Yes, an open discussion-how not to do it!

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

 Snow Dog wrote:

 Certif1ed wrote:

 Snow Dog wrote:

 Certif1ed wrote:

 Snow Dog wrote:

 BaldFriede wrote:

He makes the mistake of singing these lyrics beautifully, which is plain nonsense, in my opinion. The lyrics have nothing to do with beauty, and the voice should mirror that. That's what I love about Peter Hammill: You don't need to understand a word to understand what he is singing about. He would have sung that line totally differently.

Its no mistake and it is sung perfectly. Please don't make fictitious rules about singing!

You don't like Relayer, so why argue about it. The song is sung correctly.
It's a free forum - who are you to tell me what I can or can't argue about?
I'm not telling you, I'm asking you, thats why I used "why"...duh!
OK, well the answer is that it's a free forum... double duh!!!

How can anyone sing a song "perfectly"? 
They can't. Its just my opinion. No one can be absolutely perfect and this is just a cheap point scoring shot.
Hence the sticky-out tongue... Duh! 
I don't believe your sticky out toungue to be honest. And even if I did, you ignored Horza's laughing Smiley after his "head up arse" comment.....
What does that mean - you don't believe it to be "honest"? 
And Horza's laughing smiley could be interpreted in a mischievous way - I did not ignore it. On the contrary.

 Snow Dog wrote:

 BaldFriede wrote:

 Fragile wrote:

I'm beginning ti think your taste is hanging in the western wind Cert at first I thought you were trying to make sense now with your latest outburst it is very clear it's your taste buds that are a poor.Muse are ok for 1 to 2 songs max; the singer is boring and Radiohead are very poor if those are your singers Cert then you enjoy them.But reciprocated facts, Nah, I don't think so our tastes are just different I love the greatest prog band ever and you haven't been blessed with that grace but that's your misfortune.

If you truly think Yes are the greatest prog-band ever you haven't heard much.

And so speaks the true Prog snob ellitist. I always new you looked down on us lowly mortals who loke "pop" music like Yes, Genesis etc.
Why do you think CTTE is number one? It must be because it is mercilessly played on MTV all the time. People who rate it so highly must be morons who mindlessly accept anything fed to them!
If Magma or Gong had the number one album here wpuild that make you happy? Of course not, how copuld you be a patronising, condescending elitist then?

Please do not admonish other forum members or collaborators in such a way or call them names - it is against the forum rules.
I didn't call her a name. She is patronising. So are you come to that!
Calling her a "patronising, condescending elitist" is calling her a name. I know she can stick up for herself, but it looks like you need a reminder of the forum rules.
And whether she or I are patronising is entirely a matter of opinion.
In my opinion, neither of us are.

Either debate the points or shut up.  
No you shut up! You can't can you?
I didn't tell you to shut up... read the sentence again, will you?

It is VERY bad form to make personal comments about people, collabs or not, and people like you are making the administrative side of this site look bad.
I just dislike you and baldfriede so much I couldn't contain it any longer........sorry.
Maybe - and I accept your apology - but you should not break the forum rules in order to tell us those sort of things - that is what the PM is for. 
Whether you like me or not is hardly my concern - that is your problem. Don't make it everybody else's.
You are a Collaborator on this site.
Act like one.

Edited by Certif1ed