Author |
Topic Search Topic Options
|
Evandro Martini
Forum Senior Member
Joined: February 08 2006
Status: Offline
Points: 183
|
Posted: December 02 2007 at 07:24 |
In The Court Of The Crimson King |
1969
Studio Album
|
|
Review by
Evandro Martini
Posted 6:59:24 PM EST, 6/23/2007
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77fd7/77fd7186fb261a6a3ecef59377957f73a702a3bc" alt="5%20stars"
The first wholly progressive album from history (in my opinion) Defining prog-rock is a pretty hard task, and saying which album was the first to
contain all of its elements will depend on your point of view and your taste. But to
me this album, besides being a beautiful masterpiece, is the first album that can be
called completely progressive. I’ll explain it here. By 1969, various experimentations with rock music had been made. The Beatles had
recorded with orchestras and string ensembles, Moody Blues had recorded a conceptual
album with an orchestra (that would be the first, I suppose, with the singer/flutist
role, so common in prog), Jimmy Hendrix had recorded insane albums, Procol Harum and
then The Nice had mixed classical and rock in a clever way, etc. All these influences
were important to progressive rock, but they are not, to me, completely progressive.
Now, let’s go to Crimson King...
21st Century Schizoid Man opens the album violently, with saxophone being used in a
completely original way, dialoguing with the guitar. Bass is behind, but very
cleverly constructed, always changing, playing a melody, instead of just
accompanying. What’s the name of that? Progressive rock. The long instrumental
section is amazing, ending with more vocals from Lake. Greg Lake is my favourite
singer in all times, so I am really pleased with his voice all through the album. I Talk to the Wind follows, showing that the album’s style is regular in the world of
ideas, rather than in musical ideas. This is the basis of prog-rock for me, let me
explain it. While heavy metal is easily discernible by its sound, with heavy guitar,
shouted vocals, etc, prog-rock is not constant in this way. It changes from calm to
violent, from simple to complex, and what defines it is actually a group of ideas
that are common to these different-sounding songs. In this song we hear Ian
MacDonald’s beautiful flute work, in a pastoral style, far from what someone would
expect from a rock band. Ian MacDonald says: “The idea was to be expansive, more
inclusive of other styles of music than just the old “two guitars, bass and drums”
format, so we included classical and jazz elements.” Greg Lake agrees: “My roots are
very much European music rather than the blues, which is the basis of most
rock’n’roll. I was always into classical and folk music, and that’s where I look for
my inspiration”* Pete’s lyrics are slightly nonsense but still gorgeous and well
written. Epitaph has even better lyrics, dreamy but very direct. MacDonald says about it: “On
Court Of The Crimson King, Peter deliberately wrote in this stylised, colourful
language but the lyrics were actually sharp commentaries on the states of things at
the time. It was just phrased in that way, but most prog writers then tried to
emulate that style”* Here we have many highlights: Greg Lake’s most expressive voice,
going from extremely calm to extremely melancholic /sad, the gorgeous work on the
Mellotron, being this one of the first songs to have it on such a crucial role,
influentiating many bands. The way the melodies from voice and mellotron dialogue is
fantastic.I must notice that this song manages to be completely effective and
wonderful with a very simple (but good) harmony. At this time, prog wasn't a
competition of who can make the most complex song... Moonchild starts as a calm song, similar to I Talk to the Wind, and stays like that
for 2 minutes. These two minutes are great, with good singing, discrete mellotron and
dreamy lyrics perfectly constructed. Then, the song ends, and starts a long
improvisation of guitar, vibes and, later, drums. This is very different from
anything you’ll expect: atonality is constantly present. This would mark the
progressive tendency for experimentation. It is not for anytime, but with headphones,
at night, it’s a really interesting experience. The album ends perfectly with its title song. Again we have perfect lyrics, evoking a
medieval atmosphere in well-structured verses. After each sung part, there’s an
instrumental section, always great, with a hell of a work by Ian MacDonald (his
personality was very important here, and his departure will deeply affect the band’s
sound).
A friend of mine has defined well the mellotron/voices gorgeous harmony (aaah)
repeated all-through the song as a perfect soundtrack for the gates of heaven (if
there was one...)
When you think the song has finished, enters a woodwind section that I love,
reworking the theme with harmonies between flutes and clarinets.
All in all, this album bring with it a whole new style of music, that would reach its
peak commercially and arguably artistically in the 70s, but would keep alive until
today. Says Ian: “The opportunity was there, groups were given more freedom in the
studio, we were able to produce our own album. The Beatles had a lot to do with what
was going on, this idea of using the studio as an instrument and being free to make
the music that they wanted. That impacted on the rest of the business for a while.
After a few years record companies started demanding more control over producers and
budgets again, but there was a time there when bands had a lot more freedom to
express themselves in the studio. We were never given a lot of time though, the first
album was done very, very quickly—eight days from beginning to end I believe,
including the mixing.”
Ok, Ian. And you expressed yourselves very, very well. Thank you for that eternal
masterpiece. *Interviews quoted from Record Collector magazine from December 2005
|
|
"You’ll never make any money playing music that people can’t sing.” Keith Emerson's father
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
sleeper
Prog Reviewer
Joined: October 09 2005
Location: Entropia
Status: Offline
Points: 16449
|
Posted: December 02 2007 at 08:05 |
Just to balance things out a bit, my worst is my review of Dream Theaters Falling Into Infinity, which really does need to be re-written. http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=96389
|
Spending more than I should on Prog since 2005
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Angelo
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin
Joined: May 07 2006
Location: Italy
Status: Offline
Points: 13244
|
Posted: December 02 2007 at 09:07 |
The Promethean Syndrome |
2007
Studio Album
|
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music
|
Review by
Angelo
(Angelo)
Posted 11:03:49 AM EST, 11/11/2007
Every once in a while, a nice surprise comes along.Through the dark, hidden paths of ProgArchives, I was provided with a promotional copy of this album. Azureth - a band not
known to me before - turned out to be one of these surprises that you run into every once in a while. The band claims to be
influenced by bands like Yes, Kansas and Genesis, but have managed to make it into something of themselves. I have to admit
that on occassion Vince Font's voice reminds me of Marillion's Steve Hogarth - another influence that's not mentioned? The
sound is definitely 70's like, but at the same time quite modern - not surprising given the instruments used, like a 1975
Fender Custom Telecaster, in combination 21st century compositions and modern recording and production techniques. The instrumental title track The Promethean Syndrome is the introduction to, as the band calls it, 'a conceptual
Prog-Rock Opera about a man who tries to fights against an egalitarian society where intellect is discouraged in favour of
uniformity'. A dark keyboard melody guides us into his world, shortly accompanied by the rest of the band for a close to 4
minute prog fan catching introduction.
