest. After his death His partner, Mari did an interview...

"He read all the criticism online and was a sensitive soul. Last year he played concerts and people posted mean comments such as, 'I wish he would stop playing.' He was tormented with worry that he wouldn't be good enough. He was planning to retire after Japan. He didn't want to let down his fans. He was a perfectionist and the thought he wouldn't play perfectly made him depressed, nervous and anxious."

It made me more sensitive to what I had written.



-------------
Thank you for supporting independently produced music


Posted By: lazland
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 12:48
^you need to review more. I enjoyed those.

-------------
Enhance your life. Get down to www.lazland.org

Now also broadcasting on www.progzilla.com Every Saturday, 4.00 p.m. UK time!


Posted By: JD
Date Posted: March 04 2021 at 15:37
Thanks, at one time I meant to do one a day but life gets in the way. I jump in and out of the forums throughout the day as I do my work and listen to music. Most of the writing that I am doing (and need to do) is work related, and I'm way behind.

Maybe I'll start by doing one a day, on Sat and Sun only.
Thanks for the encouragement.


-------------
Thank you for supporting independently produced music


Posted By: octopus-4
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 07:28
My first one was a very short an unimpressive review of Camel's The Snow Goose, on October 31st 2006.
I haven't written much in the last years, and currently my last review is from December 22nd 2020: Metronhomme - Tutto Il Tempo Del Mondo.

3 stars ...di una moneta che cade.

At the very first listen I had to wait for this song before something clicked in my mind, but I don't regret having waited enough, as with the following listens all the tracks deserved to be listened to.

What clicked is the similarity, at least what I think is a similarity, with the experimental side of Franco BATTIATO. So, having in mind something to be used as a key for the listening experience, I later appreciated the whole EP.

I (still) don't know the previous works of Metronhomme, so I can't say if this is different. For sure having composed, performed and recorded it by exchanging files via network during the lockdown must have had its impact on the overall process.

But let's speak about the music: Quarantine is a short instrumental mainly based on electric piano and keys. A bit jazzy with electronic percussion which are not sequenced but "played by hands" as the drummer Andrea GHEZZI proudly states on the bandcamp page. Short and light, not as dark as a quarantine can be. Come La Neve (As the snow), has lyrics and a lazy tempo. It gives me the idea of a naif painting or a b&w photograph. Very atmospheric.

As already said, "..di una moneta che cade" is my favorite track here. Experimental in the choice of sounds, with that bit of electronic which is not too invasive, so that the track can show its structure and continuity. But there is continuity throughout the whole EP. The sounds and the lazy tempo of the tracks, even when it gets more rhythm as in this one, are consistent with a dreaming soundscape. It gives the idea of a very unusual situation, like in some dreams, but far from being a nightmare.

"Supermarket" is very interesting. Experimental again, with the weird female voice speaking of trivial things like her favorite supermarket. The banality of daily life even during the pandemic.

Arkhe' is a greek word, meaning "beginning" or even "ancient". "Ark" derives from it. A piano based track, similar in some ways to the album opener. I'm not able to say what language is spoken below the music. Arabic or Russian?

Il rumore del Mare (The sound of the sea) is a proper song and the lyrics are about the strange summer of 2020. "L'estate dipinta su un muro" means "Summer painted on a wall". Curiously, "Son y Myr" (sound of sea) is one of the few things that I know in Welsh. Nothing to do with the album, which is closed by the darkest track: La citta' di K. (The city of K,) which I suppose has something to do with Franz Kafka. I wonder whether the SciFi sound in the first part of the track is a theremin.

Not "essential" in the progarchives sense, but surely not wasted time. About 25 minutes of dreamy soundscapes and the intention of digging the Metronhomme music further.

Note: 3 PA stars can have a different meaning if instead of "good but not essential" it's read as "not essential but good". And good is what I mean.




-------------
I stand with Roger Waters, I stand with Joan Baez, I stand with Victor Jara, I stand with Woody Guthrie. Music is revolution


Posted By: octopus-4
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 07:31

.. but Logan deleted my 2nd review (GTR) because it was very poor, so I had to rewrite it. LOL


-------------
I stand with Roger Waters, I stand with Joan Baez, I stand with Victor Jara, I stand with Woody Guthrie. Music is revolution


Posted By: essexboyinwales
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 08:09
I have never reviewed or rated any albums.  Should I leave the forum?!

I dunno, I'm not sure I'd do a very good job of reviewing.  Maybe I should just rate.  Do you have to fill in a form, or can you start start rating whenever you want?.....


