Cailyn LLoyd: Sub-genre?...Discuss!

As I said to the very understanding admin to whom I tendered my resignation, this kind of utterly needless arguing, shouting, and pedantry really was completely removing all enjoyment I had of the music and the site as a whole.

However (!) just for the record, it was not, from what I can see, Ian who resurrected this particular music lecture, it was a relatively new forum member. I wholeheartedly agree with Ian. Why do certain individuals always have to have the last word? Why do we need to carry on like this? Wouldn't a simple PM to the person posting his "dissent" been far better?

I was going to write a lot more. However, Can't Be Arsed comes to mind

Yep, and perfectly reasonable reasons for your rejection were posted, in a very clear and polite fashion. In fact, I did later in the thread suggest that the poster went for prog related, given the feelings of teams on this artist. I never had a problem with the rejections, as such, although there is, of course, a valid argument that covers of prog songs can be a cogent reason for inclusion, given the plethora of prog covers albums we are seeing being released and included on the site.

Your post was not the problem, it is this constant bickering and, in my eyes, exceptionally unreasonable posts which have a large degree of SHOUTING in bold type.

Cue another complaint against me, I suppose, in a place I can't even view. Actually, I barely care anymore. It is my clear and unambiguous opinion that this behaviour is utterly unacceptable, and is a very great downside of an otherwise great site.

I can see the post was written almost three months ago, so would be puerile to protest now.

Iván

Snow Dog wrote: Ivan_Melgar_M wrote: Snow Dog wrote: As I said. I am not trying to upset Ivan or his precious Symph team. I had heard Cailyn's new album and wanted to find out some info here. I was dismayed to find she wasn't on PA so I started this thread. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=90287 Not knowing she had already been suggested. A bad error but evidence that rthis has nothing to do with trying to nettle Ivan. I have clearly stated I didn't care which genre she went to.   I can see the post was written almost three months ago, so would be puerile to protest now. Iván I don't understand your point. My thread was more than a month after this one.

1.- My post you protested about is this one

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote:   SD...Prog of some kind = Symphonic? Two members of the Xover team have rejected her (not moved), please don't like to see the Symphonic team always as the bad guys rejecting an artist that should be here. She has some Prog elements, but IMO and the opinion of the team (and apparently 2 Xover members), very few. Iván

I believe you never saw the date

2.- You wrote today 

Snow Dog wrote: As I said. I am not trying to upset Ivan or his precious Symph team. I had heard Cailyn's new album and wanted to find out some info here. I was dismayed to find she wasn't on PA so I started this thread. http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=90287 Not knowing she had already been suggested. A bad error but evidence that rthis has nothing to do with trying to nettle Ivan. I have clearly stated I didn't care which genre she went to.

I hope you follow me

3.- On this post

Ivan wrote: I can see the post was written almost three months ago, so would be puerile to protest now.

4.- FOR GOD'S SAKE, I DIDN'T EVEN READ IT, I NEVER VISITED THAT THREAD, I WOULD NEVER PROTEST ABOUT IT NOW THAT ALMOST THREE MONTHS HAVE PASSED.....AS A FACT, I HAVEN'T TALKED ABOUT YOU IN THIS YEAR 2013

Ivan

That's why all this nonsense started, and  a third person that doesn't have any business here (Lazland) came to make it worst.

Ditto.

qft

It's relevant Snow Dog

This was a discussion that started and ended three months ago, we talked about it and solved the problem in October

And BTW: I never saw your post on the other thread, so never was taliking about it

Iván