After this, the piano opening of Being Alive changes the atmosphere and creates the path for the first vocals of Vince
Font on this album. And what a vocalist he is. The first time the album was in my CD player, I got distracted by something
else, until he started singing. My attention was caught and I really wondered whether I was listening to a young Peter
Gabriel, or to Steve Hogarth in good shape. The singer on Azureth's debut album Yesterday's Future Tomorrow's Past,
Kenneth Aspeslåen, was far from bad, but Vince Font is more than just a replacement.
Breakaway is another instrumental, with a quick fingered guitar and keyboards taking turns - but without showing off.
There's a synth organ in here that I wouldn't mind replacing for a Hammond... The organ returns in Chains that Bind, a song
that in a way reminds me of Aragon's Solstice (on their 1988 debut Don't Bring the Rain). Beyond the
Boundaries is a great, atmospheric track of just over 10 minutes - for which old Genesis, Kansas, Camel or early
Marillion would not have been ashamed - recommended to those who are investigating Azureth for the first time. Here,
Azureth's own sound signature shows through. It's not just keyboards and technical guitar work, sometimes a guitar needs to
be played as a rhythm instrument to make this really rock - and it does here. After this long track, we're back to an
instrumental journey - this time joining in on the four minute Flight of Prometheus. A great piece of rock, with loads
of guitar, bass and keyboard solos and improvisations. Recommended to be listen on head phones at night - in bed and with the
lights out. This applies also to the following Shadow of a Man II - which has a laid back acoustic intro, followed by
great organ work. There's a bit of drums and bass guitar behind the organ that is just sufficient to complete the sound and
not disturb it.
Via Into the Nowhere, another piece that shows how Azureth can create an emotional atmosphere, we end up in the
Garden of Ignosense. A varying track, with a multi-vocal piece as well, and a nice prologue to closing epic A New
World, which lasts almost 16 minutes. Contains some pulsing keyboard and great bass work in the rockier pieces, again as
a background for great vocals. The Promethean Syndrome has a very clear and crisp production - which is not too common among private releases. All
instruments can be heard clearly, a fitting reward for the musicians that play them. The only possible improvement in that
area according to my ears would be put the drums a bit more forward in the mix. Details on the concept, it's sources in
literature, as well as the lyrics can be downloaded from the web site, after entering a code that comes with the CD.
This band deserves to be up the charts along with other hidden - yet different - treasures like Bacamarte and Circa. Highly
recommended to anyone looking for, as Erik Neuteboom calls them, 'lesser-known prog bands' - and to fans of classic and
symphonic prog in general. Now what was the definition of a cult band again?
|
Edited by Angelo - December 02 2007 at 11:08
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
ShW1
Forum Senior Member
Joined: September 10 2005
Location: Sambation
Status: Offline
Points: 284
|
Posted: December 02 2007 at 09:56 |
Atavachron wrote:
^ even the ones that knocked Tull, ELP, Genesis and Zep?
|
especially those ! data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/959ca/959ca2d6d88148d24699142aaed89a741d71a1b9" alt="LOL"
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
el böthy
Prog Reviewer
Joined: April 27 2005
Location: Argentina
Status: Offline
Points: 6336
|
Posted: December 02 2007 at 12:33 |
I think this might be, maybe not the ebst, but one of them
MESHUGGAH
I |
2004
Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo
|
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music
Review by
el böthy
(matias boettner)
[Prog Reviewer ]
Posted 2:00:53 PM EST, 3/6/2007
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77fd7/77fd7186fb261a6a3ecef59377957f73a702a3bc" alt="5%20stars"
Ok...where to start? mmm...let’s start with the fact that Meshuggah used to be the
one band I thought I would never get into and, to be honest, it’s quite logical why.
I mean... heaviness just for the sake of heaviness, no melodies, the singing (or
should I say screaming?) the cold, soulless feelings to it, really, how can somebody
even like this band? Well... look at me now... This is the first album (or EP to be more specific) from this guys I have, I thought
it would be a good place to start. Why?... I don’t know, I guess cause I’m like the
biggest epic fan ever and thought I should give this 21 minutes song a try, cause if
I didn’t like this, then I could easily move on to something else, knowing I had
listened to the "best" Meshuggah song. Also, and this is kind of strange, I read the
lyrics before I even heard the song, just cause I was so intrigued of it´s name… “I”.
“One has to have a lot of balls, or be reeeeally pretentious to name an epic this
way” I thought, “I´ll check out the lyrics, cause for sure they can´t be that good”.
Guess what, the lyrics are genius! Chaotic but in an almost poetry-like way…
awesome!!! And then I heard not one, not two, but a lot of people praising that this
was THE BEST METAL SONG EVER… well now I have to listen to it. So, I got “I”, almost
sure I was making a huge mistake. Only once did I have this feeling before: when I
bought “In the court of the Crimson King”, and it turned out to be my favorite album
ever. Man do I like to be wrong sometimes!!! This song, this monster, is like the most brutal experience ever. I can’t say this
was love at first sight. In fact, I got a headache the first time I listened to it,
but I immediately knew there was something to it, something special. So I kept
listening to it, and the more I listened to it, the more I liked it. By the fourth
time I had no doubts, this is a work of genius! There is no weak spot, no filler what
so ever, just 21 minutes of pure brilliance. And there are some parts here and there
that are just too good, like the whole 10th minute for example, with Kidman chanting
“Shifting from worlds from chaos, to chaos, to chaos” and then the best part of the
whole song… Meshuggah plays in 4/4!!! The result? One of metals best riffs ever,
certainly one of it’s heaviest. By far, the best part of the song, yet, after this,
it doesn’t drag or get dull, it continues truly great, until the big finale where
Kidman delivers that final shout: “I” and the creepy outro begins… I can now agree, this is one of metal best songs. I think it’s important to remark
the importance of the lyrics, which I noticed nobody really does. They match the
music perfectly, and although shouting might not be the best singing technique, it
fits the music and concept of the lyrics like a glow. 5/5; a masterpiece. Meshuggah
truly are “crazy”.
|
"You want me to play what, Robert?"