Posted By: Shadowyzard
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 08:25
My first with this account, on this site, is also my latest. You can see it from my profile. I don't know how to put it here. Smile


Posted By: Psychedelic Paul
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 08:29
Originally posted by essexboyinwales essexboyinwales wrote:

I have never reviewed or rated any albums.  Should I leave the forum?!

I dunno, I'm not sure I'd do a very good job of reviewing.  Maybe I should just rate.  Do you have to fill in a form, or can you start start rating whenever you want?.....
Any member of ProgArchives can rate and review albums. All you need to do is log into the main site with your username and password then you can rate as many albums as you like. Smile


Posted By: Awesoreno
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 14:12
I've always had some in-depth opinions and insights into plenty of albums, but I just never get around to writing them. Maybe I should some time? I'll get over the laziness some day.


Posted By: zwordser
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 15:12
Haven't done many, as I don't think I'm a great writer. I Did four reviews years ago and quit, then finally did this one for Cats on the Roof in February this year because I like the music, and noticed that this band had ZERO ratings/reviews (which I think, or at least HOPE is unusual for any band having been on PA for years).

Review of Arabesques:

Compare this review to my recent review of To A New People. Most of what I wrote there applies, except that the two tracks here: Arabesques and Up the Pass, are quite a bit harder rocking! They have a similar sound to some more heavy Post/Math rock (such as Russian Circles). The longer track, Arabesques, has a hypnotic deep beat and melody, switching in the middle to a quicker bridge with an amazing bass-line. There are no vocals, but some cool vague talking at the end. Up The Pass has an up-tempo complex rock beat with some spacey-jazzy synth lines and a bit of funkiness.

Quite an enjoyable "album", (except, too short to be a real album). In spite of the length, I like it quite a bit more than To a New People (though mostly listen to them together, like they're a single album). 4.3 stars for sure. Recommended If you like heavier spacy, jazzy-rocking instrumentals.


My first review was this, for Shadowfax, (a band that had very few reviews/ratings at the time in 2013). Looks like I'm still the only non-collaborator to have reviewed it.

Review for Watercourse Way:

For my very first album review on Progarchives, I've decided on one of the better albums I've heard that seems to be less well-know and perhaps doesn't get quite the attention it deserves. In fact, I'm a little surprised, as this is just such a great album; one of the better jazz-rock/symphonic albums that I have heard to date. True, Shadowfax is classified as "crossover", and considering their later career, I suppose they are. But Watercourse Way is much heavier, and to my ears, sounds more passionate than at least some of their later albums (four of which I have heard as of writing this review). Shadowfax went much lighter, more like New Age music after this album. I wouldn't say the band's path was necessarily a mistake , as I don't know the details of their history and can't judge. However, after hearing Watercourse Way, I can't help but wonder if they could have become one of the more preeminent Prog acts had they chosen to continue with a similar sound, rather than moving into new agey territory.

In any case, Watercourse Way is worth a listen for anyone who really likes jazz/rock, symphonic, and/or eclectic prog. It just sounds so progressive, with all the elements: multiple instruments, (including ethnic ones like the sitar), shifting time signatures, a mix of harder and softer tunes, and complex arrangements, which are, IMO, very good ones, on par with many of the best Prog bands of the 70's. As it is, I suppose the album could be classified as a "hidden gem". A solid 4.2 stars.









-------------
Z


Posted By: Cosmiclawnmower
Date Posted: March 05 2021 at 15:15
Ive never attempted to review any lps (although i have thought about it).. Partly i just dont have much time and the time i do have my brain is usually pretty tired and incoherent.. also i'm just not convinced that yet another subjective view on an album will really be of much value. There are some bands that i have over the years absorbed lots of information about and in some cases done lots of research for personal reasons.. but i read lots of extremely well written, researched and expressed reviews here over the years which i have found highly insightful and very useful in developing my own interests and i am extremely grateful to those individuals for their time and passion in producing them. 

-------------



Posted By: Lewian
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 04:48
Doing this is a bit depressing because I still like my first review a lot and don't feel that I have become better at doing this, but anyway, here we are.

First one, Renaissance Camera Camera:

4 stars Not sure whether it's a wise move making my debut here with writing something positive about this record, but I think it's big fun actually and one of the most underrated albums. Much has been written about them trying to become commercial and even "new wave", but the truth is that if they tried this they failed miserably, at the same time pissing off much of their old fan base. It was probably the wrong album at the wrong time, but my take on it is very different.

