Punk vs Grunge - music killers

both are famed for KILLING MUSIC  as we know of and by that making people play more porely on theri instruments, dress uglyer and behave like teenagers ,  but who killed the scene the most ,

did Punk kill of Prog more or was Grunge more ruthless towards Glam/Hair metal,

many people say Grunge killed metal IS THAT TRUE or did Punk kill prog IS THAT TRUE

what is most true and what is least true

and don' think this poll seriously, it is a fun poll made for common conception of killing of genres, or can we say mis-conspetion

but im not blaiming anyone that say a genre killed another genre, it is just funny to hear people ranting, when they havent investigated in teh genres,

thier is bad punk and their is good punk, also theri is bad grunge and their is good grunge

but this is about killing genres what killed of the other genres most


Edited by aginor - April 22 2012 at 04:55

Grunge basically destroyed everything that was remotely good in the early to mid 90's and influenced a tidal wave of sh*t into the rest of the decade and early 2000's wile punk gave raise to very interesting re-readings and rebirth of genres and bands.

I don't believe anything i  am reading in this thread.

Snow Dog wrote: I don't believe anything i  am reading in this thread.

Fox On The Rocks wrote: Horizons wrote: Punk. I like Pearl Jam and Soundgarden and practically nothing from the punk genre. I also think Punk's influence over music in general has continued much longer and stronger.  Damn, I accidentally voted Grunge. I totally agree with this. I actually enjoy bands that are typically labelled Grunge/Alternative/Indie - they make much more exciting and creative music compared to Punk bands. The only thing I like about Punk is the whole culture and community, really. The Smashing Pumpkins, Soundgarden, Dinosaur Jr., Pearl Jam, all these bands are amazing.

I like a lot of Punk (Sex Pistols, The Clash, plus punk's offshoots like Post-punk, New Wave, and No-wave) and I like alot of Grunge (Well, just Soundgarden)

it is a just for fun poll,so it is for fun and those with humor , but then maybe my humor is silly and dumb but i dont care,

htis is a SPOOF of the genre killing thing, i have never NEVER said a genre was killed or that genres dissapeard, I have NEVER ever had that opinion in my life, but this is satirical it is a spoof, a playing on the term of the two most known genres to have "killed of " a certian genre decade, and i don't suspect people are taking it seriously, humor is good to ligthten up the just for fun section,