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
akiko
Forum Senior Member
Joined: June 18 2005
Location: The Cinema Show
Status: Offline
Points: 169
|
Posted: December 03 2007 at 20:51 |
Atavachron wrote:
^ even the ones that knocked Tull, ELP, Genesis and Zep?
|
Those reviews fall under Proto-crap...
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Chris H
Prog Reviewer
Joined: October 08 2006
Location: Charlotte, NC
Status: Offline
Points: 8191
|
Posted: December 03 2007 at 21:01 |
The Black Noodle Project - And Life Goes On...
Review by Zappa88 (Chris Henne) [Prog Reviewer ] Posted 2:16:43 PM EST, 4/16/2007
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/891aa/891aab45d7527ef46ed3c54643f395d38d4499d3" alt="5%20stars" I think this was the album that got me started with looking into modern progressive rock bands. I'm not positive about that fact, but when I look back on this album now I wouldn't doubt it one bit. Just a little bit of history on how I ended up discovering a French band with no previous albums to start my modern progressive rock journey, The Black Noodle Project was formed in the French capital and media-hub of Paris, where any album can explode onto the market quickly. The rest is history, and here I sit writing about it. One rumor that I would like to end right now is the rumor that this band is a Pink Floyd wanna-be. Sure their major influence is Pink Floyd, but the above statement is completely not true, my friends. I suppose they could be the same in the sense the Roger Waters of Pink Floyd and Jeremie Grima both write their songs with a raw passion that can only be surfaced through musical expression, but the music can obviously tell the difference between the two bands. Black Noodle Project plays every note with an unbridled emotion and sings every word with a sense of passion that Pink Floyd sometimes managed to grow cold on over the years. Now onto the music, shall we? The concept of the album, which I just learned after listens, is how to let go of a broken relationship. Even though their are a few heavier passages, the album is mainly layered with spacey textures to give the feeling of someone's deepest reaches of depression. I suppose the soaring lead guitar and mellow piano textures are responsible, although the saxophone on "Do It Alone" is an amazing touch. The first thing that broke the Pink Floyd wanna-be connection in my mind was the heavy percussions mixed with subtle keyboards, while Pink Floyd tends to go vice-versa. "Time Has Passed" opens the album with some wind blowing and clocks chiming, and then a tribal drum beat and subtle acoustic guitar set the tone for would will be the style of music throughout the whole album. Once the song starts to come to life, that soaring lead guitar that I was talking about rips into the atmosphere and drenches the remaining sounds with some beautiful riffs. The vocals are slightly accented,, and that just adds to the romanticism that Grima was trying to achieve on this album. "Do It Alone" starts off with the sounds of rain pouring and thunder in the distance, but the effects give way to some a cappella vocals before the piano tones flood the speakers. Like I said before, the saxophone is an amazing touch, and this is the only song on the album where it can be heard. Definitely something to check out, meaning the saxophone solo with tribal drum beats. The next track is their heaviest song by far. "Where Everything Is Dark" starts out very slowly, and builds up with some very suspenseful atmospheres created by the echoing vocals and subtle riffs, but the explodes into a machine of guitar fueled aggression, however the piano manages to keep the song in touch with the melancholy mood of the album. Once again, the vocals are a winner for me. The accented Francophone English compliments the mood of the music so well. This where the heavy percussion comes into play on the album as well, it provides the backbone for some almost techno-sounding lead guitar solos. Their next song, "Face The Truth", takes all of the edge right out of the previous song and replaces it with subtle beauty. A reviewer on another website had compared the beginning to Eric Carmen's "All By Myself", and I do not disagree with her, although unlike "All By Myself", "Face The Truth" never hits a musical peak where all of the instruments click together. Not that that is a bad thing, however. This truly is a perfect ballad. "Drops In The Ocean" is another mellow, ballad-esque song, with a few guitar solos here and there, one soft and one aggressive. This song can almost be compared to a 20-minute epic in the sense that instruments each enter the song individually after a certain period of time. For example, the song begins with some really spacey keyboards that create the atmosphere, and the vocals come in alongside the strumming guitar. The tension starts to mount, and then the sound explodes and the bass and drums get heavier and heavier. The instrumental "Interlude" starts off with the sound of a baby crying and then some very classy piano playing takes over, while the guitar stays in the background for a while. The piano starts to overtake the guitar with around a minute left, and creates a magnificent solo that blends the guitar's raw power with the piano's cultured and cured tones. The ending of "Interlude" leads into "Where Are U?", which opens up with some more strumming guitar and vocals, but the song is different because of the added use of the cello in the chorus. The song's title may suggest that it is a very depressing, yet musically amazing song. With the accented voice pounding out lyrics such as "6 feet underground, where my heart was cold", this just may be the most depressing song that you will ever hear. "Somewhere Between Here And There" is one of the only songs on the album that really creates a rich sound, and by that I mean all of the instruments working in harmony. Usually the instruments follow one another into a chorus, but this time they play in synchronized time which gives the song a very full sound, rather than the layered sound from the other tracks. Some excellent distorted keys open up this track, and the drum beats are at their most powerful. "Lost (I Miss You)" is a very weird track in the sense that they seem very happy and upbeat while singing, but the lyrics are incredibly tragic and gloomy. The song opens with the sounds of a beating heart, and then the track is dominated by some incredible work on the cello. "Disappeared" is a song that is literally built on percussion. For the first time on the album, the drums create the atmosphere and the guitar follows it. Some more sad vocals and spacey background keyboards lead into a blazing guitar ending. The final song, "She Prefers her Dreams", almost hits the 10 minute mark, and is the longest song on the album. During the song, the band has systematic explosions of sound that is very out of character for the group, but is a welcome change. The ending of this song really starts with around 3:30 left in the song, and just seems to keep building up and flowing on and on, and when it does eventually end all you want to do is play the CD over again from the top. It's very hard to sum up this album, because most of everything has been touched upon already. I highly recommend this album to fans of Pink Floyd, Landberk and Shadowland. This band may be an acquired taste, but for those of you wanting some excellently engineered space rock, this is the band for you! 5 stars, no hesitation.