I appreciate that they tried out something new and that they took a risk here. I even like the photo, which probably proves my bad taste. I find the album very fresh actually, and it's full of surprises. True, some of the material is pretty straightforward and can't really be called "prog", and one couldn't accuse them of following any consistent direction here, but I actually like the fact that every song is quite different from every other. There are some really excellent and at times extreme vocals here (Annie does other things than "beautiful & epic" here, which may have shocked some), good and dominant bass playing, some good melodies, some of rather mellow and some of rather determined character, some more Eastern influence. The rhythm section in several songs is harder and more "driving" than on other Renaissance albums. My favourite is Tyrant-tula, which is started off by a good guitar riff, has some quite "physical" parts, a quite exciting keyboard solo and some unexpected turns (leading into something of a dead end but that's part of the fun).

I don't mind the 80s keyboards, by the way, and quite a range of sounds and styles is used there, too (including some old school Renaissance piano). Actually, the whole "70s prog band goes 80s commercial" thing fascinates me to some extent; trying to make things a bit slimmer and straighter wasn't too wrong for some. In some cases there are interesting results like here, where the band keeps up their creativity (I think there's more creativity in this one than in a number of their predecessors actually) and it turns out that they put too many ideas in an album to be really commercial.

One can find things to criticise about this, not every idea works well (I don't like "Running Away From You" much but as all the others it's something unique on this record so it at least contributes to the overall number of styles). Considering the warning I just got from the system I should probably refrain from giving it all five stars but still I love this and it's a pretty pretty strong 4.

Most recent, just today:

Patricia Dallio, L'encre des voix secretes

4 stars Patricia Dallio is ex-keyboarder of Art Zoyd and went solo in the 2000s. She was originally a pianist but took a more electronic direction that also dominates her solo albums as far as I know them. In fact, her later work seems to be well in line with how Art Zoyd was developing at the time, so I wouldn't suspect that the split was because of big musical differences (I don't know actually). In fact she is active to this day; her most recent album at the time of writing this is a 2020 live album but the later stuff is not currently listed on PA.

L'encre des voix secretes is something of a sampling feast. The title, "The ink of the secret voices", hints at the fact that spoken word is used a lot, if often deconstructed, manipulated, newly put together in musical, often rhythmic ways, but so that the words can still be recognised and followed, neither as a lead nor as a background, rather as another equally important instrument in the ensemble. However, this is still clearly a keyboarder's album with some piano and a lot of electronic keyboards on top of the rich use of sampled sounds. The mood on the album is not too far away from much of what Art Zoyd have done; it is definitely on the darker side of things with a densely overgrown secret garden atmosphere.

One could put this album in the experimental avantgarde electronic category. I listen to a lot of such music, and tend to categorise it between the poles "meditative" and "busy". This work is pretty much half way between them. There is certainly quite a bit of movement and business here, however the sound spectrum is rather transparent with some slower and more contemplative parts, and we are not exposed to something of a chaotic noise attack. I have characterised one of Art Zoyd's 2000s albums as "ice mountains in the distance". The music of Patricia Dallio surely comes a bit closer to the listener, but it still has an intellectual and elusive feel to it.

Sequencing and rhythm are important throughout the album. Sound- and dynamic-wise it has quite a variety on offer, although the general style and approach are pretty homogeneous, and most tracks have a quite repetitive spine. What is different from Art Zoyd's later approach is that the tracks are generally shorter and compositions are more "local" with not much of an overarching thread (Art Zoyd has done short tracks as well, e.g., on Eyecatcher, but most of these are not meant to stand on their own, rather to be integrated in the overall structure). In fact this is the only thing I find to criticise about this fascinating album, namely that the 17 tracks (67 minutes overall) feel a bit randomly put together. Every track in itself is good stuff but I don't get much of a logic regarding how one follows the other, which makes the album less striking in its overall effect than Art Zoyd's best work. It's a grower though. I wasn't very impressed when I heard it the first time, but I discover more an more on it. Besides Art Zoyd fans who will surely appreciate this, I recommend this to people interested in experimental electronic music. I currently give it 3.8 stars but it's on a positive trajectory.



Posted By: Lewian
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 04:51
Originally posted by Cosmiclawnmower Cosmiclawnmower wrote:

Ive never attempted to review any lps (although i have thought about it).. Partly i just dont have much time and the time i do have my brain is usually pretty tired and incoherent.. also i'm just not convinced that yet another subjective view on an album will really be of much value. There are some bands that i have over the years absorbed lots of information about and in some cases done lots of research for personal reasons.. but i read lots of extremely well written, researched and expressed reviews here over the years which i have found highly insightful and very useful in developing my own interests and i am extremely grateful to those individuals for their time and passion in producing them. 

