Favourite Led Zeppelin album?

ProgMetaller2112 wrote: ole-the-first wrote: Blues and folk tradition is largely based on borrowing. not really its based on sounding similar.

Yeah, ... because there is a huge difference.

ProgMetaller2112 wrote: what is it now Jamie Muir??? why go as far as to using profanity

That's Kyle MacLachlan, wisea$$.

Edited by Dayvenkirq - January 11 2013 at 01:50

Dayvenkirq wrote: ProgMetaller2112 wrote: ole-the-first wrote: Blues and folk tradition is largely based on borrowing. not really its based on sounding similar. Yeah, ... because there is a huge difference. ProgMetaller2112 wrote: what is it now Jamie Muir??? why go as far as to using profanity That's Kyle MacLachlan, wisea$$.

I'm not talking about his avatar wisea$$ I'm calling him that because he made a comment about Jamie Muir on my thread about King Crimson drummers, you dork and why was Jamie on only one album?? King Crimson could have been interesting by using Bruford and Muir as an attack but no only one album will do.


Edited by ProgMetaller2112 - January 11 2013 at 01:59

ProgMetaller2112 wrote: I'm calling him that because he made a comment about Jamie Muir

And you will remind me about that until my decease and will read this comment on my funeral speech.

Dayvenkirq wrote: ^ Then don't call him Jamie Muir. It makes no sense.

why not he reminded me of that time, he should take it as a compliment


Edited by ProgMetaller2112 - January 11 2013 at 02:16

Atavachron wrote: I wonder how many phrases Tony Banks has 'borrowed' from any number of sources during his career--  I think it's more than once

name some I wanna hear about them

ProgMetaller2112 wrote: Atavachron wrote: I wonder how many phrases Tony Banks has 'borrowed' from any number of sources during his career--  I think it's more than once name some I wanna hear about them

Bach Fugues, Vivaldi .. you name it.   The guy was a composer, that's what composers do; they bring together bits & pieces of music that for all practical purposes already exist, combine it with their own creations, and voilà, you have a varied, complex piece.   Whether or not it's any good is a matter of taste.   Banks was very, very good at it.   So was Keith Emerson.

HarbouringTheSoul wrote: What a strange argument. Yes, Led Zeppelin plagiarized on numerous occasion. But that doesn't mean that all of their music is plagiarism, it doesn't mean their music sucks, and it certainly doesn't mean Led Zeppelin is not music. You can dislike Led Zeppelin. You can even say they suck. But don't try to rationalize it with silly arguments like that.

I was joking they don't suck just not my cup of tea, there's too much "baby" in their lyrics and I find it somewhat overused and not that good

^ Not sure, but I have noticed the 'Six Notes or Less' rule in musical propriety and plagiarism has given rise to some shrewd poaching of popular themes by certain big corporations;  I hear John Williams lifted regularly during those corporate logo flashes before and after films, other composer too like Danny Elfman.

harmonium.ro wrote: lazland wrote: BaldJean wrote: sure, and why not? Led Zeppeling took the blues and did progress it. look at a song like "Since I've Been Loving You" from their third album; that is progressive blues  Yep, couldn't agree more. Not only that I agree, but I think that In My Time Of Dyin' is an even (much) more progressive blues. I'd even stand for the "prog-blues" descriptor in its case.

Sumdeus wrote: I never understood how people can try to fault anyone for 'plagiarizing' when it comes to blues based music...

All cutural evolvment is based of what may be called 'plagiarizing'.
It is impossible listning to music, without carrying inspiration into your own creations, and it not a bad thing.
And im sure it no more evident in blues than in any other genre, every track with a drumset, is basicly inspired by african drumming.
As there was very Little drumming in traditional European music.