I'm a bigger fan of my reviews for "Absolutely Free" or "Weasels Ripped My Flesh", but I'm told this was my best so enjoy. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ff4e5/ff4e54c24bfa051e80b6f29ce635fca0cf361f26" alt="Smile"
|
Beauty will save the world.
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
rileydog22
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 24 2005
Location: New Jersey
Status: Offline
Points: 8844
|
Posted: December 03 2007 at 21:02 |
Phew, I was worried that Zappa88 was gonna post that Tago Mago review.
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Dim
Prog Reviewer
Joined: April 17 2007
Location: Austin TX
Status: Offline
Points: 6890
|
Posted: December 03 2007 at 21:22 |
Bob, I know your out there!
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
rileydog22
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 24 2005
Location: New Jersey
Status: Offline
Points: 8844
|
Posted: December 03 2007 at 21:25 |
Well, none of my reviews are very good, but I guess this one's the best:
NEBELNEST
NoVa eXPReSS |
2002
Studio Album
|
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music
Review by
rileydog22
(Jake)
Posted 10:55:31 PM EST, 11/27/2007
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77fd7/77fd7186fb261a6a3ecef59377957f73a702a3bc" alt="5%20stars"
This French quartet can COOK! NeBeLNeST's second album, NoVa eXPReSS,
just might be my favorite prog album to come out in
the last ten years.
NeBeLNeST's sounds mixes a range of progressive styles. One thing that I find interesting about this band is that it seems
that each member of the band was a fan of a different style of music. The keyboardist clearly was influenced by symphonic
rock, and he is not afraid to let it show in his mellotron (!) parts. The guitarist seems to be largely influenced by
psych/space rock, evidenced by his use of every stomp box imaginable except distortion. The drums reek of heavy metal
influence, complete with (subtle and tasteful, not machine-gun) double-kick and roaring fills. The distorted and rolling
bass shows a zeuhl influence. What is most remarkable, though, is the way it all blends together in one cohesive whole.
The music is dominated by the rhythm section, as the aforementioned rolling distorted bass and heavy-metal drums run you over
with the melody section going nuts on top. If you are looking for beautiful, hummable, and uplifting melodies, look
elsewhere, as everything EXCEPT that is represented by the band. The bass and drums just pound away in constantly shifting
patterns, seemingly unable to repeat themselves more than once. Every time signature you can imagine is used on this album,
but it is done so with startling ease; I had listened to this album several times before I even realized that the music was
in odd time sigs.
This album actually manages to stand out with its production. Ordinarily, I don't care much about production, but the
production on this album is good enough to make me notice. There are only a handful of albums that I think have a true
"atmosphere" to them, and this is one of them. Despite all of the rapid twists and turns he puts into the album, Bob Drake
managed to maintain remarkable consistency in the overall "feel" of the album.
This album single-handedly restored hope for me that the world was still producing good music. I cannot recommend this album
highly enough to anyone who is a King Crimson fan (particularly the Red-era), an RIO fan, or simply someone looking to hear
something you haven't heard before. If you are looking for a symphonic orgy of melody, this is not the place. Otherwise,
you owe it to yourself to hear these guys.
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Certif1ed
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: April 08 2004
Location: England
Status: Offline
Points: 7559
|
Posted: December 04 2007 at 03:19 |
EMERSON LAKE & PALMER (ELP) — Love BeachReview by Certif1ed (Mark) [Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator] Posted 6:10:12 AM EST, 21/12/2112
Crap Beach.
|
The important thing is not to stop questioning.
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
sircosick
Forum Senior Member
Joined: January 29 2007
Location: Chile
Status: Offline
Points: 1264
|
Posted: December 04 2007 at 15:52 |
^ Pure genious! As for me, dunno..... Probably this:
KING CRIMSON
Islands |
1971
Studio Album
|
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music
|
Review by
sircosick
(Jorge Saavedra)
Posted 3:22:15 PM EST, 8/17/2007
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77fd7/77fd7186fb261a6a3ecef59377957f73a702a3bc" alt="5%20stars"
This album is beautiful. Sad, even depressing, but beautiful. No hard
riffs, no agressive beat changes, perhaps the less
skilled album of the early days, but beautiful. The musicianship is far
from their peak, singer and bassist Boz Burrell is
not Wetton or Lake, Fripp’s guitar is not as dinamic and protagonist as
on any other release, because he seemed to take a
more atmospheric direction. But despite all that, this album
is......... beautiful!!! Complexity doesn’t prevent emotions, as simplicity doesn’t prevent efficiency. This album is less complex, but also less
accesible. I think that’s the reason why it uses to be underrated. The songs are slowly elaborated and require a lot of
pacience by the listener. Because of that, people generally find this album quite boring. But don’t get scared; just turn on
your chimney, get a cigarrete, a glass of wine and a comfortable armchair, and put this album in your CD player... Pay
attention to it, fall in love with it and (I hate to sound cheesy:) let your tears fall down. The experimental side of King Crimson was also onmipresent in every album, but here is at their peak, mostly on the first
side. ‘Formentera Lady’ starts the album slowly and very atmospheric, beginning with vocals and string bass and deriving into
an interlude more dinamic and melodic. The second half of the song is mainly driven by weird melodies by soprano Paulina
Lucas, until the brasses come up at the end of the song and go on in ’Sailor’s Tale’, which is a prolongation of the track,
but louder. ‘The Letters’ closes the first side keeping that mindblowing and warm atmosphere, but being Boz Burrell’s vocals
way more protagonist. In these last moments of the first side maybe you can think “this album is smooth and blaaaaaand”, but
just listen to the second side. The fourth track is ‘Ladies on the Road’, perhaps the most beloved by fans. It has nice bass at the beggining and some
Beatle-esque harmonies, then falling into a chorus. The next number is one of my all-time fave Crimson pieces, the beautiful
‘Song of the Gulls’. No vocals here, just orchestration and string arrangements. Slow-paced and a simple but lovely melody.
