Forum Home Forum Home > Progressive Music Lounges > Prog Polls
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Battle of the Prog Bands SFD2: Floyd vs. Rush
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Battle of the Prog Bands SFD2: Floyd vs. Rush
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <12345 8>
Poll Question: Which band do you prefer?
Poll Choice Votes Poll Statistics
97 [62.99%]
57 [37.01%]
You can not vote in this poll

Author
Message
  Topic Search Topic Search  Topic Options Topic Options
Catcher10 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar
VIP Member

Joined: December 23 2009
Location: Emerald City
Status: Offline
Points: 17846 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Catcher10 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 01:30
Originally posted by rogerthat rogerthat wrote:

Originally posted by Billy Pilgrim Billy Pilgrim wrote:

Any one member of Rush is twice as talented as Pink Floyd as a whole band. 


Lifeson twice as talented as THE Dave Gilmour, the king of bends and vibrato?  Gimme a break!  Lifeson doesn't even do his technical rock stuff too cleanly unlike the other monsters from the 70s like Roth, Schenker and Eddie Van Halen and some of his solos, like Freewill, are not too good at all.  No debate on Lee and Peart but then again, having better players never made a better band.
 
I agree with Gilmour...he is amazing, much better than any of the Floyd musicians, he stands alone in this group.
But Lifeson does not compare to the others....Uli Jon Roth after the Scorpions got lost in transcendental, heavenly Andreas Vollenweider type stuff. Uli was just like Ritchie Blackmore, kinda got lost...but great guitarist. I love his time with Scorpions.
I assume you mean Michael Schenker and not Rudolf. Michael was born a guitarist, a master of the 6-string. Michael's time with Scorpions and UFO clearly outshines what he has done the past 10-15 yrs. I am an advid MS listener....in no way would I compare his playing to Alex's. And Alex is not a frontman like Michael or Eddie VH were..
 
But agree on Gilmour.....I especially like his solo material.
Thanks Smile
 
Back to Top
rogerthat View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer


Joined: September 03 2006
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 9869 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote rogerthat Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 01:32
Originally posted by Catcher10 Catcher10 wrote:

 
On Influence, its my personal opinion about both bands...not the whole genre or time frame they may be influencing.


Sorry, I don't get this? Isn't influence about influencing genres/musicians to follow your leads?
 
Originally posted by Catcher10 Catcher10 wrote:

My personal belief is a band that enjoys playing music together as one cohesive unit makes better music longterm than a band that does not and has a lot of internal issues. And for these two bands that proof is in the pudding....I am sure you get my point that longevity is one main attribute of success...for me.


I got that. Personally, I also draw lines between the quality of albums.  The best Rush could do, Moving Pictures, is still not a patch on Meddle for me. Now if that is NOT your opinion, I can understand that but not how a long sequence of good albums is better than a few outstanding albums because I would always go for the latter.


Originally posted by Catcher10 Catcher10 wrote:

I doubt any band starts out to only be mildly succesful...The Beatles, Pink Floyd or Rush....and since you brought that other poll into this, yes I do feel Rush are more succesful than The Beatles for having the stamina and focus to continue for 35 yrs.


I should hope bands start out to, to put it baldly, make music.  Confused  Like Robert Fripp, for instance.  The music is what matters end of the day, not what the critics, the media, the fans think of you.

 

Originally posted by Catcher10 Catcher10 wrote:

Your last point I don't understand....you said the following above "...Floyd spread themselves across a much wider variety of music"......I think most would be fine subing in Rush for Floyd in your sentence..Pink Floyd could have been trademarked in the 70's.



Then I would have to conclude they have never given much attention to Floyd beyond their 'iconic' songs. Let's take Dark Side....they go from Time through Great Gig in the Sky through Money through Us and Them etc to Eclipse.  That IS a wide variety of music, covering a wide gamut of emotions in turn.  I brought this up before in the Beatles debate too but Rush having already slotted themselves as heavy rock limit their options and are forced to lean on the side of heavy no matter what they do. Floyd never had such restrictions.  Anyway, I don't really see much similarity between Meddle and The Wall and, yes, I have heard them 'properly'.
 