I try to prefer albums that haven't yet been reviewed or just once (or occasionally when I want to say something else than others have already said). This is probably helpful to others even if we may feel when writing them that our writing and knowledge is not quite on top of things.


Posted By: nick_h_nz
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 05:01
I have to admit the only reviews I have posted here are ones that I reviewed for TPA. I never originally intended to review here at all, but whenever any artist reached out to me after a review was published on TPA, and asked if I could repost it here, I did so. In the end, I decided it was simpler to just repost them here regardless. It does mean most of my reviews tend to be for albums that don’t otherwise have a lot of reviews. In most cases, if I posted my review here before TPA, it would be the first review for an album. But given there is usually a three to five week gap between my submitting a review for TPA and it getting published, it usually means someone else has made the first PA review. There have been a few times when I have add to add the album to PA in order to repost my review (as I had to, today, when I reposted my review of Aborym’s Hostile).

At some stage I might think about writing some reviews for older albums on PA, but if I do, it will almost certainly be for those that have few or no reviews. There’s little value in my putting in time and effort to review an album that’s already been reviewed a hundred times....



-------------
https://tinyurl.com/nickhnz-tpa" rel="nofollow - Reviewer for The Progressive Aspect


Posted By: Cosmiclawnmower
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 14:04
Originally posted by Lewian Lewian wrote:

Originally posted by Cosmiclawnmower Cosmiclawnmower wrote:

Ive never attempted to review any lps (although i have thought about it).. Partly i just dont have much time and the time i do have my brain is usually pretty tired and incoherent.. also i'm just not convinced that yet another subjective view on an album will really be of much value. There are some bands that i have over the years absorbed lots of information about and in some cases done lots of research for personal reasons.. but i read lots of extremely well written, researched and expressed reviews here over the years which i have found highly insightful and very useful in developing my own interests and i am extremely grateful to those individuals for their time and passion in producing them. 

I try to prefer albums that haven't yet been reviewed or just once (or occasionally when I want to say something else than others have already said). This is probably helpful to others even if we may feel when writing them that our writing and knowledge is not quite on top of things.
When i have seriously thought about taking that dive, thats the approach i have considered.. i think you are right, sometimes certain personal insights or passions about an album, particularly one maybe on a less trodden path, can give some extra insight.. its certainly what has stood out to me in the numerous reviews ive read here over the years SmileClap


-------------



Posted By: JD
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 14:24
Originally posted by nick_h_nz nick_h_nz wrote:

[EDIT]

At some stage I might think about writing some reviews for older albums on PA, but if I do, it will almost certainly be for those that have few or no reviews. There’s little value in my putting in time and effort to review an album that’s already been reviewed a hundred times....

I can't remember how many times I've read this. I can't say it doesn't hold some truth.
So not to derail this thread from the OP's focus, but in the manner of reviews, a couple of questions that maybe you can add to your posts.

1 - What's the likelihood of your searching and reading reviews here before exploring or purchasing a title?
2 - What's your view on the above referenced position of reviewing albums with, let's say what, 200 reviews or more. Love to see them or time to move on?



-------------
Thank you for supporting independently produced music


Posted By: SteveG
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 14:29
These are good questions. For seeing a review before purchasing an album I would guess 50% of the time. After 200? Depends on the album

-------------
This message was brought to you by a proud supporter of the Deep State.


Posted By: JD
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 14:46
^["Depends on the album"]
Can you elaborate? What's your criteria?


-------------
Thank you for supporting independently produced music


Posted By: micky
Date Posted: March 06 2021 at 14:56
Originally posted by nick_h_nz nick_h_nz wrote:

At some stage I might think about writing some reviews for older albums on PA, but if I do, it will almost certainly be for those that have few or no reviews. There’s little value in my putting in time and effort to review an album that’s already been reviewed a hundred times....


I was never a prolific reviewer myself..though I must say.. the proud owner of the most notorious and infamous review in the history of this site.. I did only did because I was forced to by the old admin team.. and once I came into Raff's orbit I got blinded by her verbal luminance and my reviews looked like cosmic debris in comparison I stopped bothering to review albums.

that said.. while I did review..  I only touched the big heavies.. the classic top 100 or so popular albums only when I thought I had something unique to say about the albums.  Both of those being Yes albums.. other than those..and my killer Yes remixes review.. didn't review a single album by the big 5.

my first...