Always put me sad, but I love it anyway. The closing track is a long epic, the longest number of the song. It’s also atmospheric, but now with fine piano and Boz’
voice. The chords are the same all along the song; Boz stops singing and a mellotron and a trumpet begin to appear subtlely,
till the end. A very sad track too, but quite nice. Maybe goes a bit long, but just a minimal bit. A warm album in general,
and yeah, fairly bland, but in the good sense ;) Highly recommended for progheads and ESSENTIAL for KC’s fans. Before stop writing this review, I’m gonna consider a couple of
additional points: this neglected masterpiece was sandwiched by other two brilliant records more popular than this, but don’t
be fooled about the musical quality founded on this stuff. Don’t dismiss it. And second, this was my first experience with
this marvelous band, so you can consider it, since my rating and my words don’t share the majority’s opinion about this
album. But that’s it; I love this bunch of songs and see no important differences of musical perfection between this and
ITCOTCK or Red. Five stars, from both personal and objetive point of view. Cosick.
|
3.73
Excellent addition to any prog music collection
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9841c/9841cbfa11f97a99f6143eefdb299cc02cb3e51c" alt="" |
|
The best you can is good enough...
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
cynthiasmallet
Forum Senior Member
Joined: October 01 2007
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 545
|
Posted: December 04 2007 at 16:34 |
Although it isn't the best written of my reviews and by no means the most detailed, i'm rather proud of my 2/5 star review of "lateralus" by Tool. I feel as if some justice has been done
|
Would you like to watch TV, or get between the sheets, or contemplate the silent freeway, would you like something to eat?
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
ClemofNazareth
Special Collaborator
Prog Folk Researcher
Joined: August 17 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 4659
|
Posted: December 04 2007 at 17:50 |
Well this is a pretty self-indulgent thread, but what the heck - here's my personal favorite:
SUPERTRAMP
Famous Last Words |
1982Studio Album |
|
Review by ClemofNazareth (Bob Moore) [Special Collaborator Prog Folk Researcher] Posted 11:17:01 AM EST, 8/26/2006
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/891aa/891aab45d7527ef46ed3c54643f395d38d4499d3" alt="5%20stars" Some of the greatest lineups in progressive music were done in by the 1980s and the resulting personal and creative chaos that seemed to characterize the early part of that decade. Unfortunately, Supertramp was no exception. “…famous last words…” marked the departure of founding member Roger Hodgson and the dissolution of one of the true songwriting duo treasures of modern music between Hodgson and Rick Davies. The split would leave Davies as the sole remaining original member of the band, plus the de facto (and legal) steward of the band’s future direction. Hodgson would launch a solo career. Neither would achieve either the kind of commercial or creative success that Supertramp did in the 1970s. I got into Supertramp with the Even in the Quiestest Moments release, although quickly discovered the much more dazzling Crime of the Century. When Breakfast in America released in 1979, I was caught up with the millions of other who flocked to hear the band’s unique blend of jazz, pop, nostalgia, and brilliant songwriting as the album went quadrillion²-platinum or whatever it ended up being. Three years later I was still playing the record, and several of the hits were still on the radio, but since the band didn’t tour very heavily across the heart of America, they weren’t on my radar all that much. Then, out of nowhere, out comes “…famous last words…”, and of course my curiosity was piqued. What had the boys come up with this time? Well, not more of the same, I can assure you of that. There are all kinds of symbolism in this album to signal the pending breakup, and the overall mood is rather resigned and depressing. First is the album cover itself, a picture of a circus performer on a tightrope looking nervously over his shoulder as a faceless hand reaches up to cut the rope with a huge pair of scissors. The album title suggests the band knew people like me would be writing wistful memorials long after the band itself was gone. The split of songwriting credits to clearly distinguish between those of Hodgson and those of Davies was a first for the band; on previous albums, the credits were always shared in one way or another. The inside liner notes even have the lyrics color-coded to distinguish between the two main writers. And the inside picture of the band shows the five members of the band, none smiling, all walking nervously across separate tightropes. And the lyrics themselves mostly point to watershed points in personal relationships in one way or another. There was no question whatsoever that this was the swan song of the band, and that the breakup was not all smiles and hugs. If you can get past the mildly depressing nature of the album though, there is actually some pretty good music here. Perhaps also symbolic, the album both begins and ends with songs written by Hodgson. And knowing Hodgson’s flair for drama, I think it’s also intentional that the album begins on a pensive high note with “Crazy”: “Here’s little song to make you feel good, put a little light in your day; these are crazy times, and it’s all been getting pretty serious. Here’s a little song to make you feel right, send the blues away; well it’s a crazy game, tell me who’s to blame – I’m pretty curious”; And ends with the sad and melancholy “Don’t Leave Me Now”: “Don’t leave me now, leave me holding an empty heart. As the curtains start to fall… all alone in this crazy world, when I’m old and cold and grey and time is gone”. I guess pain is just a reminder that you're alive, I suppose. “Crazy” is a typical opening number for the band, a peppy tempo with lots of piano, saxophone highlights as well as a short sax solo, all wrapped up in Hodgson’s slightly- mad-Englishman vocals with complementary backing by Davies. And in keeping with a trend in some of the band’s oter albums, the presence of Hodgson’s guitar is secondary to the keyboards. Davies wrote “Put on Your Old Brown Shoes”, a kind of retro-sounding jazzy/blues number with what sounds like an alto sax and an almost ragtime feel to the piano. The Wilson sisters of Heart provide backing vocals, and the overall sound is not unlike some of the music on their Private Auditions album. The lyrics are in keeping with the general breakup theme of the albuml, accented by a nice piano/sax extended instrumental passage in the middle of the song: “You and me, we’re helpless can’t you see – we’ve got to get away, get away. Got to move on, catch the next train and we’ll be gone; And the rest of our lives we’ll be free”. Hodgson offers up one of his glossy pure-pop tunes with “It’s Raining Again”, which turned out to be another huge hit single for the band. This is one of those songs you either love or hate, and I choose to love it. Like “Dreamer” or “The Logical Song”, these are bitingly sarcastic lyrics set to an upbeat, almost danceable rhythm, and some of the most haunting saxophone work John Helliwell has ever done: “It’s raining again, you know it’s hard to pretend. Oh no, it’s raining again, too bad I’m losing a friend”. The children’s chorus ending of nursery rhyme lyrics is a bit cheesy and self-indulgent on Hodgson’s part, but clearly