The Best Pink Floyd Album

Wish You Were Here, followed by The Wall and Animals.

How hard because of their huge crative universe, but:
4.Wish you were here
3.The dark side of the moon
2.Animals
1.The Wall

Has to be Dark Side of the Moon, despite some reservations.

dr wu23 wrote: Xonty wrote: I don't get why Dark Side isn't the top answer to be honest. Better than WYWH and Animals to me    Well...I agree with you X man................imo DSOTM has a better batch of songs ;  to me WYWH is a close second and Animals is third. I chose Meddle because it's a sentimental favorite with me.

Mmm... well, for me both "Wish You were Here" and "Animals" are stronger than Dark Side. I guess that's mainly because those other albums have less songs, and they are longer, so they have more space to develop and create atmospheres, and get longer solos.

Moogtron III wrote: Stool Man wrote:   How many times have we done these polls? Yes, and how many times are we going to do these polls again in the future?  Well, I don't mind the repetition myself. Actually, it's fun to do it again from time to time. But that's me.

Xonty wrote: I don't get why Dark Side isn't the top answer to be honest. Better than WYWH and Animals to me

Edited by dr wu23 - September 14 2013 at 08:47

Dellinger wrote: Olape wrote: My personal fav is Live in Pompeii, by far. From the studio albums, i am among Atom Heart Mother and Meddle. Vote goes to the first of them. I don't think I would put Live in Pompeii as my favourite, but it's right there next to Wish you were Here and Animals for me, and just a bit above Dark Side and Division Bell. I wish it had been released as an audio album too, that would have been great. In some ways, I find Live in Pompeii better than Meddle... it certainly has a better selection of songs (and it has the best songs from Meddle included). The only thing is that the performance and/or recording of those songs is a bit better on Meddle.

Pompeii - just amazing. Waters bass during the funky section of Echoes first half is stunning, he has such a great sound here, better than the 'Meddle' version. And Gilmour plays these glorious power-chords and just rips it on his black strat. Man, I think I'll dig out my DVD of this today.

Olape wrote: My personal fav is Live in Pompeii, by far. From the studio albums, i am among Atom Heart Mother and Meddle. Vote goes to the first of them.

I don't think I would put Live in Pompeii as my favourite, but it's right there next to Wish you were Here and Animals for me, and just a bit above Dark Side and Division Bell. I wish it had been released as an audio album too, that would have been great. In some ways, I find Live in Pompeii better than Meddle... it certainly has a better selection of songs (and it has the best songs from Meddle included). The only thing is that the performance and/or recording of those songs is a bit better on Meddle.

Tom Ozric wrote: dr prog wrote: Piper 2/10 rubbish How so ???

Rubbish may be too strong a word to use, but I'm not particularly fond of this album either. The one song that I really love on this album is "Astronomy Domine", and the next 2 or 3 songs are kind of OK too, but the rest of the album is just not my taste. "Interstellar Overdrive" was an almost great song, but it had too much disonance and too little of the cool riffs at the beginning.

Animals.