10 Highest Rated Albums On PA

They are rated so high because they only have 4 and 5 star ratings. Album like CTTE or TAAB have many ratings but some of them are 2 or 3 stars. You can check almost any sub-genre page and the #1 album in the top 20 is usually not even the highest rated.

Wow. I only know for of these. I'll vote later. 

Never heard of any of those except for Henderson and the thread title is incorrect or misleading at any rate.

Kotro wrote: Must accept the shame and confess I haven't even ever heard of those artists, never mind the albums!

This. You're not alone haha

Hercules wrote: Wanorak wrote: No vote. I've only heard the Seer and I didn't like it. I did listen to it after recommendations on here and I thought it was an absolutely bloody awful album. If I could be bothered to review it, I'd give it 1*, but with only 17 ratings it's such a minor album it's not worth it. I haven't heard any of the rest so no vote from me either.

For a recently added band, that's a good showing.  I mean, it was only added a couple of weeks ago, wasn't it? I'm sure had Swans been added earlier it would have considerably more ratings.  I suspect that Seer would have many more had the band been added in 2012 (the year that album came out).  At rateyourmusic The Seer has 229 reviews, and is ranked the number two album of 2012.  At allmusic it has a four-and-half star rating out of 5 stars.  Not a minor album in the general music world, I would say.  I haven't heard it yet.  Of course your rating and review would have a bigger effect on the average at PA since it has only 17 ratings, but not good to rate unless you've given it a number of spins and given it some time to sink in, I think -- especially if its outside your regular listening sphere so you don't have as many compass points when it comes to the style.

I've been lucky in that I've almost never received a recommendation that I didn't like.  I commonly don't pay much heed to recommendations unless they're directed at me personally by people who know my tastes, and usually they have similar tastes -- I mean, I'll try out bits of the music (say on youtube) based on lots of recommendations, but not usually listen to a  whole album unless I feel I have good reason to believe that I will like it already.  Some people I know that I'll never be led wrong-by and in those cases I will get the whole album -- even then it might take a while for the music to fully click (or I might just need to be in the right mood), but it always has clicked.  PAers have never steered me wrong.  I did make the mistake of buying a couple of albums back in 2004 or 2005 based on their reputations here which were not to my tastes, but then those recommendations weren't being aimed at me, so i only had my impulsiveness to blame (had I known the proggiverse better, and knew better in following descriptions, then I wouldn't have made those mistakes.


Edited by Logan - January 07 2014 at 20:01

Factor Burzaco, amazing album!!!!! followed by Korekyojin

Wanorak wrote: No vote. I've only heard the Seer and I didn't like it.

Jackson

No vote. I've only heard the Seer and I didn't like it.

Factor Burzaco. Have you already heard it?