the guy was dealing with some pretty raw emotions at the time, and this is how he often expressed those feelings in his music. This song contains one of the most striking lyrical passages Hodgson ever put on paper, in my opinion: “You’re old enough some people say, to read the signs and walk away. It’s only time that heals the pain, and makes the sun come out again”. I still can’t hear that passage even today without blinking back a few tears. I personally think that “Bonnie” is a highly symbolic work by Davies to describe the intensely personal relationship between him and Hodgson. The lyrics read like the story of an obsessed fan of an old-time movie star who is longing to get closer to her, but I believe it also describes how Davies felt about Hodgson at one time. Hodgson follows that one with the most achingly personal lament he ever penned – “Know Who You Are”. This is mostly an acoustic number with Hodgson strumming his guitar and singing in a halting, pensive mood, and I can’t listen to it without feeling like a gawking intruder into an intensely personal moment for Hodgson: “Know who you are… there’s a new song inside you. Weep if you can… let the tears fall behind you”. Davies counters with another retro-sounding light jazzy number, “My Kind of Lady”. By now the stylistically different directions Hodgson and Davies were pursuing was becoming apparent. For me this is the weakest track on the album, with 50’s-sounding backing vocals, rather tepid piano, and overall just a bit of unenthusiastic, plodding tempo. Perhaps part of the reason was that neither of the band's leaders were probably very enthusiastic to record this one. This sets up one of the band’s strongest album finishes though, with the remaining three tracks all being complex and highly memorable. Hodgson’s “C’est le bon” is almost an autobiography of sorts, with gorgeous acoustic guitar accented by what I believe is a clarinet, while Hodgson chants about having a heart full of music that just has to get out, regardless of the consequences. The Wilson sisters add touching backing vocals to give this one a timeless feel, making it one of the great forgotten Supertramp classics. Davies’ strongest work follows his weakest one, with the horn-driven “Waiting So Long”. Here again the listener cannot escape the tension in the band, with lyrics that are both biting and sad: “Did you get all you want? Did we see the whole show? So where’s all the fun that we used to know? As the memories fade way out of view, I’d love those old days to come back to you”. Hodgson offers his strongest guitar work on the album, heavy and brooding but full of life at the same time. The album closes with the final emotional cry from Hodgson, the deeply resigned soul- sigh in “Don’t Leave Me Now”. Musically this is nothing new from the band – melodic and beautiful piano and thoughtful saxophone, very little guitar, and the little-known Claire Diament with some very pleasant backing vocals. But the message is clear in the lyrics, and with the end of the album also comes the end of the band, at least as we all knew and loved them: “Don’t leave me now, leave me out with nowhere to go. As the shadows start to fall – Don’t leave me now”. In some ways I see this album as a soundtrack to the end of an age, and a symbol of the much broader dissolution of a decade of wonderful music, incredible artistic creativity, and pleasant memories. It’s a stark contrast to the band’s Breakfast in America peak, but also an incredibly poignant and personal look inside the souls of one of the great musical icons of an eclectic and artistic generation. It pains me to listen to this album, especially today as those of us who came out of that generation and those times are now adults, and we are just expected to deal with some of the same kinds of heavy, somber emotions and complex relationships that once seemed so simple and straightforward. But it is also a reminder that once you get past all the extraneous trappings, life is really all about our relationships with each other. Hodgson and Davies understood that, probably still do today. And I cherish the many songs where they expressed this and shared their emotions with us willing listeners. I am confident I am a better man for it. Hopefully those who listen to this music today and contemplate all the layers of meaning it holds for our personal interactions will someday feel the same way. peace |
|
"Peace is the only battle worth waging."
Albert Camus
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Heptade
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 19 2005
Location: Canada
Status: Offline
Points: 427
|
Posted: December 05 2007 at 08:44 |
I rather like this one, since I think it should make you want to run out and buy the album:
Mental Notes
1975
Studio Album
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music
Review by Heptade (Allister Thompson)
[Prog Reviewer ]
Posted 10:01:33 PM EST, 6/20/2007
Mental Notes is unlike anything else in the Split Enz catalogue, and frankly unlike anything else ever made. It's astonishing to think that this was their first album and their sound was so complete and assured out of the gate.
These crazy young kiwis produced a bizarre stew of early seventies sounds, without leaning too heavily on any one in particular. You can hear lots of weirdo symphonic a la Genesis, the visceral energy of Vdgg, and the unhinged art rock of 10cc and Roxy Music, with folk and music hall tossed into the mix. The album draws you into a weird surreal universe of its own, aided by eerie, echoey production and lots of spooky mellotron. That's right proggers, there's tons of 'tron on this album.
The musicianship is unexpectedly high throughout, particularly from keyboard whiz Eddie Rayner and virtuosic drummer Emlyn Crowther, who wasn't with the band for long, more's the pity. The drum production is excellent, good and thumpy. Guitarist Wally Wilkison also acquits himself well with some great electric playing. But the band's two stars were vocalists Tim Finn and Phil Judd. Finn's style resembles some kind of manic music hall singer, while Judd employs a mega-vibrato bray that is somehow incredibly creepy and matches the weirdness of his lyrics.
The album starts off with an art rock epic with lots of different memorable parts and melodies before delving into Judd's scary death ballad Under the Wheels. That's when you know this is going to be one weird trip. Before you're through, you've been treated to full blown symphonic (Stranger Than Fiction), a beautiful piano and mellotron-led ballad (Time for a Change), a thumpy rocker (Maybe) and a very strange mandolin- based song (Titus), before ending with Judd's maniacal, riffy Spellbound. You can imagine the band rehearsing in a small shack in at the very bottom of the south island of NZ, with a storm crashing overhead, conjuring up the weirdest sounds and vibes imaginable.
Believe me, proggers, no matter what you think of the later edition of the band in its Neil Finn days, this is an absolutely essential art rock album, so just get your hands on a copy!
4.36
Excellent addition to any
prog music collection
|
The world keeps spinning, people keep sinning
And all the rest is just bullsh*t
-Steve Kilbey
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Zitro
Prog Reviewer
Joined: July 11 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 1321
|
Posted: December 05 2007 at 16:51 |
I dunno. Maybe Meshuggah - I or the latest Flower King album. I've done quite a few reviews after being titled "reviewer' and I probably forgot which ones stand out.