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=3321" rel="nofollow - CONCERT 1971, BRUXELLES - THÉÂTRE 140

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=646" rel="nofollow - Magma

 

Zeuhl

2.75 | 29 ratings

From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

http://www.progarchives.com/Collaborators.asp?id=4823" rel="nofollow"> http://www.progarchives.com/Collaborators.asp?id=4823" rel="nofollow - micky
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
2 stars this is an easy album to review. If you are reading this you are probably familiar with the music and language of Magma. If not.. get acclainted with a copy of Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh. This album is an 'official' bootleg recorded in Brussels at Theater 140 the 12th of November 1971. The date is significant for a couple of reasons. First off this was the first public performance of Mekanik Kommandoh which of course became the basis for their landmark (and essential album of prog) Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh. Secondly as a huge fan of the fusionairy debut album Kobaia, I wanted to hear live versions of songs from that album. On both counts the album left me completely satisfied.

Being a offficial 'bootleg' I feel a word about the quality of the album should be said. It is a released bootleg so don't expect 100% perfect sound quality. This album is for probably for Magma fans only. That said the quality was never a hinderance to my enjoyment of the album. Now on to the album itself

The album contains three songs off of Kobaia. Stoah, Kobaia, and Aina. The whole of the 1001 degrees Centigrade album, and two works in the formative phases at that point. The aforementioned Mekanik Kommandoh, and Sowiloi which would turn up later on the outakes album Inedits. The one thing that really stood out between this album and the previous versions of songs I noticed, was the Rhodes Piano and it's central place in the live Magma sound. Many accoustic parts in Kobaia were played instead by the Rhodes. That took a bit of getting use to for me since part of my love of Kobaia was the great accoustic piano playing.

The highlights for me...

Stoah. Those opening vocals are impressive. Even more so in the live environment. The vocals are so massive on this album. Must have been an incredible live show.

Iss Lansei Doia. My least favorite song off of 1001 is transformed here into a favorite by a simple shift in instruments. The menacing intro riff instead of being played on the bass is instead played on the accoustic piano. Adds a whole new darker vibe to it.

Mekanik Kommandoh a showcase for Blasquiz's vocal improvisations. A fascinating listen. 18 minutes of total musical freedom.

Magma is not for everyone so I'm torn in trying to rate the album. Much like my ELO album earlier today, my personal score will be several stars higher than I actually rate it. For myself 4 stars. In general for the prog community. Magma/Zeuhl completionists only but that is no reflection on the incredible quality of this music.

micky

micky | 2/5 | 

and last...

5 stars Prog-Metal. Haha. I have so much fun holding it by the nose and kicking it in the ass around the forums. It does have a 'kick me' sign attached to it for many whose last bout of acne was when Genesis was showing their true talents and tearing up the pop music charts. It is a interesting point of discussion within prog circles. While prog fans are eager to embrace and call their own music which expands the boundaries of rock music and bring a sense of art and culture to rock music's traditional mundane subject matter, prog metal is one of the great, and rare, dividers of the otherwise tight prog rock community. One could devote an entire essay as to why prog-metal divides the community so and an album review is definitely not the place for that so what I will do is relate my experiences and thoughts with a traditional prog-metal album that hit home where none that I had listened to before had. As I have not reviewed an album in 5 or 6 years, and have been a vicious critic (though often tongue in cheek) of the genre, I thought this album an appropriate one to review.

It should be natural for listeners like me to love prog-metal. I enjoy prog, and love metal. Yet for some reason the mixture of the two just never really connected. I had long thought I had simply been missing a group or album that connected with me. I think a large part of it was continually having Dream Theater pushed upon me as the 'gateway' band and finding that group was for myself, and likely many others, exhibit A why prog-metal inspires such negative feelings. While the musicianship was stellar, the songwriting was not on par with the abilities of the musicians. The sum of the parts can often exceed the sum of the groups work. The vocalist was also a HUGE turn-off for me. Some years ago I reviewed their 'masterpiece' and, while I hated the album, I still rated it quite highly as it was regarded a masterpiece of the genre - and who am I to disagree. I did often long to hear a consensus masterpiece of the genre that I really enjoyed. Well? I finally found one? this album.