Sorry if my style of argument of dividing the post line by line was offensive. Embarrassed
Back to Top
Tarquin Underspoon View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 12 2009
Location: USA
Status: Offline
Points: 1416 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Tarquin Underspoon Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 01:37
I'll vote Pink Floyd here, and I'll probably sit out the final round....too tough
"WAAAAAAOOOOOUGH!    WAAAAAAAUUUUGGHHHH!!   WAAAAAOOOO!!!"

-The Great Gig in the Sky
Back to Top
rogerthat View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer


Joined: September 03 2006
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 9869 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote rogerthat Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 01:45
Originally posted by Catcher10 Catcher10 wrote:

But Lifeson does not compare to the others....Uli Jon Roth after the Scorpions got lost in transcendental, heavenly Andreas Vollenweider type stuff. Uli was just like Ritchie Blackmore, kinda got lost...but great guitarist. I love his time with Scorpions.
I assume you mean Michael Schenker and not Rudolf. Michael was born a guitarist, a master of the 6-string. Michael's time with Scorpions and UFO clearly outshines what he has done the past 10-15 yrs. I am an advid MS listener....in no way would I compare his playing to Alex's. And Alex is not a frontman like Michael or Eddie VH were..
 
But agree on Gilmour.....I especially like his solo material.
Thanks Smile
 


Never really tried Roth solo, so I did have his time with Scorpions in mind. Amazing guitarist, could let it rip like Catch your train and then use his lovely vibrato to delicate effect on ballads like In Your Park. 

Yeah, meant Michael Schenker. I know, his solo material was SO disappointing. Cry  UFO was clearly his best. 

I should reassess this but I like Gilmour's guitarwork on On An Island as much as on Meddle through to Dark Side, which is my favourite from his work with Floyd.  So dreamy, fluid and unbelievably beautiful.
Back to Top
Gandalff View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 07 2007
Location: Middle-Earth
Status: Offline
Points: 4214 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Gandalff Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 01:54
Pink Floyd by light year.
A Elbereth Gilthoniel
silivren penna míriel
o menel aglar elenath!
Na-chaered palan-díriel
o galadhremmin ennorath,
Fanuilos, le linnathon
nef aear, sí nef aearon!
Back to Top
octopus-4 View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
RIO/Avant/Zeuhl,Neo & Post/Math Teams

Joined: October 31 2006
Location: Italy
Status: Online
Points: 14110 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote octopus-4 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 02:55
There's no story here...I would have been curious to see Floyd vs Yes instead...
I stand with Roger Waters, I stand with Joan Baez, I stand with Victor Jara, I stand with Woody Guthrie. Music is revolution
Back to Top
Varon View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: August 06 2010
Location: Ukraine
Status: Offline
Points: 502 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Varon Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 03:44
Pink Floyd have never been among my favourites but in that case I vote for them .
Would you catch the final words of mine?
Would you catch my words???
Back to Top
progknight94 View Drop Down
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie
Avatar

Joined: September 21 2010
Location: italy
Status: Offline
Points: 4 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote progknight94 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 04:53
I can't understand how a band could ever be better than Robert Fripp, our only King.
He shouldn't partecipate, only arbitrate: this is a "battle" for the 2nd position.
Prog wouldn't exist without King Crimson.
 
