Bad singer

La Brie, definitely.

The poll is missing a lot of worse singers - I can't tell you how many prog bands make great music but have a terrible singer.

Puppet Show comes to mind - sometimes the singer is good, but sometimes he sounds like Axl Rose bustin' veins in his neck.

And any band that sounds like Yes has a horrible singer - there's no substitute for Jon at higher octaves.

KeyserSoze Senior Member Joined: 2005 09 April Location: Hungary Online Status: Offline Posts: 124

Posted: 2005 25 May at 10:57pm | IP Logged eriksalkeld: No, it isn't useless because I didn't ask who is the worst. I asked who is a bad singer and you could vote for more than one singer from that list. I consider some singers on the list as good singers but people can have a different opinion. I hope not many people will cheat selecting one singer more times...

that's what I meant, people voting more than once for 1 singer.

I hope the exact thing ...

Geddy Lee's here but no Kerry Minnear?!  What a biased poll!

Drew!

Chill out!

I'm a huge Rush fan and I agree that Geddy Lee is a good singer, but he sure aint for everyone, and people dont qualify as morons for not liking him.

I've never heard the guy from Pain of Salvation, but he can have my vote as his band has a crap name...

IMO...

some of the people says in this poll that labrie´s voice is really bad... but in the other poll, where ask for our votes for the best voice, some people choose labrie´s voice too!!

can you decide??

is good or bad?' non twice

None of them - it's a matter of taste

Anyone who lists Peter Hammill as bad singer has never heard what he really can do. And I am not talking of the extreme singing he often deals out which certainly is not everybodies cup of tea. But the man can sing absolutely beautifully. Let me relate something that happened on a Peter Hammill concert in Bochum: He had given 5 encores, and the roadies had already started to dismount the stage, yet still the audience wanted more. Then Hammill came back on stage, a towel around the shoulders, advanced to the front of the stage and sang "Again" in an absolutely beautiful voice, without mic. The whole audience was completely silent, but when he had finished the applause thundered.
What many don't like about his singing though is that when he doesn't sing of beautiful things his voice sounds the same as what he sings about, so I understand why many hate him. But he can sing completely different, and one should take the time to hear this side of him too. But saying he cannot sing is completely off the mark

Edited by BaldJean

Beefheart...duh.. Geez

eriksalkeld: No, it isn't useless because I didn't ask who is the worst. I asked who is a bad singer and you could vote for more than one singer from that list. I consider some singers on the list as good singers but people can have a different opinion. I hope not many people will cheat selecting one singer more times...