Why does this album connect to me whereas others have not? That begins with the incredible vocalist of Symphony X, Russell Allen. Allen's singing is powerful, clearly inspired by one of the greatest of all metal vocalists, the late great Ronnie James Dio. Vocals pleasing to the ears and so full of color, and nuance. In this band I found a vocalist who is a vital component of a group's sound, not a distraction to that sound, or a mere deliverer of lyrics. Musically this album is prog-metal, but what does that really mean? As it is a metal album, you want to hear great riffage, and it is the riffs themselves that often separate great metal from the not so great. The riffs are driving and brutal in their intensity and often drive me to fits of insane headbanging. It is music full of intensity, and life, one of the main things I and many others love so much about metal. If this was just a metal album, however, I wouldn't be reviewing it. As a prog fan, I want to hear great musicians playing their asses off and with some sort of nod to what made prog, prog: the merging of 'high art' and music. Prog for many has come to be a password for long compositions, and outstanding technical ability. That is especially true, in my opinion, in classic prog metal and shown not in an ensemble context but through the soloists. The album has plenty of great solos, mandatory I suppose for prog-metal albums, but what I love about this album is the relative lack of emphasis on the soloists, thus the album has less a feel of 'look at me' and there is more an emphasis on group playing and the songs themselves. Yes, there are solos galore but - unlike some albums I've heard - I thought the solos fit well within the music itself and were tastefully done rather than jarring departures from the original song itself.

Prog to me is so much more than about technical ability. Otherwise we'd be reviewing bluegrass and country albums. Prog is about, and art-rock was based upon, highly educated musicians merging classical music and classical literature and creating a thinking man's music. This is what appeals most to me about this album. The album has direct inspirations and quotations from classic literature and classical music. Songwriting is not an easy task, especially in prog, with its penchant for extended song lengths and albums based on themes. Many have tried, and most have failed to deliver unique concepts that can hold a listener's interest throughout the course of a full album. What I perhaps love most about this album is it is NOT some original kitschy concept, but a album whose musical centerpiece, the nearly 21 minute title track, is musically grounded in one of the great classical pieces immediately recognizable to music lovers. It is an album a music lover, especially a prog fan, can immediately gravitate to. One special bit of praise, and what in the end make this a masterpiece and worthy of recommendation to those like me unable to make progress into the world of classic prog-metal, is the overall length. Many modern albums simply drag on FAR too long and would be best served by trimming the least effective tracks and making stronger overall albums. At 65 minutes it is only slightly longer than traditional long play albums and does not approach the excess of many bands that use the CD format to expand albums out to nearly 80 minutes in length. It is tightly packed and it never overstays its welcome.

In summation this is, I believe, an album that those who are not fans of prog-metal but enjoy both root forms can like, even love. An easy album to grade, 5 stars in my book, and for the site I agree it deserves the classic prog-metal album status it has. It is a prog-metal album that non- prog-metal fans might really enjoy.

micky | 5/5 | 


-------------
The Pedro and Micky Experience - When one no longer requires psychotropics to trip


Posted By: Lewian
Date Posted: March 07 2021 at 10:46
Originally posted by JD JD wrote:



1 - What's the likelihood of your searching and reading reviews here before exploring or purchasing a title?
2 - What's your view on the above referenced position of reviewing albums with, let's say what, 200 reviews or more. Love to see them or time to move on?


1 Not sure but I do that regularly. Particularly when I explore a new band I have a look at reviews and ratings to decide where to start.
2 I think I don't mind when others do it. I may occasionally read one when it's new and appears on the homepage. I'd do it myself only when I think I have something to say that isn't said already. I was the first to give five stars to King Crimson - Beat, and the first to give two stars to David Bowie's Low, if I remember correctly.


Posted By: Progmind
Date Posted: March 07 2021 at 13:48
My First and only review because my english its very primitive, 

4 stars Review N° 1 Band: Differences Album: The Voyage Label: Si Music (1991) Simply 4

As a member of ProgArchives for many years I decided to write my first review, overcoming my panic because of my poor English language skills.

The first band I chose is Differences, because in my opinion they created one of the best albums of the 80s and which unfortunately was unknown, I guess because it was promoted by a small label (Frizzbee) and then was reissued by SI Music that broke the mid-90 `.

Differences have strong influence of bands like Camel (I recommend listening to the third track of this album, "True or False") also can recognize the influence of bands like Genesis of the era of "Wind and Wuthering" and Novalis.

The structure of the songs is not very complex, but has very good arrangements, typical of bands like Amenophis, Osiris, Rousseau, Coda and Arkus.

The jewel of this album is the penultimate song called "The Melody", a song full of nuances, very melodic guitars and many layers of keyboards.

Recommended as it represents a transition between the symphonic rock of the late 70s and early neoprog 80.