MESHUGGAH
I |
2004
Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo
|
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music
Review by
Zitro
[Prog Reviewer ]
Posted 7:24:50 PM EST, 6/14/2007
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/16a49/16a49917897cb0d4e52ee6c9f4315b05c37d02d4" alt="3%20stars"
Huh?? That was my initial reaction when I listened to this brutal and mechanical piece of
work. This is not an album, but an EP composed of a single massive song that is 21
minutes long. Why this album is great The musicianship is absolutely mind blowing. these guys play perfectly with insane
speeds and time signatures without a single flaw in a continuous 20+ minute track,
and the guitar solos are musically impressive as well. The rhythm section is usually
composed of time signatures that probably don't even have integers as it seems to be
undecipherable. The music manages to be very coherent from one section to another for
the whole time, never letting go the heavy sound except for a few eerie soft moments
that work very well and are never out of place. The riffs are all based on these
rhythms and appear to have subtle variations in every measure, and despite the
unusual rhythms, it still manages to not sound awkward and come off as extremely
brutal, mechanic, and some of the heaviest guitar-driven recording in the history of
music. In addition, the majority of these guitar riffs are absolutely phenomenal,
including the only one you can headband to midway into the song (it is on 4/4). The
heaviness of the rhythm guitars is amplified by the maniacal double-bass drumming and
the death-metal vocals, making complete this machine that is ready to annihilate your
ears. Why this album is horrible Please, dear machine, have mercy on me! Being musically brutalized for 21 minutes
with barely much of a break is just exhausting to the ears! The death-metal vocals
are in my opinion completely unnecessary except for the lyrics which really fit and
are poetic, if in a violent way. This song could have just been instrumental. Also,
there is hardly any melody or harmony to be found in here, making this musical
journey difficult. I mean, how can you listen to a 21 minute long song without really
any melody? The only kind of melody to be found is in minute three, when a nice lead
guitar plays along with the brutal guitar riff very beautifully. In addition, the
music just has no emotion, no soul ... it's purely calculated and mathematical. The
bass is as inaudible as in Dream Theater, which is a shame as it could have played some neat bass lines as a counterpoint to the rhythm guitar. Another problem I
have with it is the beginning of the piece which is nothing but trashy noise for
almost two minutes. the last problem is repetition, you have music based on guitar
riffs and the death-metal vocals always sound the same. It's just overkill! Well,
my 5-star and 1-star qualities cancel each other into a 3 star album. I recommend this album to extreme-metal lovers and anyone
who is adventurous to try something radically different. Symphonic rock
lovers, approach this EP with extreme caution.
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Tapfret
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin
Joined: August 12 2007
Location: Bryant, Wa
Status: Offline
Points: 8614
|
Posted: December 05 2007 at 22:19 |
cynthiasmallet wrote:
Although it isn't the best written of my reviews and by no means the most detailed, i'm rather proud of my 2/5 star review of "lateralus" by Tool. I feel as if some justice has been done data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a4f76/a4f764987bb8e22f885e1330ca6bb37d4b9c96f1" alt="" |
I rated it the same. And while it is not my best review, it was the most work I have done listening in order to write the review. Painful.
As far as my best, not really satisfied yet. I have a format that I like and I think I can share a lot about an album with it, but it still needs fine tuning.
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Fight Club
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 572
|
Posted: December 05 2007 at 23:38 |
I don't know which of mine is my best, but I think I'm improving with every one! I look at some of my early reviews and wanna throw up because they're so stupid and uninformative. Hopefully I'll keep getting better (and fix those spelling errors!) That is if I can actually bring myself to write another review...
|
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Cesar Inca
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: May 19 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 4888
|
Posted: December 08 2007 at 07:46 |
I'm particularly proud of this review for SENOGUL's debut album - it started as an English translation of a Spanish review I had written a week before, but it turned out to have its own particular general idea.-
SENOGUL — SenogulReview by Cesar Inca (César Inca Mendoza Loyola) Special Collaborator Symphonic Prog Specialist
Senogul has delivered with this album a manifesto of their musical genius, stating one of the most exquisite new affirmations of the prog genre in their country. The material recorded through the years 2005 and 2006 is what we find here in Senogul's offiical debut recording, now released by Mylodon Records in 2007. Five of the 12 tracks that are comprised in this repertoire already existed in their demo "Tránsitos", and now we can enjoy them in refurbished fashion... well those tracks and all of them, in general. The quantity of guests (mainly on wind instruments) is very revealing of the band's interest on the expansion of the colors inherent to their compositions. The band's sound is characterized by an energetic combination of symphonic prog and jazz- rock, porperly ornamented with classical music touches and folky flavors. García Salueña's keyboards (with the piano assuming a prominent role) play a reasonable featured part in the band's sonic architecture, while the rhythm duo displays a high degree of dynamics and precision, very accurate to help the band's overall input to make things happen in a convincing way. The album's first 6 minutes are occupied by the diptic of 'Dr. Gull I' and 'Racionalidad'. 'Dr. Gull I' gest started on a solemn note, based on the ambiences delivered by the piano chordp rogressions, while the other instruments (mainly the lead guitar) build up a moderate sense of energy instilled into the main motif's development; with the choir adding a touch of majestic vibrations to the fold, teh door is open for the entrance of 'racionalidad', a delicious track plethoric of melodic dynamics and an exciting tempo. Next comes the first opus in teh album, 'Tango Mango'. This is sheer old-fashiones progressive sophistication: various motifs succedding one another, variations of mood and tempo, tight performances full of technical prowess, but never getting the pyrotechnics to a gratuitous level. The inclusion of tango-based elements helps the track to preserve its colorfulness throughout its expansion. Having said this, I confess that I find this track less cohesvie than the other long numbers: it is very good, but it wll soon be eclipsed by the next two pieces. 