Your Favorite Pink Floyd Vocalist

One of these days I'm going to cut you into little pieces! I voted Gilmour, but hearing Mason say that sends shivers down my spine 

Wright has an emotional feel that makes all of the songs he sings in the greatest on their corresponding albums, such as Echoes, Summer 68', and/or Wearing the Inside Out. They make a kind of hollow, reclusive feel that trademarks said songs.

David + Roger together

Roger's falsettos are excellent!

Well, I've finally decided. I'll say Syd Barrett is the best. I've always loved early Floyd but I think all of the vocalists in the band were great.

I went for Rog

Gilmour still has a lovely voice - angelic, even......while Waters' voice is far from lover-ly, it's much more emotive - and that's his strength.  The messages that guy puts across demands eerie whispers and pointed shouts (and an array of signature sound effects).  Animals is my favorite Floyd album - Gilmour never got more out of his guitar and the lyrics just need those snide Waters vocals.  But Animals is it for me.....Roger's voice took over the Wall and it's the reason I rarely put it on.  I love the "story" behind the Final Cut, but Roger's voice was almost too much.....grating at times.  Killed the feel of the final two records.

I voted for mister Wright. Just listen to Paintbox and you'll know it to be true.

I like them all, but I find it a hard choice between Gilmour and Waters: David Gilmour has the best voice of them all and even in his sixties he is a good singer. Roger Waters can lay a unique venom in his singing, which fits well in some of his songs. I vote for David Gilmour, especially because Roger Waters has lost the major part of his voice and his singing comes close to whispering on his later albums.

Gilmour = vocals
Waters = Lyrics