Solid 4 star (8/10)

Cheers

Rodrigo



Posted By: kenethlevine
Date Posted: March 07 2021 at 15:41
My first reviews were pretty primitive and I think I improved a lot the first few years, but maybe less so since.  

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=7655" rel="nofollow - NUMB EYES, THE SOUL REVELATION

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=1631" rel="nofollow - Harnakis

4 stars A beautiful guitar oriented symphonic progressive album from Spain, this one off is even more impressive for having been conceived during prog's darkest days, well before the revival of the 1990s. It compares favorably to earlier Spanish progressive efforts such as those of IBIO and ASTURCON, but is less ethnically based and seemingly more steeped in the British tradition, while still retaining an innocence missing in British prog since the early 1970s. The lead guitars are mostly gorgeous sounding but occasionally raucous, the vocals in English are more than competent and include both male and female representation, and there is plenty of space for instrumental development and revisiting of themes. This album is very unique and fresh, but yet nostalgic sounding. Highest recommendation for fans of symphonic prog.

HERE NOW

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=401" rel="nofollow - Poor Genetic Material


4 stars POOR GENETIC MATERIAL is like the carpenter with 12 toolboxes, each highly specialized, who cannot remember which toolbox does what, so has to open all of them. Luckily, this seems to delight the listener while apparently not aggravating the carpenter nearly as much as one might expect. Embarras du choix. Put another way, they have about 5 lead instruments give or take, because, after all, Phillip Griffiths' voice could swallow up about 5 average prog vocalists, if he didn't have flawlessly good taste that is. Lyrically erudite as well, he either insists on or is aggressively encouraged to bring in his dad Martin of BEGGARS OPERA fame at least once an album who manages to simultaneously raise the bar and make Phillip sound better! Oh dear I suppose that makes 6 instruments doesn't it? No matter. Open up the boxes!

Thematically, "Here Now" seems like the antonym and antidote for predecessor "Absence". The here and now is all we have, and, particularly in the centerpiece "The Garden" (sung by papa who name checks my favourite Beggars Opera track), the present has the capacity to be anything but a gift to the more sensitive among us. But who says we can't create our own, better reality, even if just for a vacation, or an evening for that matter? Musically, "Here Now" kicks off simply, with a string of shorter and progressively better tracks that converge while remaining well demarcated. As before, the group plies its trades comfortably at the intersection of simple and complex melodies, verse chorus structures and variegated suites, spacey ambience and funk, chill and edgy, solos and ensemble. My personal favourite is the touching "Note from my Younger Self", the complete package encapsulating all of the above.

In typical PGM fashion, all will be revealed in time, in my case almost 6 months, not that I think I have it, or anything figured out for that matter. But I can tell you that the arrangements, in particularly how Pia Darmstaedter's flute comingles with each other lead as called for, continue to mature, which might not be a requirement for this fan, but, inasmuch as it makes the band more likely to stick around for another decade or so, I'm all for it. Oh yeah sorry, I am just happy they are here now.



Posted By: A Crimson Mellotron
Date Posted: March 21 2021 at 14:18
My first review is on 'Kaleidoscope' by Transatlantic; the creation of this profile coincided with me listening once again to this great album and having a great time, so I wrote about it, from September 10, 2020:

4 stars 'Kaleidoscope' is the fourth studio release by the 'supergroup' Transatlantic. This is an album that comes after three stellar ones, so the expectations were, of course, quite high. Here, the band does what one would expect them to do ' a massive album bookmarked by two monstrous epics with a few shorter songs in between. We also get five vocalists throughout the whole thing (!), as Morse, Stolt, Portnoy, Trewavas, and the guest Daniel Gildenlow all have vocal duties.

Opening track 'Into the Blue' might be my most favorite thing from this band, it is absolutely majestic and memorable, it has some genius vocal harmonies by Neal Morse and the performance of all the other members is top notch. 'Shine' is a nice ballad-type band effort that was released as a single, if I am not wrong, with everyone in the band taking the spotlight on different parts of the song. 'Black as the Sky' is a punchy and proggy track with great vocal harmonies and an in-your-face chorus, much in the spirit of some of their 70s favorites like Tull or Focus. 'Beyond the Sun' is a little Neal solo piece leading up to the 32-minute title track ' which I feel is not as strong as 'Into the Blue' but quite spectacular as well. The instrumental sections on this one are the least to say impressive, and the chemistry between the players is enviable!

Excellent music, another really good release from Transatlantic, and a great addition to symphonic prog lovers' (and not only) collection.