'La Verbena Hermética' is just awesome, captivating, owning a captivating dexterity that comprises both variation and cohesion in perfect doses. The piano leads the track's main body with its inspiration in the jazzier side of Emerson. There is an interlude near the end that goes deeper into the jazzy side of things while the horn arrangements play some agile counterpoints, very much a-la GG. And then comes the final section, a lovely lovely translation of part of the main motif into a 6/8 tempo, a homage to Asturias' folk dances (Asturians happens to be the band members' native Spanish region). The candid colors of Norhern Spain's folk are funnily complemented by the amazing Moog solo and the burlesque of animal sounds - I get goosebumps everytime I get to this closing portion. 'Microcosmos Blues' is more jam-oriented, consisting on a smaller amount of motifs that fin more room for expansion than those comprised in 'Tango Mango'. Unlike its immediate predecessor, 'Microcosmos Blues' bears a more greyinsh mood, like an autumn evening under the haze. This prominent mood is more featured in the relaxed sections, although there is also room for some solid dual guitar riffing (leading the band toward a flirt with tandardized psychodelia) and even a brief reagge-jazz interlude. The album's second half begins with another diptic, 'Dr. Gull II'-'Gotas de Cristal en Tu Vaso de Lluvia' (beautiful title, 'Crystal Drops in Your Glass of Rain'). 'Dr. Gull II' begins with a reprise of some piano touches from the first 'Dr. Gull', and then comes a series of special effects that serve as a proper prelude for the manifestation of density in 'Gotas de Cristal...'. One of the most amazing tricks of this number is how well the intense spiralling piano goes sliding under the rhythm section's slow motion and the dense guitar solo. 'La Maha Vishnuda' continues with this trend of slow tempo and melancholy ambiences, but this time the track is less dense and more candorous. The interaction between the two guitarists is carefully crafted in order to guide the track's dynamics fro mbeginning to end in a solid manner. 'Agua, Fuego y Porexpán' brings back the appealing colorfulness that had been cleverly exploited in tarcks 2-4. The track's punchy spirit is enhanced by the effective work of the guests on saxes, trumpet and trombone - following the road of fusion, the band also feels comfortable, although the sytlish vibe they deliver is evidently due to their overall progressive approach. The jazz thing persists in the beautiful (albeit too ephimeral!) 'Travesía de las Gaviotas', a display of soft Ltin-jazz under a guise of serenity. I personally feel that 'La Maha' and 'Travesía' could have benefited from further expansion, but anyway, things are as they are and these two tracks are very good as they are. 'La Mulata Eléctrica' has, in comparison to the version included in "Tránsitos", a tighter guitar work and more notable dynamics. The band's symphonic splendour is revealed in full colors, even including some crafty hints to Andalusian prog (like Triana or Mezquita, so to speak). Well, the last 4+ minutes are occupied by 'Dr. Gull III', the most articulated composition in the 'Dr. Gull' series, setting once again that fluid combination of symphonic and jazz-rock that is Senogul's. This album is really great, essential to get to know one of the peaks of the current Spanish progressive scene - Senogul has reached full maturity in terms of performance and creativity.
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |
Cesar Inca
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: May 19 2004
Location: Peru
Status: Offline
Points: 4888
|
Posted: December 08 2007 at 07:49 |
This was also a review that I was glad I could write, and a few days later, one of the band's musicians e-mailed me to show me appreciation on behalf of the whole band.-
NEBELNEST
Review | Album details | All reviews | Buy Music |
Review by Cesar Inca (César Inca Mendoza Loyola) [Special Collaborator Symphonic Prog Specialist] Posted 10:39:01 PM EST, 9/30/2006
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/891aa/891aab45d7527ef46ed3c54643f395d38d4499d3" alt="5%20stars" Abrasive energy, aggressive darkness and challenging inventiveness – name these three items and you will be summarizing what NeBeLNeST’s recent release “ZePTO” is all about. This has to be one of the Top 5 prog albums of the year, and it’s really stunning how energetic and cohesive this avant-rock album is, considering that it was conceived and recorded during a long period of crisis, during which an old guitarist stayed for a little more time and then left, another one came in to replace him, and ultimately, the band’s nucleus was reduced to Tejedor brothers and drummer Anselmi. Anyway, NeBeLNeST’s sound is more focused on Olivier’s multiple keyboards than ever before, but it hasn’t stopped the band from creating their most ballsy recording so far. Yes, the nuclear trio have managed to concentrate mainly on their most chaotic side of their music and explore it further in order to instill a renewed electrifying energy into the realms of RIO. But that doesn’t come out that clear until the second track. The catchy opening track ‘Pillars of Birth’, built on a robust 5/4 tempo, pretty much follows the path of the previous offering “Nova Express”. ‘Manjuns’ is definitely oriented toward radical disturbance, stating an ambience of semi-controlled anarchy that the musicians deliver with solid efficiency, while challenging each other mercilessly. ‘The Old Ones’ kind of recycles the spirits of the previous two numbers; it recaptures the swing of track 1, but with a more sinister vibe, which results in a tension similar to that exposed in track 2. A special mention has to go to the keyboard input, essential for the mood of ‘The Old Ones’. There is also a noticeable presence of jazz-rock nuances in places, which allows the generation of contrast against the harder-edged sections: Gregory’s wickedly distorted bass lines serve as main solidifiers of those aforesaid harder sections. Does the listener want some more anarchy? There is the short ‘The Thing in the Walls’, that appears to our ears as an endless masochistic nightmare with its random paths that concretize a massive sonic deconstruction. Free-jazz, thrash-metal, radical psychedelia and HC’s “In Praise of Learning” RIO: all this and more in less than 2 minutes. Its abrupt end is segued into the more ethnic ‘Fabric of Reality’: percussive drifts and exotic clarinet flourishes emerge over a krautrock-inspired minimalist series of keyboard layers, until the last minute brings a defying musique concrete display. ‘De Triumpho Naturae’ and ‘Do What Thou Wilt’ are the longest tracks in the album. The former is linked to the aleatory coda of ‘Fabric’, and actually gets started in a similar mood, until a well-ordained crescendo appears, seasoned with a cosmic interlude. The latter has a weird, eerie 4-minute intro, like a subtle hint of scary things to come. Then… they come. The main motif shows a ballsy mixture of classic Present and “Starless and Bible Black”-era KC. The spacey synthesizer ornaments are featured in order to enhance the track’s overall surreal essence. The epilogue ‘Station 9’ portrays the machine-driven world that we live in. The cybernetic aura created by the free flowing of mechanic- sounding keyboards and percussions is full of abstract mystery and creepy intensity. Many of NeBeLNeST connoisseurs were afraid that the band had left the scene for good: we were so wrong… the band was only recreating itself in the dark, waiting to reappear with a vengeance. And so they did: “ZePTO” is a hell of a masterpiece in the current world of RIO. |
|
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87e8d/87e8df83ce72662bbb416676070d3558b4ba7267" alt="Back to Top Back to Top" |