P.S: rush??? is 2112 better than supper's ready?? no one could ever say that...
Prog, after classic, is the highest form of musical expression!!! (I prefer prog, but I guess classic music has to be a bit better:D)
Back to Top
rushfan4 View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: May 22 2007
Location: Michigan, U.S.
Status: Offline
Points: 66260 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote rushfan4 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 05:12
Originally posted by thellama73 thellama73 wrote:

Rush for me. Too bad they're going to lose.
This.
Back to Top
Snow Dog View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: March 23 2005
Location: Caerdydd
Status: Offline
Points: 32995 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Snow Dog Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 05:16
oooh.....this is a toughy for me.
Back to Top
Zargus View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: May 08 2005
Location: Sweden
Status: Offline
Points: 3491 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Zargus Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 05:26
PF by 2 light years, i never been a rush fan, they are a good band, but not on the same level as floyd.
Back to Top
Bonnek View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 01 2009
Location: Belgium
Status: Offline
Points: 4515 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Bonnek Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 05:47

Pink Flush
Back to Top
refugee View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar
VIP Member

Joined: November 20 2006
Location: Greece
Status: Offline
Points: 7026 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote refugee Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 06:13
PF. I acknowledge the skills of the members of Rush, but their music just doesn’t move me like PF’s music does, and I always wonder why they chose a 14 year old girl to sing LOL (my apologies to Geddy).
He say nothing is quite what it seems;
I say nothing is nothing
(Peter Hammill)
Back to Top
harmonium.ro View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator

Honorary Collaborator / Retired Admin

Joined: August 18 2008
Location: Anna Calvi
Status: Offline
Points: 22989 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote harmonium.ro Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 07:42
Originally posted by octopus-4 octopus-4 wrote:

There's no story here...I would have been curious to see Floyd vs Yes instead...


+1
Back to Top
chrijom View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: October 23 2010
Location: UK
Status: Offline
Points: 683 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote chrijom Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 08:40
Rush, but they will be suffocated by the behemoth that is Pink Floyd.Unhappy
Back to Top
mEP View Drop Down
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie


Joined: August 10 2010
Location: po
Status: Offline
Points: 36 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote mEP Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 08:53
.

Edited by mEP - April 21 2018 at 07:02
Back to Top
thellama73 View Drop Down
Collaborator
Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: May 29 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 8368 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote thellama73 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 09:06
Originally posted by progknight94 progknight94 wrote:

I can't understand how a band could ever be better than Robert Fripp, our only King.
He shouldn't partecipate, only arbitrate: this is a "battle" for the 2nd position.
Prog wouldn't exist without King Crimson.
 
P.S: rush??? is 2112 better than supper's ready?? no one could ever say that...


2112 is better than Supper's Ready Tongue
Back to Top
Jörgemeister View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: February 10 2008
Location: Nauticus
Status: Offline
Points: 2296 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Jörgemeister Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 10:00
Originally posted by thellama73 thellama73 wrote:

Originally posted by progknight94 progknight94 wrote:

I can't understand how a band could ever be better than Robert Fripp, our only King.
He shouldn't partecipate, only arbitrate: this is a "battle" for the 2nd position.
Prog wouldn't exist without King Crimson.
 
P.S: rush??? is 2112 better than supper's ready?? no one could ever say that...


2112 is better than Supper's Ready Tongue

+1
I Could have bought a Third World country with the riches that I've spent
Back to Top
someone_else View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar
VIP Member

Joined: May 02 2008
Location: Going Bananas
Status: Offline
Points: 24295 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote someone_else Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 10:11
Pink Floyd.
Back to Top
anoblesoul View Drop Down
Forum Groupie
Forum Groupie
Avatar

Joined: July 02 2009
Status: Offline
Points: 46 		Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote anoblesoul Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 14 2010 at 10:18
At first glance I thought "PF, of course" and then the pendulum started swinging. My favorite album from either is Hemispheres, but my desert island discs would also include The Wall. In individual songs PF has more of my faves. Both have a period of albums I enjoy and lots that I haven't gotten in to. Since I can't vote yet anyway, this one is easy. No vote. Approve


Edited by anoblesoul - November 14 2010 at 10:30
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <12345 8>

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.227 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.