ProgArchives Mafia: The Merriweather Murder

S~V~S wrote: and MPs statement that he will deal with non posters leads me to think he would prefer we not vote for them~

No, actually, vote for whomever you want. I encourage you guys to punish people who aren't playing by voting them, if you so wish. You can do anything with your votes, technically, I just want you to feel like you're doing the most wise option with them.

I'm trying to help out with non-posting as much as possible, but that doesn't mean anything about whether you should vote for non-posters or not. It's all up to you guys.

horsewithteeth11 wrote: MovingPictures07 wrote: S~V~S wrote: and MPs statement that he will deal with non posters leads me to think he would prefer we not vote for them~ No, actually, vote for whomever you want. I encourage you guys to punish people who aren't playing by voting them, if you so wish. You can do anything with your votes, technically, I just want you to feel like you're doing the most wise option with them. I'm trying to help out with non-posting as much as possible, but that doesn't mean anything about whether you should vote for non-posters or not. It's all up to you guys. I'm starting to think about doing that. From what I can tell, TNP, J-Man, and Sleepwalker are the ones who seem quite guilty of this. Is there anyone else who has hardly posted at all (or better yet, hasn't posted anything)?

Looking at my vote spreadsheet... progkidjoel has not voted in a single lynch at all. ThreeLittleBirds has only voted on Day 1. Both of them haven't posted a ton either.

Well, if the host does not take care of low posters, perhaps the killers will 

I prefer to vote for cause if possible, and JJLehtos reaction to the srs bsns remark being brought up pings me big time~ a strong potential for BTSC there. So~

*Votes JJLehto*

Off to work, later happy Prog Rock Mafia Players

For the new players who are still finding it difficult to find things to say in the thread:

Just express your opinion! There have been 3 nights AND 3 lynches now, people's posts to go off of, and plenty of actual evidence to form theories about. You can look at trends in people's voting to see any sort of pattern with confirmed evidence you have from who was lynched, you can look at the night post to see which Mafia teams are targeting the kill victims and which civvies are targeting other players.

It doesn't matter if you don't have much to say, just post anything you think of! The whole point of the Mafia day period is to discuss and deduce.

If you are a civvie, not posting or not contributing really hurts your team. If you are a baddie/indie, not posting or not contributing really makes you seem suspicious. You can't win either way; it's better to try to contribute to the discussion than not say anything at all.

J-Man wrote: POST!!!!!

This isn't going to cut it. This will not count as an on-topic post.

Thanks! 

MovingPictures07 wrote: horsewithteeth11 wrote: Who are all the people who haven't voted then? I figure that's a better place to start. You mean, ever? Let me look. J-Man did not vote on Day 1 or Day 3. Lizzy did not vote on Day 2. progkidjoel did not vote on Day 1, Day 2, or Day 3 TheSleepwalker did not vote on Day 2 (but he wasn't on PA at all) The Truth did not vote on Day 0, Day 1, or Day 3. ThreeLittleBirds did not vote on Day 0, Day 2, or Day 3. TNPLH did not vote on Day 0.

Alright. Considering 3 people haven't voted 3 times, I may consider voting for one of them if I can't find a good enough reason to vote for someone else.

SaltyJon wrote: I vote for ThreeLittleBirds.  She has aroused my suspicion, both by silence and for other reasons I'll leave you to figure out.

Because that doesn't sound suspicious at all.

I want to be sockface...!!! I could haunt anyone in PA...

Damn I can't edit!
So I haven't been on PA during Day 2 of voting.

Good point Lizzy. I was starting to notice that as well.

Well, I work 3-11 today, so when I get home tonight I'll barely have enough time to cast a vote. Which means I might have to do it before I leave for work.