My latest review concerns Beardfish's 'The Void' from 2012, and was posted just some minutes ago!

4 stars Beardfish's heaviest fantasies come to life on their mighty seventh album, 'The Void' - an exploration of existential dread and fear, cloaked in the romantic drapery of hopeless romanticism and wishful expectation.

The Swedes are certainly one of the trailblazers of 21st century progressive rock, handily but confusingly labeled symphonic/retro prog, they never stopped reinventing themselves, thus supplying the mythical creature that Beardfish has managed to become, with loads of dedicated fans, despite the lack of overly commercial success. This album is no exception to the typical Beardfish approach to music - ever-changing and gripping, full of memorable melodies and punchy instrumental passages, with intelligent and adventurous lyrics.

An album that sometimes gets neglected or overlooked due to the fact that their well-known keyboard-centered sound is put at the back seat, in favor of a much heavier, distorted and headbanging sonic body, it should not be left unmentioned that is an excellent symphonic prog album at its very core, it is just skillfully masked in the almighty riffs and gnarly bass sections.

A sore spoken word introduction by The Tangent's Andy Tillison serves as the entrance to 'The Void', a place that Rikard Sjöblom successfully paints as dark and uninviting, allowing the listener to embark on an emotive journey through his mind. From then on, the acrobatic main riff of 'Voluntary Slavery' crushes every expectation that one could have had for this album. The band is aggressive but certainly well-behaved, while Rikard throws in some guttural shrieks just to keep the listener alert. 'Turn to Gravel' is another heavy piece that seems to sounds nothing like your usual Beardfish, the lyrics are enduring and reflective, the tone is menacing and unsettling. 'They Whisper' is the piece that finally gives off the impression that the ambitious new direction of this band will come to a very satisfactory result, given the shockingly blissful mixture of heavy guitar riffs and memorable, resonating melodies. 'This Matter of Mine' might be a bit more laid back than the cannonade of heavy songs coming before it, yet it still finds Rikard screaming at the top of his lungs once!

'Seventeen Again' is a beautiful instrumental that begins with a very stripped-down piano progression, unfolding into a very Wakeman or Emerson-esque pastiche, craftily performed by the band's leader. Spiraling through the excellent love song 'Ludvig & Sverker' and the jazzier 'He Already Lives in You', the band reach the apex of the album with the nearly 16-minute epic 'Note', just to finish off on a high (or rather low) note on the cerebral 'Where the Lights Are Low'.

All in all, 'The Void' is a fantastic exercise in beautifully-ornamented and rich songwriting, penetrated by the bombastic nature of the riffs; something that hardly let the listener disregard this album as anything less than excellent. This album proves that no matter how many times the mighty Beardfish reinvents itself, it always remains one of modern progressive rock's finest exponents.




Posted By: BaldJean
Date Posted: March 22 2021 at 10:47
my first review was for this one:



here is what I wrote:

This album may not have the best of sounds, but it shows the band at the peak of their energy, and there never has been a more brutal bass guitar than that of Nic Potter on this album. Hammill is in excellent form and screams away at the top of his lungs. The opener "Ship of Fools" is a real killer. The adding of a cello works wonderfully for tracks like "Still Life" and "Pioneers Over c" (watch out for the part where violin and cello go manic at high tempo while the bass guitar suddenly starts playing the slow rhythm of the beginning
again). The only thing I hate is that the CD version misses 2 tracks (I can't get hold of the Japanese pressing), so I am really looking forward to the remastering Virgin is going to do this year and hope they won't leave out any tracks this time.

One of my absolutely favorite live albums ever. Raw Power!

the album was released as a double CD meanwhile containing all 10 tracks, so no more complaints.

my latest review was for this one:



here is what I wrote:

I am usually not the biggest fan of prog folk, but this album is different. it has a refreshing naiveté to it and is simply beautiful. and it is definite proof that the general belief that "In the Court of the Crimson King" was the first prog album is nothing but a myth.

it is not my habit to go into discussing the music in detail in my reviews, and I certainly won't start here. just listen and enjoy. but this album is one of my absolute favorites and deserves 5 stars, which I gladly give so more people will listen to this wonderful little gem

I wrote 27 reviews; 10 of them were 5 star reviews. besides the two albums mentioned they were for these albums:


















all of these 10 albums are highly recommended by me


-------------


A shot of me as High Priestess of Gaia during our fall festival. Ceterum censeo principiis obsta



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2014 Web Wiz Ltd. - http://www.webwiz.co.uk